SpeedStacks WCA Timer

And I would think that buttons, with having a mechanical component to them as opposed to the current state, would be much more prone to breakage, especially with high use and people who hit the timers hard.
You might think, but my spacebar is still ok after 4 years :) I'd still strongly support buttons as they might sole more problems than they would create.

Yes, bu you don't hit your keyboard as hard as some timers are hit. I have a hard time believing Speed Stacks wouldn't have looked into buttons in the first place. I think either buttons are really prone to breakage because of either the force, or a combination of force and hitting them from the side (still from the top, but hitting them off-center).

Hopefully the timer engineers will give us feedback and cost on our choices so that we don't request something and then having timers that cost $50 and have serious flaws that result in them not working after two competitions.
 
Laptop-keyboard type buttons would be cool. They are hard to break (I've hit my keyboard pretty hard while playing rhythm games and I've never broken a key), cheap, and easy to take apart, clean, and replace, and their sensitivity is constant over time. They aren't TOO sensitive, though - you do have to apply a small amount of force to activate them, so you probably would decrease the frequency of people accidentally stopping the timer by placing their hands/arms on it.
 
I liked the old stackmat because you couldn't drop the cube on the timer, causing it to turn. This doesn't need to be overthought. I would just vote for a simple timer more resembling the old stackmats, that solves the problem of extra turns and has better integration with the displays.
 
An idea to prevent .02 solves.


Code:
+---------------------+
|  ##  sensor 2   ##  |
|                     |
|        mat          |
|                     |
|  ##  sensor 1   ##  |
+---------------------+
Start timer with both hands on sensor 1.

Stop timer with both hands on sensor 2.

People would fail so bad on that.

OMG its not stopping!!!
Oh wait, I have to do the other sensor.
 
An idea to prevent .02 solves.


Code:
+---------------------+
|  ##  sensor 2   ##  |
|                     |
|        mat          |
|                     |
|  ##  sensor 1   ##  |
+---------------------+
Start timer with both hands on sensor 1.

Stop timer with both hands on sensor 2.

People would fail so bad on that.

OMG its not stopping!!!
Oh wait, I have to do the other sensor.
they'd get used to it.

and if we went from 2 to 1, they'd put their arms accidnetally on 1 after starting :/
 
Maybe an option that you would have to put one hand on one side of the timer while you are cubing onehanded?
 
I have a few Stackmat timers and I think they're perfect for a mass-produced product.

I have a version that came with shielded power and reset buttons and that's a pretty good improvement to stop accidental button presses (although you can mod your own by glueing on appropriately-sized plastic rings).

I hadn't noticed the bias in the distribution of the hundredths, but then I haven't dealt with so many results, so if there's an improvement in accuracy possible then that would be very good indeed.

USB or Bluetooth interface? Way, way, way expensive! Plus useless for competition unless we need a PC to be wired to every competitor table!

For home use I've investigated a simple hack for non-competition timers where the current readout of the LCD is made available on a PC via a cheap Arduino interface but this still works out more costly than a competition timer! Still no access to the memory of the timer either!

Moreover, if you have a PC available then just use the PC as a timer!
 
it's ridiculous that SpeedStacks wants $64.31 for its timer (€39 + €6 shipping) . Being small would also be nice because we could more easily take it with us everywhere.

I agree with this, it should be low cost and small. In the past portability didn't really mater much, you cant cup stack in the car, so regardless of the buttons it should be small and very lightweight
 
Well, Stefan, we can't ever expect a good timer to get anywhere near the cost of a crummy stopwatch (for competition timers, we do need a mat, two buttons or touch sensors, and some LEDs) although I do agree that $60 is a bit much for an essential tool. I think that making the mat smaller (it doesn't need to be bigger than half a sheet of newspaper, really, except for maybe magic events) would take off a lot of the cost - not only would you save on the mat itself, but the whole thing would fit in a much smaller bag and would thus cost far less to ship. The timer itself should be very cheap, though... I guess <$10 should be possible, but I don't know for sure.

