Calvin's Puzzles - SQ1 & DLitwin SQ2 Testing Thread!

[youtubehd]1awNyzOQCrI[/youtubehd]

I tried to take this video as seriously as I could, honestly.


TL;DW:
- noticeably lighter than Mf8 v2 and Cubetwist
- U/D easier to turn
- the slice feels smooth, almost like it's been sanded
- not amazing out of the box, it definitely needs something like Maru lube or Lubix, but it will be amazing after that
- pshew-pshew approved
 
All right, just got mine in the mail. Here are my impressions:

First of all, as Sarah noted in her video, it's very light. The feel and sound of the turning are a bit different, so perhaps it's a different type of plastic? The U/D layers are also probably the best I've felt right out of the box: normally these are the hardest part to break in. Also, I like the color of the stickers: bright blue, plenty of difference between red and orange, and very nice silver foil logos. The mechanism is basically the same as the MF8 v1, which means the turning resistance is basically zero, but it doesn't cut corners at all. With a bit of practice, I think I can get much faster with it, but because I've been using v2s for a while, my turning isn't accurate enough to keep me from locking up.

All in all, it seems like a solid puzzle. It's definitely an improvement from the MF8 v1, and I'm looking forward to seeing what sort of times I can get once I'm used to it.

I'm curious, though: was there a reason you used the ball mechanism for your Square-2, but decided to stick with the old mech for Square-1? I know some solvers aren't too keen on the MF8 v2, but I quite like them, and I'd definitely welcome more options like that.
 
I got my Square-2 today. Some negatives: The pieces come off of the "ball" track too easily with just a little upward force. The caps also come off very easily, though that's not necessarily new. There's a lot of clicking going on during U/D moves as each piece crosses the slice gap. Finally, there's one type of misalignment that happens frequently, displayed in the linked picture: http://imgur.com/cWAjo
These may have to do more with the puzzle itself than Calvin's design, but I can't say for sure since I haven't tried any others (e.g. Cubetwist or self-made ones).
Overall, it's a fun puzzle to play with and is good for a collection, but not great for speedsolving.
 
Back
Top