what are your opinions for what I should get

Rubixcubematt

Veteran
Joined
Jul 23, 2008
Messages
793
Location
in a house
YouTube
Visit Channel
Hey everyone, im going to make an order soon from 9spuzzles,it will consist of a megaminx, pyraminx and something else.that something else i cant decide, it is between a magic or a sq-1.

this is the magic :http://www.9spuzzles.com/index.php?gOo=goods_details.dwt&goodsid=105&productname=

this is the sq-1: http://www.9spuzzles.com/index.php?gOo=goods_details.dwt&goodsid=87&productname=

i would like to get a square-1 just because it looks interesting and fun to play with, but i also want the magic because it also looks fun and interesting, and i would like it for the unnoficial comp im melbourne coming up, but it may not come in time because im going to choose the SAL shipping option, but it may very well come in time as well. please give me your views on what i should get, i will apreciate it a lot. thanks in advance.

P.S. i know some of you will say "its personal prefference", but i would like to know which of the two you enjoy more.
 
magic is best.

fast solving
easy to learn
not time consuming
More people are interested and can learn easily

Though maybe you should just get both
 
i think in the long term you'd get more fun out of a square-1... learning to solve it would be more fun than a magic.

if you get a magic also, the probability of breaking it before your comp is quite high. or just breaking it anyway, then i bet you'll wish you got the square-1?
 
But the square 1's only performing algs and I don't find that very fun......

I haven't played with a magic before, but it seems like something that you would mess around with if you were bored.
 
ty everyone. i guess i will probably get a sq-1. i could probably learn how to do the magic (in theory) the night b4 the comp, and then use tims magic to compete with (if he lets me :p)
 
I don't know why people think the magic is fun or interesting or impressive.

If you just do it fast, it's like, OK, you changed the shape in one second, whatever.
If they take it and scramble it, you will look like an idiot spending 5 min to get it back to the correct form. It's just annoying and not really a puzzle by current competition rules.
The sq1 really impresses people, even if you can only solve it in 2 min. People call it the crazier Rubik's cube.
 
But the square 1's only performing algs and I don't find that very fun......

So figure out how to solve it on your own. I guarantee you that's a lot more fun than the magic can ever be.

Don't be to negative about the Magic. It is a nice puzzle and playing with it (making shapes) is a lot of fun. It is also a great toy to use as a pickup-tool ;) because you can easily explain it to others and they instantly like it
 
meh, my parents took me to hamleys (big toy shop in london) when i was about 8 and said "you can have anything you like". i chose a magic, which i obviously broke in the first day because i didn't know what to do with it. boy did i wish i'd chosen something else...

moral of the story: get the sq-1
 
Back
Top