Of course, you'd also save even more money by having the whole thing produced in and shipped out of China with no middleman... but that would mean cutting out SpeedStacks entirely and I'm not sure if that would be a good decision.
 
Maybe have the timer built into the mat? Like the timer is a little lcd at the top of the mat and beeps when inspection is over. The whole mat has pressure sensitive sensors on it and it'll detect when you drop the cube and when your hands hit the mat.
----------------
|-----LCD------|
|--Whole mat--|
|---Pressure---|
|-- Sensitive---|
----------------

Say goodbye to portability..

Defiantly
definately

My eyes!!

As for the timer, I definitely (that's d-e-f-i-n-i-t-e-l-y, people!) want it to be more accurate. I'd always had a hunch that some hundredths were more common than others (and I'm sure that the stackers want that too.) I'm against the idea of starting the timer with buttons because they'd have to make the buttons huge for us to be able to use them. Something that's less sensitive than what we have right now but not too hard to use like a button is what we need. Also, rather than having protectors over the power and reset buttons (which don't really work because the cube's corner can still hit the buttons) maybe we can have the timers require you to press the button twice or hold the button for a set amount of time before it resets/turns off.

I'd like to see a timer that provides scrambles, but calculating averages is too much. Say you have a DNF or a +2 during an average. You'll need to press a DNF or a +2 button, which would have no use at all except when you're doing averages (I don't see how you'd need any of that when you're just solving casually). Also, what if you accidentally start the timer before you're ready? Won't you also need a 'discard' button? The average function will just put 3 pretty much useless buttons on the timer, which we don't need. If you want to know your averages, figure them out yourself. I just don't see how we can have a timer that gives you your averages without it being very difficult to make.

I like the idea of the timer also giving optional preinspection if the amount of time given is adjustable. Instead of the timer starting right away when inspection is done like many computer timers do, I'd like to hear a beep that signals for you to put your cube down and hands on the timer, so you can start when you're ready.

I'm also all for raising the 10-minute limit to 30 minutes, or maybe having the limit be adjustable so that when you're doing big-cubes BLD you can raise the limit, and when you're done lower it back to 10 minutes so that you don't waste battery by accidentally leaving it running for 30 minutes. AA or AAA batteries would be nice too.

That's just my 2 cents.

Well this is embarrassing. I blame spell check.
 
Last edited:
USB or Bluetooth interface? Way, way, way expensive! Plus useless for competition unless we need a PC to be wired to every competitor table!

For home use I've investigated a simple hack for non-competition timers where the current readout of the LCD is made available on a PC via a cheap Arduino interface but this still works out more costly than a competition timer! Still no access to the memory of the timer either!

Moreover, if you have a PC available then just use the PC as a timer!

Hi Everybody! Any news on this?!
I think the problem is that competition display is extremely expensive and when we organize a competition we always have few displays however we have enough timers.
It would be a good way to have laptops as displays.
 
USB or Bluetooth interface? Way, way, way expensive! Plus useless for competition unless we need a PC to be wired to every competitor table!

For home use I've investigated a simple hack for non-competition timers where the current readout of the LCD is made available on a PC via a cheap Arduino interface but this still works out more costly than a competition timer! Still no access to the memory of the timer either!

Moreover, if you have a PC available then just use the PC as a timer!

Hi Everybody! Any news on this?!
I think the problem is that competition display is extremely expensive and when we organize a competition we always have few displays however we have enough timers.
It would be a good way to have laptops as displays.
Why did you dig up a year old thread? You should have just posted a new one
 
Why did you dig up a year old thread? You should have just posted a new one

I disagree completely. This is an example of a very good bump. Posting a new thread would be a much worse way to handle this, since the context would be lost. This way, everyone can see the context and remember it. And the question was a good one. (Unfortunately, I don't have an answer.)

And also, it's only a half-year-old thread, not a year old.
 
It's an honest bump. I kinda want some news on this too.
 
Of course, you'd also save even more money by having the whole thing produced in and shipped out of China with no middleman... but that would mean cutting out SpeedStacks entirely and I'm not sure if that would be a good decision.
I was thinking about that. It seems like a good idea, the first part at least.
 
Back
Top