Rate your cubes! (survey)

Rubik's Storebrought (my only cube & it's very nice :D)
Smoothness/Speed:8
Lockup Resistance:6
Cutting Corners:7
Pop Resistance:9
Quietness:7
Reliability:5
Overall:7
 
Type A core and centers with Rubik's Storebought pieces, siliconed to the point where it took weeks to dry out:

Smoothness/Speed: 8. I have it set to the point where you can feel the corners click over edges when they pass.
Lockup Resistance: 9. Never does, but when I start speeding, slices snag on the center.
Cutting Corners: 9. Cuts reasonable size misalignments, and it corrects them FAST. Don't even need to snap your wrist.
Pop Resistance: 9. It sometimes pops when the tightness undoes itself.
Quietness: 8. The lube has dried, and you also hear the cubies scrape against cube dust. Idk why I haven't cleaned all that out yet.
Reliability: 9. I can trust this thing to take 4 foot drops. But, of course, there's always that possibility of somthing bad happening.
Overall: 10. This is my competition cube and it's stood by me in the times of good and bad averages.
 
eastsheen 5x5 black
Smoothness/speed 9
Lockup Resistance 5
Cutting Corners 2
Pop Resistance 7
Quietness 10 (when Lubricated Properly)
Reliability 6 If you go too fast, then it can pop and not caught quickly enough you can have an explosion (fixable)
Overall 8 It is the only 5x5 I have
 
Rubik DIY core and centers with Rubik's Storebought pieces.

Smoothness/Speed: 7. It's not a super fast cube, but I admit it's decent.
Lock-Up Resistance: 5. It's got quite a few problems with lock-ups.
Cutting Corners: 7. I'd guess around 25-28 degrees.
Pop Resistance: 8. I virtually never have pops.
Quietness: 8. Pretty darn quiet, but there's still some noise.
Reliability: 7. I can trust it to get me a handful of good times, but I'd prefer my storebought that I've done a whole load of **** to.
Overall: 7. I like it as a cube and all, but I don't really know if I could go to a competition with it.

I'm kinda too lazy to review my other cubes. :fp
 
3x3x3 Storebought (newly silicon'd):
Smoothness/Speed:7
Lockup Resistance:4
Cutting Corners:6
Pop Resistance:8
Quietness:4
Reliability:7
Overall:6

4x4x4 Rubik's Revenge (Pre-lube/Post-lube)
Smoothness/Speed:2/6
Lockup Resistance:1/5
Cutting Corners:0/2
Pop Resistance:2/0 (pops more w/ lube)
Quietness:7/9
Reliability:3/3
Overall:2/4

Eastsheen 4x4x4 (Pre-lube/post-lube)
Smoothness/Speed:8/10
Lockup Resistance:5/5
Cutting Corners:2/2
Pop Resistance:10/10
Quietness:6/9
Reliability:9/9
Overall:7/9

7x7x7 V-cube (Pre-lube/Post-lube)
Smoothness/Speed:6/7
Lockup Resistance:8/9
Cutting Corners:8/9
Pop Resistance:4/7
Quietness:6/9
Reliability:5/7
Overall:7/8
 
Dian Sheng no:333
Smoothness/Speed:9
Lockup Resistance:4
Cutting Corners:2
Pop Resistance:7
Quietness:2
Reliability:5
Overall:5

Rubik's Storebought
Smoothness/Speed:5
Lockup Resistance:1
Cutting Corners:3
Pop Resistance:10
Quietness:7
Reliability:8
Overall:6.5
 
Rubik's Ice

Smoothness/Speed: 3
Lockup Resistance: 2
Cutting Corners: 0
Pop Resistance: -5
Quietness: 6
Reliability: -10 (It pops every time you try to solve it, and breaks easily.)
Overall: Less than 0

I can't find anything good about this cube. It just sucks.
 
I've collected all the ratings so far into a spreadsheet and calculated some averages. The aggregated statistics have been added to the initial post. Stats have only been posted for puzzles with 4 or more ratings.

If you're unhappy with how a puzzle is rated, or would like a puzzle to appear in the list, please add your own ratings and the list will be updated...
 
Eastsheen 2x2

Smoothness/Speed: 8
Lockup Resistance: 6
Cutting Corners: 4
Pop Resistance: 10 (Never had a pop)
Quietness: 9
Reliability: 10
Overall: 9

Cube 4 You DIY Transparent Black (Seems to be different plastic than regular DIY)

Smoothness/Speed: 8
Lockup Resistance: 8
Cutting Corners: 7
Pop Resistance: 7
Quietness: 5
Reliability: 7
Overall: 8.5


Those are the only two cubes I'm packing, and my friend has my 2x2...
 
