[Help Thread] Puzzle Choice Thread

Which 5x5 should I use?

Hi Guys!

I need help with my 5x5. I am going to a competition on October 11 and I am joining 3x3, 3x3 OH, 5x5, and mabey pyraminx. I have been useing shengshou and v cube 5x5. The shengshou turn very well but is get's stuck and it's hard to go fast on, and the v cube is very stiff. should i wing it with the shegshou, try to loosen up the v cube by solving it all the time, or get another 5x5? If so witch 5x5 should i get? Also, I know this will sound like a newbie question but, what happens when you get a DNF?

P.S. If i should get a new cube, which one should I use to practice right now?

Thanks guys your life-savers!
 
First, this should be in the One Answer Question thread, just for future reference. Now regarding your question, personally i would use your shengshou, but tension and lube it. If you get a DNF, it is eliminated from your avg5. BUT if you 2 DNF's in an average, your whole average will be a DNF.
 
Keep practicing with the Shengshou. You WILL get better at not locking up as you keep practicing. Plus, the cube will continue to break in. I use a Shengshou that is broken in, tensioned fairly tight, and lubricated, but not modded at all, and I don't have problems with lockups at all.

Tighten your cube. The lockups that are due to the cube, and not due to bad turning, will decrease.
 
Need Help

Cow124 said:
I am a speed cuber who averages around 57 seconds (I just learnt Intuitive F2L, 2-Look OLL and 2-Look PLL). I have a year old Ghost Hand (Internally damaged, but still better than storebought). I have been cubing for 2 years. I cannot decide between: Alpha V, DaYan GuHong V2, DaYan ZhanChi, FangShi ShuangRen II, MoYu AoLong, MoYu WeiLong II and a ShengShou Aurora. You can recommend another cube also. I also want it to be available at speedcubeshop.com
.
Click to expand...
Hello, I have only got one reply which is to get a Weilong, I want more answers.
 
Cow124 said:
I am a speed cuber who averages around 57 seconds (I just learnt Intuitive F2L, 2-Look OLL and 2-Look PLL). I have a year old Ghost Hand (Internally damaged, but still better than storebought). I have been cubing for 2 years. I cannot decide between: Alpha V, DaYan GuHong V2, DaYan ZhanChi, FangShi ShuangRen II, MoYu AoLong, MoYu WeiLong II and a ShengShou Aurora. You can recommend another cube also. I also want it to be available at speedcubeshop.com.
Click to expand...

Hi. I recently came your route and after some months of practice I am averaging 21-24. Your question has no simple answer, it all depends on your preferences, turning style... but I have bought a lot of those cubes this year so, I can tell you this:

Dayan Zhanchi: the stickered version is quite good but surpassed by Moyu and YJ new cubes. the stickerless version has a very different feeling and I would not recommend it, it is far too uncontrollable for your/my speed. Also, both of them pop once in a while, but all the others below don't (unless I explicitly say otherwise).

Fangshi: it is not bad but it is not as good as other options. It feels very light in the hand (if you like that) but tends to catch a bit. Good thing: it is quite silent.

AoLong: I got a V1 and I get A LOT of corner twists (I like somewhat loose tensions, but even after tensioning it a bit more, still corner-twists like crazy). It is fast and controllable and has amazing corner-cutting, so it doesn't force you to be accurate while turning, which can be good or bad, depending :) I don't like it's bubbly feeling and rounded edges so, after a while I changed it for another one (see below). If you still like it, everybody recommends to get a V2.

Weilong II: great cube but a bit fast for me, I have it in a drawer for the time when I get to sub-20 territory and have much more accurate turning. Then I think it will be my main. It does not corner-twist at all and has a much more "squarey" feeling so I prefer it to the Aolong (just a matter of personal taste).

ShengShou Aurora: very good cube, good overall feeling, quite fast, almost no corner-twists (but some) but I make mistakes at times because it tends to slide and turn in unintended ways / axes if not accurate. Also very sensitive to good tensioning and lubing. Don't tension it too tight or you will lose a lot of corner-cutting and without proper lube it does not corner-cut at all but well lubed it can be a very nice cube ...still not quite the best.

The others you have mentioned I cannot tell but I have tried others you don't mention:

Moyu HuangYing: Surprisingly good. Very noisy and with clicky-clacky feeling but it stays perfectly square during solves, which I love. It is really fast and forces accurate turning. It was my main for some time. Problem: it's got open corners and I sometimes hurt a nail by getting my finger accidentally inside the cube.

