SpeedStacks WCA Timer

I do see a problem though with people talking about a timer that tracks pre-inspection. If the timer is to do this, then this mode must be able to be toggled off for BLD events. This increases costs too. I think a pre-inspection mode should not be included for this reason. The only exception to this would be if the costs/budget for the timer allow for it (and it is worth it).

Chris
Also, just in the short time I've been competing the inspection rules changed. And if Ton got his way it would go away completely and we'd all need new timers. ;)
 
Well if the timer stopped when the puzzle hit the mat (the mat would have to be pressure sensitive), not your hands hitting the timer, and the timer started when your puzzle came off the mat, I think that could fix a lot of problems. We wouldn't need a stopwatch because if you don't take the puzzle off before 15 seconds is up, you get DNF'd. This would also fix the problem with having to wait for the green light. Considering cost I'm not sure if it would work, but it would get rid of the problem with the starting with and ending with 2 hand patent that speedstacks has, and many others as well.
 
2 - What will happen to current times/records? Will they be erased? I don't think it's "fair" to compare times with different equipment.

Two major things have happened since the WCA started recording times:

1. Switch from Gen 1 to Gen 2 stackmat timers
2. New starting procedures

Is it "fair" to compare times recorded under all those different conditions? Maybe not, but ideally the new timers shouldn't change things too much so that the times can still be comparable.

The Gen 1 timers could not be stopped before 0.32 seconds had passed. This meant no timer malfunctions of 0.0x. If the timer was accidentally stopped before the solve was finished it's clearly the competitor's fault. It's not like anything can be solved in under 0.32 anyway (when the Magic WR reaches 0.4 or 0.5, then we'll talk)

Gen 2 timers have very sensitive touch pads. Basically they're heat sensitive; we've had some old timers where the sensors can be triggered by just hovering your hand over the pad without actually touching it. This can result in timer malfunctions. Do we need the pads to be that sensitive? Most people slam the timer pretty hard when they finish. I don't think we'd lose much by having a button or a pressure sensitive pad like the Gen 1 timers.
 
Last edited:
I think it is unfair to hand out DNFs for stoping the timer accidentally...

In case anyone else is wondering about this, here is why we do that:

A6b) It is the competitor's responsibility that the timer is stopped correctly.

...I think it should have two modes, one of them, for most events, that will not stop the timer until it is over one second, another, for things like magic master magic and maybe even pyraminx, Where sub 1's would be allowed.

I think this is making the equipment costs too high.

I do see a problem though with people talking about a timer that tracks pre-inspection. If the timer is to do this, then this mode must be able to be toggled off for BLD events. This increases costs too. I think a pre-inspection mode should not be included for this reason. The only exception to this would be if the costs/budget for the timer allow for it (and it is worth it).

Chris

What's wrong with making a blind person put their hands on the timer, pick them up, put them back down, and then pick them up and take the cover off the cube? I can't see throwing away such a valuable and useful feature that can easily be worked around.
 
I think it should look cooler than the blue, maybe some cube colored squares on it, or at least the black and green like the one for cup stacking.

Maybe there could be a square drawn on the mat to place the cube before solving.

This is an good example of what I meant by cube colored. http://bedzine.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/08/rubik-cube-clock.jpg

Some people might find that too flamboyant, what do you think?
 
Last edited:
If there were some sort of 'custom' casing or whatnot that'd be cool.
Something like supporting whatever method they do, like 'Rebels use Salvia,' or perhaps like 'Do the sexy move' with some sort of custom casing, but this really isn't needed.

Also, of course, built-in averaging would be really nice for home use, as would USB connection.
 
If there were some sort of 'custom' casing or whatnot that'd be cool.
Something like supporting whatever method they do, like 'Rebels use Salvia,' or perhaps like 'Do the sexy move' with some sort of custom casing, but this really isn't needed.

Also, of course, built-in averaging would be really nice for home use, as would USB connection.

definitely USB.
 
Last edited:
If there were some sort of 'custom' casing or whatnot that'd be cool.
Something like supporting whatever method they do, like 'Rebels use Salvia,' or perhaps like 'Do the sexy move' with some sort of custom casing, but this really isn't needed.

Also, of course, built-in averaging would be really nice for home use, as would USB connection.

wouldn't this be too over-the-top? the cost would be too much with custom casings. I'd rather make my own "Roux Rebellion" sticker and stick on my timer. ;)

Like you said it's not needed.

The things that I'd like to see on this timer would be
- pads that aren't too sensitive...
- larger display
- USB connection and and built in averaging for both 5 and 12 solves
 
If there were some sort of 'custom' casing or whatnot that'd be cool.
Something like supporting whatever method they do, like 'Rebels use Salvia,' or perhaps like 'Do the sexy move' with some sort of custom casing, but this really isn't needed.

A fully white case would be nice. Then, you could use permanent markers to write anything you want. ;)

Things I'd like to see:
-Averages
-Make the overall timer size a tad smaller
 
Last edited:
Besides what has already been suggested, I'm all for a smaller mat. Something along the lines of this:

http://i32.tinypic.com/dzfbwk.jpg (my blindfold is not purple!)

For cupstacking, it has a purpose, but for cubing, we don't need that much room for the mat (maaaybe for OVER 9000 multi).
 
What about attachable modules? They could be available as separate accessories (and some could even come with the stackmat). You could have:

- a module that tracks times and calculates averages
- a light for cubing in the dark
- scramble generator (with the ability to add different puzzles and scrambles through some sort of software on a computer)
- something to make the sensor pads larger for people who need it
[that's all I can think of for now]

Being able to take apart and rearrange the modules and the stackmat parts would be cool as well. You could have two sensors together and a timer at the side, the timer at the side with a light module in between the pads, and so on. I got this idea from the LG Versa phone, which has attachable modules, such as a keyboard or a D-pad for gaming.

EDIT: And of course, corrected time distribution and precision. I just didn't mention it because lots of other people already have.
 
Last edited:
In general, it is best to not worry about the cost implications in a discussion like this. If you're not a Stackmat engineer, it is very hard to know what the price implications of different features really are. Leave it to the pros to figure that stuff out. Our expertise is what cubers really want.

It is also not good for creativity to self censor ideas. Some times you have an idea that solves a problem, but costs too much, but someone else can come up with a variation that is simpler. That would not have happened had you not mentioned the first unbaked idea.

The end result of this discussion is probably a wish list of features, that Stackmats will then look at and evaluate how feasible they are, and then this reiterates several times.
 
I think the timing distribution is a big issue that needs to be fixed. Speed Stacks advertises "Stackma accuracy," and I think it is their responsibility to back up that claim now. I won't consider the timer fixed until the accuracy is actually corrected (and not just using a hack, like random rounding to even the distribution).

Timer: "precision time" and "accurately time your stack in hundreths [sic] of a second."
StackPod: "displaying every second with StackMat accuracy."

I like the idea of incorporating inspection. However, for this feature, and others like it, I'd like to emphasize the option to change any settings, like the value of "15" seconds.

Also, official computer interaction would be nice. Perhaps this could even be used to transfer settings to the timer (so that you can just plug it in, and transfer current WCA settings on). I would also lobby for an open implementation (with an API?) of the Stackmat signals. It's worth it for them to let interested cubers develop software that interacts with the Stackmat timer.
 
It's disturbing to see "2: 3.45" rather than "2:03.45". This is a programming mistake in the chip. It's small details like this that affect the perceived quality of a product.

I would like to save more than just 3 times (with timestamps). Maybe a person could choose a puzzle type from a list and attach it with the time.

As someone said before, it might be nice to display the last 12 solves, with best and worst in parentheses, and the average of the remaining 10.

My top issue is that it needs to record over 10 minutes. I think 59:59.99 would be a nice limit.
 
Back
Top