RETOOLED TYPE C DIY

Smoothness/Speed: 10
Lockup Resistance: 6
Cutting Corners: 8
Pop Resistance: 8
Quietness: 5
Reliability: 9
Overall: 9
 
It's funny how old type A scored less than storebought. >_>


Old type A - bad cube.. slow and sticky. petroleum jelly killed it. But it
Overall: 4
DIY Type A (white)
Overall:8
Modded Old Type A
Overall: 9
Type A
overall: 2
Old Type A
Overall: 9.5
Old type A
Overall: 8.5

Lol, yea. Type-A really polarises opinion. It's like Marmite, either you love it or you hate it..
 
It's funny how old type A scored less than storebought. >_>


Old type A - bad cube.. slow and sticky. petroleum jelly killed it. But it
Overall: 4
DIY Type A (white)
Overall:8
Modded Old Type A
Overall: 9
Type A
overall: 2
Old Type A
Overall: 9.5
Old type A
Overall: 8.5

Lol, yea. Type-A really polarises opinion. It's like Marmite, either you love it or you hate it..

Hope I will, once I get mine, lol.
 
JSK – Japanese Speedcubing Kit

I asked my mom to pick up a couple of these for me, mostly for collector’s sake – one stayed in the package, the other is out and played with. After conversion, you’re looking at around $30 CDN/USD, so value-wise, you can do much, much better.

Here’s what $30 gets you: a 3x3x3 pre-labeled with PET/PP stickers with the Japanese colour scheme (ie: the ones with layer of plastic that peels off after an hour or two of active use) with removable caps and adjustable screws; a small tube of lubricant; two small screwdrivers – one Phillips head for adjusting the screws and one flat-head for removing the caps; a display stand (woo!); and a detailed instruction sheet complete with algorithms, some of which may be new to you.

Immediately out of the package, it is extremely stiff, even after adjustment. It’s only after a few drops of lubricant that it becomes workable. Within the first two hours of use, there’s nothing that really sets it apart from store-bought cubes. The cube still needs a solid breaking-in as it’s prone to lockups and does not cut corners particularly well, especially when compared to a freshly assembled and lubed DIY, although it improves after a few days of use. It also turns better with Jig-A-Loo, as opposed to the packed-in tube of lubricant.

On the plus side, the faces turn wicked fast and M2 turns are great and it doesn’t pop. This might change after a few years of heavy use, however.

Much preferred to a flat-centered Studio Cube, but for the price, you can buy a handful of DIYs.

Smoothness/speed: 10
Lockup resistance: 5
Cutting corners: 6
Pop resistance: 8
Quietness: 3
Reliability: 5

Average: 6.2

Mefferts 4x4x4 (white plastic, tiled)

Compared to the Eastsheen and Rubik’s versions, this version wins hands-down. The tiles make the cube significantly larger, which is not great for small hands (for which the ES may be preferable).

Does not have any of the lockup problems that the Rubik’s retooled 4x4x4 has (especially lockups on aligned faces and pops) and can even cut corners to an extent (at least better than then Eastsheen). I would prefer if a stickered version of this cube was available, but there is the option of popping off the tiles and smoothing the surface down.

Much of this also applies to the QJ version (aka “Clefferts”, or Cloned Mefferts), with a few key differences. The QJ version turns much, MUCH faster, but by extension is more difficult to control (ie: you may experience more lockups due to misalignment), and it’s much noisier. It’s also almost half the price ($10.79 for a QJ vs. $18 for a Mefferts).

Smoothness/speed: 9
Lockup resistance: 8
Cutting corners: 7
Pop resistance: 10
Quietness: 9
Reliability: 9

Average: 8.6
 
C4U (JSK clone i guess) Speedcube

When i took it out of that nice little box it came in it turned way better then all of my other cubes (OFC i had to mess it up by loosening it) so now its on medium loose right now, it only pops if i go too crazy, the stickers are peeling (i didnt put Cubesmith stickers on them, i dont have any), and its lubed with, Grease, ya. I stuck grease on that thing, it works.

Smoothness/Speed: Its smooth but it doesnt turn as fast as some of the other cubes, so.. about a 7
Lockup resistance: 8
Cutting Corners: 9
Pop Resistance: 7 (Its loose)
Quietness: 8
Reliability: Im not sure what "reliability" is. butt its pretty reliable to me. so 9
Overall: About 8.6
 
Mini Diansheng!
So Cute!
Smoothness/Speed:10
Lockup Resistance:7.5
Cutting Corners:8.5
Pop Resistance:5.7
Quietness:4.3
Reliability:10 (I beat my PB with this little cutey! And It's never popped on me during a solve, though it's happened when I was just messing around with it.)
Overall:9.2 (May seem a little high, but I'm in love with this cube. :D)

Comments:
BUY IT. :p
 
Back
Top