IRNjuggle28
Member
I've heard nothing but negative things about the way the accomplishment section of the forum was changed. So, let's have a vote. Here are my thoughts, which I posted in the accomplishment thread before it was closed.
Having a bunch of tiny accomplishment threads instead of this will ruin it. The biggest reason I like this thread is that there's constant activity on it. Someone is always acheiving something and posting it here. Making a bunch of smaller, more specific threads will dilute the "people accomplishing stuff" effect that this thread has. If you guys really feel like the forum needs to be changed in this way, I'm not going to ***** about it too much, but please let this thread and the accomplishment subforum coexist, rather than replacing this thread with that.
The reason cited for replacing this thread with the accomplishment subforum was to separate accomplishments by puzzle. Other than a spat about people posting slidy puzzle accomplishments and not using spoilers even when they were obviously needed, I have never heard someone complain about the accomplishment thread not being separated by puzzle. I like that all puzzles can be posted about in here. I like seeing accomplishments on various puzzles, some of which I've never tried or have no interest in personally. I love the variety. Having threads for specific puzzles is a great idea, but again, I don't think it's a replacement for this thread.
In the future, moderators and admins, if you want to change the forum like this, perhaps have the forum members vote on it beforehand?
EDIT: whoever put this in help & support, please move it back to accomplishments. The entire point of this is to gauge what the people who use the accomplishment thread a lot think, and that area of the forum is much more active. Less people will see this thread over here.
Having a bunch of tiny accomplishment threads instead of this will ruin it. The biggest reason I like this thread is that there's constant activity on it. Someone is always acheiving something and posting it here. Making a bunch of smaller, more specific threads will dilute the "people accomplishing stuff" effect that this thread has. If you guys really feel like the forum needs to be changed in this way, I'm not going to ***** about it too much, but please let this thread and the accomplishment subforum coexist, rather than replacing this thread with that.
The reason cited for replacing this thread with the accomplishment subforum was to separate accomplishments by puzzle. Other than a spat about people posting slidy puzzle accomplishments and not using spoilers even when they were obviously needed, I have never heard someone complain about the accomplishment thread not being separated by puzzle. I like that all puzzles can be posted about in here. I like seeing accomplishments on various puzzles, some of which I've never tried or have no interest in personally. I love the variety. Having threads for specific puzzles is a great idea, but again, I don't think it's a replacement for this thread.
In the future, moderators and admins, if you want to change the forum like this, perhaps have the forum members vote on it beforehand?
EDIT: whoever put this in help & support, please move it back to accomplishments. The entire point of this is to gauge what the people who use the accomplishment thread a lot think, and that area of the forum is much more active. Less people will see this thread over here.
Last edited: