• Welcome to the Speedsolving.com, home of the web's largest puzzle community!
    You are currently viewing our forum as a guest which gives you limited access to join discussions and access our other features.

    Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community of 35,000+ people from around the world today!

    If you are already a member, simply login to hide this message and begin participating in the community!

Changes to the Weekly Competition website

OreKehStrah

Member
Joined
May 24, 2019
Messages
550
ok I didn't know that.
I like the orbit swapping aspect as long as we don't have to worry about the forced turns
Yeah jumbling just refers to scrambling in a way that the center pieces swap orbits. What we want is this, since it makes the solve more interesting and enjoyable. Cube shape is the part where forced turns are an issue. I got my Sub-1:30 jumbling with jumbled cube shape and then stopped lol.
 

thomas.sch

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2018
Messages
18
Suggestion: For curvy copter scrambles, could you put jumbling moves in parentheses? It makes scrambling so much easier to keep track of and do those moves. I found how nice it was after using the scrambles here: https://extraevents.org/events/curvycopter/training#
Excellent suggestion! At the moment I copy and paste the curvy scrambles to Word with a big letter size and then I identify the Jumbles and make linebreaks by hand!

Another curvy copter note, it has been discussed that the best regulations for scrambling might be to jumble it, but not shape shift it due to bandaging and forcing moves, causing lots of issues and complications.
Here I disagree. The shape shifting part is the exciting and special part of the curvy copter.

Also, this has probably been mentioned, but an image of scrambles at least on some events would be awesome :)
That would be fine for every event. If the traffic is the problem you can generate the images on the server an make links to pop ups. Then the image is only delivered if a cuber needs it.

But I think a the moment there is no curvy copter scrambler available that generates pictures of the "end state"! All few scramblers that I know show the picture befor shape shifting (like the one you posted with the [verify] tag in the scramble).

At the moment I check my scrambles of the "important" events (important in my opinion) also by coping the scramble to another page (e.g. cuberider).
 

Mike Hughey

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Jun 7, 2007
Messages
10,482
Location
Indianapolis
WCA
2007HUGH01
YouTube
Visit Channel
I would just like to state that I am one person who enjoys trying to get to cubeshape for curvy copter. I think it is a nice puzzle to try to be able to get to cubeshape "cleanly" (without any even partially forcing moves), and while it feels like a goal that is entirely achievable, I'm not really there yet. Sometimes I do solves where I just don't worry about how long it takes so that I can try to go completely without forcing moves, and it takes many minutes to get to cubeshape. I think it is a very interesting part of the puzzle. (It is not surprising that I enjoy this part of the solve; I also really enjoy solving truly scrambled Magic and Master Magic puzzles, and would love a competition event which involved unscrambling scrambled Magics and Master Magics, if only a scrambler could be built for that.)

However, that being said, I recognize clearly that it is not very practical for competitions, and especially not for official competitions, since forcing moves are so easy to do on curvy copter. I can see where the practical thing to do, certainly for any official competition, would be to do jumbling moves but keep it in cubeshape. As for here, I wouldn't make any changes without the usual end-of-year polling process, but I could see considering that change if community opinion were overwhelming in that direction.

As for displaying the jumbling moves, I've had the intention for quite some time of eventually having optional display modes for various scrambles, and one of these would be for curvy copter. The idea would be that the scrambles would be identical positions, but given in different notation. For curvy copter, I would probably add the parentheses as one option, and use some of the shortcut move notation as another option. Also, for 15 puzzle, for instance, there would be an option to just give the final position, for people with magnetic versions of the puzzle. This is something I still hope to do as one of the next improvements, but right now I'm rather busy so it might be a few more months before I can get to it,.
 
Top