YJ Sulong: Also good and dirt cheap, more silent than most cubes (not as much as the FhangShi) but a bit "sticky" and slow unless very well lubed and even then not as fast as others. Not a bad cube at all but not the best either in my opinion.

YJ Chilong: Improvement over the Sulong. Fast (but not as much as Weilong), squarey and a perfect mix between the Sulong and the Huangying. Result: A great cube for intermediate cubers and my current main. I have done like 5000 solves with it and it's still great. With a bit of lube it is just fantastic but be careful not to lube it too much or it will be difficult to control. Bad thing: stickers are bad, I will have to change them soon, I have hurt my finger twice by having the border of a sticker under my nail 'cos the stickers are too hard and tend to peel and chip. But this should not keep you from trying it.

There are others, like the HuangYing v2 (LiYing, I think it's called) that people say is better than the HuangYing, so it must be great as well but I have not tried it... yet :)

Regarding availability on SCS I cannot tell. You'll have to check by yourself ;-)

Hope this helps!
 
Last edited:
mafergut said:
Hi. I recently came your route and after some months of practice I am averaging 21-24. Your question has no simple answer, it all depends on your preferences, turning style... but I have bought a lot of those cubes this year so, I can tell you this:

Dayan Zhanchi: the stickered version is quite good but surpassed by Moyu and YJ new cubes. the stickerless version has a very different feeling and I would not recommend it, it is far too uncontrollable for your/my speed. Also, both of them pop once in a while, but all the others below don't (unless I explicitly say otherwise).

Fangshi: it is not bad but it is not as good as other options. It feels very light in the hand (if you like that) but tends to catch a bit. Good thing: it is quite silent.

AoLong: I got a V1 and I get A LOT of corner twists (I like somewhat loose tensions, but even after tensioning it a bit more, still corner-twists like crazy). It is fast and controllable and has amazing corner-cutting, so it doesn't force you to be accurate while turning, which can be good or bad, depending :) I don't like it's bubbly feeling and rounded edges so, after a while I changed it for another one (see below). If you still like it, everybody recommends to get a V2.

Weilong II: great cube but a bit fast for me, I have it in a drawer for the time when I get to sub-20 territory and have much more accurate turning. Then I think it will be my main. It does not corner-twist at all and has a much more "squarey" feeling so I prefer it to the Aolong (just a matter of personal taste).

ShengShou Aurora: very good cube, good overall feeling, quite fast, almost no corner-twists (but some) but I make mistakes at times because it tends to slide and turn in unintended ways / axes if not accurate. Also very sensitive to good tensioning and lubing. Don't tension it too tight or you will lose a lot of corner-cutting and without proper lube it does not corner-cut at all but well lubed it can be a very nice cube ...still not quite the best.

The others you have mentioned I cannot tell but I have tried others you don't mention:

Moyu HuangYing: Surprisingly good. Very noisy and with clicky-clacky feeling but it stays perfectly square during solves, which I love. It is really fast and forces accurate turning. It was my main for some time. Problem: it's got open corners and I sometimes hurt a nail by getting my finger accidentally inside the cube.

YJ Sulong: Also good and dirt cheap, more silent than most cubes (not as much as the FhangShi) but a bit "sticky" and slow unless very well lubed and even then not as fast as others. Not a bad cube at all but not the best either in my opinion.

YJ Chilong: Improvement over the Sulong. Fast (but not as much as Weilong), squarey and a perfect mix between the Sulong and the Huangying. Result: A great cube for intermediate cubers and my current main. I have done like 5000 solves with it and it's still great. With a bit of lube it is just fantastic but be careful not to lube it too much or it will be difficult to control. Bad thing: stickers are bad, I will have to change them soon, I have hurt my finger twice by having the border of a sticker under my nail 'cos the stickers are too hard and tend to peel and chip. But this should not keep you from trying it.

There are others, like the HuangYing v2 (LiYing, I think it's called) that people say is better than the HuangYing, so it must be great as well but I have not tried it... yet :)

Regarding availability on SCS I cannot tell. You'll have to check by yourself ;-)

Hope this helps!
Click to expand...

No comment on the YuLong?
 
mafergut said:
Hi. I recently came your route and after some months of practice I am averaging 21-24. Your question has no simple answer, it all depends on your preferences, turning style... but I have bought a lot of those cubes this year so, I can tell you this:

Dayan Zhanchi: the stickered version is quite good but surpassed by Moyu and YJ new cubes. the stickerless version has a very different feeling and I would not recommend it, it is far too uncontrollable for your/my speed. Also, both of them pop once in a while, but all the others below don't (unless I explicitly say otherwise).

Fangshi: it is not bad but it is not as good as other options. It feels very light in the hand (if you like that) but tends to catch a bit. Good thing: it is quite silent.

AoLong: I got a V1 and I get A LOT of corner twists (I like somewhat loose tensions, but even after tensioning it a bit more, still corner-twists like crazy). It is fast and controllable and has amazing corner-cutting, so it doesn't force you to be accurate while turning, which can be good or bad, depending :) I don't like it's bubbly feeling and rounded edges so, after a while I changed it for another one (see below). If you still like it, everybody recommends to get a V2.

Weilong II: great cube but a bit fast for me, I have it in a drawer for the time when I get to sub-20 territory and have much more accurate turning. Then I think it will be my main. It does not corner-twist at all and has a much more "squarey" feeling so I prefer it to the Aolong (just a matter of personal taste).

ShengShou Aurora: very good cube, good overall feeling, quite fast, almost no corner-twists (but some) but I make mistakes at times because it tends to slide and turn in unintended ways / axes if not accurate. Also very sensitive to good tensioning and lubing. Don't tension it too tight or you will lose a lot of corner-cutting and without proper lube it does not corner-cut at all but well lubed it can be a very nice cube ...still not quite the best.

The others you have mentioned I cannot tell but I have tried others you don't mention:

Moyu HuangYing: Surprisingly good. Very noisy and with clicky-clacky feeling but it stays perfectly square during solves, which I love. It is really fast and forces accurate turning. It was my main for some time. Problem: it's got open corners and I sometimes hurt a nail by getting my finger accidentally inside the cube.

YJ Sulong: Also good and dirt cheap, more silent than most cubes (not as much as the FhangShi) but a bit "sticky" and slow unless very well lubed and even then not as fast as others. Not a bad cube at all but not the best either in my opinion.

YJ Chilong: Improvement over the Sulong. Fast (but not as much as Weilong), squarey and a perfect mix between the Sulong and the Huangying. Result: A great cube for intermediate cubers and my current main. I have done like 5000 solves with it and it's still great. With a bit of lube it is just fantastic but be careful not to lube it too much or it will be difficult to control. Bad thing: stickers are bad, I will have to change them soon, I have hurt my finger twice by having the border of a sticker under my nail 'cos the stickers are too hard and tend to peel and chip. But this should not keep you from trying it.

There are others, like the HuangYing v2 (LiYing, I think it's called) that people say is better than the HuangYing, so it must be great as well but I have not tried it... yet :)

Regarding availability on SCS I cannot tell. You'll have to check by yourself ;-)

Hope this helps!
Click to expand...
I am only 57 seconds (or whatever average I have) because my F2L and Cross is slow (Look-Ahead Problems (I spend like 20 seconds looking at my F2L trying to find pairs). I need something that will last for long (unlike my Ghost Hand which lasted for a year) and is fast, but controllable. The information really helped though. I am not fast enough to get an Alpha V Feng, nor am I slow enough for a (my) Ghost Hand or a storebought. I would not like a lot of lock ups (my ghost hand loves those). Edge popping is not a big issue for me. According to the description, I think I am either getting a Weilong, Aolong or a Fangshi. If this info (reply) makes a difference, post! That is what a forum's about.
 
I used a stickerless Yulong as my main for a while. It has a lovely feel and I'd recommend it to anyone solving slower than 30s. Cheap too. I plan to buy some in bulk to give to friends' kids to get them interested in solving.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

cranberryjuice
Puzzle Choice Help- 2x2, pyraminx, and 4x4
Replies
11
Views
1,553
cranberryjuice
cranberryjuice
Tony Fisher
My Twisty Puzzle quiz - 20 multiple choice questions
Replies
0
Views
588
Tony Fisher
Tony Fisher
A
One Puzzle. One Ukulele.
Replies
0
Views
14
akiemr19
A
Jteddy
Speedsliding 2026
Replies
8
Views
194
pi=3.14
pi=3.14
Jteddy
Scramble Generator For Sliding Puzzles?
Replies
0
Views
57
Jteddy
Jteddy
Back
Top