How would the perfect cube timer work?

I also think that the perfect timer would start when your start moving the cube and not when you let go of the timer. I can think of a few ways to do this i.e. possibly having a small sensor in the cube itself that connects wirelessly to a timer and when it detects movement up to a half turn then the timer starts (might be a bit costly) or more realistically a weigh sensor timer that starts when you lift the timer off of the weight sensor and stops when the cube hits the sensor again. This would make up for the false starts, make our times more accurate and solve the problem for people who don't pick up the cube well all in one swoop.

As to the issue of current world records, I believe almost all of the modern ones are on video so if we really wanted to we could watch them closely and remeasure them from the time the cube left the table, but I think it would be maybe .2 seconds off, maybe less because the curent world record holders are really quick with this.

I also think that if we created something like the second type of weighted timer, then at least 1 thousand would be sold for competitions worldwide and fierce competitors at least, probably more.
 
Having the timer start when you take the cube off the mat would be problematic when you consider inspection. Would the judges all have to remember to put the cube off the mat before inspection? Or would the timer specifically start on the second pick-up, which would mean that if you put the cube down during inspection you can't pick it back up? Would there be an issue of the timer not starting if there is another puzzle sitting on the mat, or if someone is leaning on it? And so on.
 
Having the timer start when you take the cube off the mat would be problematic when you consider inspection. Would the judges all have to remember to put the cube off the mat before inspection? Or would the timer specifically start on the second pick-up, which would mean that if you put the cube down during inspection you can't pick it back up? Would there be an issue of the timer not starting if there is another puzzle sitting on the mat, or if someone is leaning on it? And so on.

I think this problem can be solved by having hand sensors AND a weighted mat, but as one product. Only with both hands are on the hand sensors and the cube is on the weighted mat that the timer can start and stop.
 
The weight thing exists, it's on the official Rubik's website. Problem is that people drop cubes and use the surface to solve, like KIRJAVA and megaminx people.

You could make the weight sensor only say 1 foot by 1 foot and you could then use any of the space around the timer for OH table stuff and just put it on the timer when your done. Dropping you cube is, IMO, less common than misstarts or other issues with the current system and thus not much of an issue. You are more likely to accidentally stop or not start the timer than this. Also, if the weight sensor was only 1 foot by 1 foot then you move back from that space while solving if you thought you would drop the cube.

Having the timer start when you take the cube off the mat would be problematic when you consider inspection. Would the judges all have to remember to put the cube off the mat before inspection? Or would the timer specifically start on the second pick-up, which would mean that if you put the cube down during inspection you can't pick it back up? Would there be an issue of the timer not starting if there is another puzzle sitting on the mat, or if someone is leaning on it? And so on.

The inspection timing could be done as it is currently- you would just give them 15 seconds. have them put down their cube, then they would reset the timer(you would program the timer to calculate the weight upon resetting and prepare to start when the weight is released.) and take the cube off when they are ready to go. As to the leaning and other cubes on the mat, again, we would make the sensitive area rather small so people could put cubes off to the side if they wanted. and the only way you are going to stop the timer by leaning is if you solve the cube face down on the mat(imagine that the wieght timer area is 6-12 inches from the cuber, or 1/4th of the way into the mat). Also it will be the responsibility of the cuber not to do this. If they do then it is their fault considering all of the other precautions taken (size of weight area, distance from cuber, etc.).

I really think a timer like this would work. Sure we would have to relearn how to use the timer, but that is part of progress.

"I think this problem can be solved by having hand sensors AND a weighted mat, but as one product. Only with both hands are on the hand sensors and the cube is on the weighted mat that the timer can start and stop."

Interesting, there are two problems with this though, first, cost and second the whole idea of the weight sensor it to eliminate the awkward picking up of the cube and the timer not starting, so using it would be sort of pointless.

We could add a time limit to stop the timer i.e. the timer measures when the weight has been put onto it (this is for after the cube has been picked up and you are solving and accidentally drop the cube) so say at 15 seconds and then waits 3 seconds before it stops the timer, so at 18 seconds. If you were done with your solve and just waited the extra 3 seconds then the timer would stop and read 15 seconds as you time. If, however, you had accidentally dropped your cube and you pick it up within 3 seconds then the timer does not stop and it continues until you finish your solve and put the cube down for 3 seconds.
 
Last edited:
Nice idea, then they would just have to get the cube on the weight sensor and pick it up before the 15 seconds were up.

Nono. Normal Speedstacks timer.
Add: 0.001 precision, safety net for times (can't stop before 0.2), inspection button which counts down from 15 on the timer. (Hands must be on timer before hitting zero, or else +2/DNF is instated.) Inspection and reset buttons strategically places for easy retrieval but improbable accidental pressing. Time goes up to 60 minutes.
Take-aways: Saved times, blinking lights (perhaps the lights could just stay on?)
 
Add: 0.001 precision, safety net for times (can't stop before 0.2), inspection button which counts down from 15 on the timer. (Hands must be on timer before hitting zero, or else +2/DNF is instated.) Inspection and reset buttons strategically places for easy retrieval but improbable accidental pressing. Time goes up to 60 minutes.
Take-aways: Saved times, blinking lights (perhaps the lights could just stay on?)

So...when can I buy it? :)
 
uses more common batterys (probably AAA for size) instead of the stupid flat things I can't find anywhere

one question of one of my exams was coming up with ideas for a new product and most of these ideas can probably be done.
 
Last edited:
It would be great if you could be able to save multiple times and multiple sessions (eg one for 3x3, one for 4x4 etc)
Also, you could connect it to your computer, iPod, or phone.
It could connect to the internet (would probably cost way too much though) to teach you algorithms and other internet stuff.
Give you each scramble for each solve.
 
uses more common batterys (probably AAA for size) instead of the stupid flat things I can't find anywhere

Took me 9.47 seconds to find thousands of offers:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/sch/i.html?_f....l1313&_nkw=cr+2032&_sacat=See-All-Categories

The weight thing exists, it's on the official Rubik's website.

Can't find it there anymore, but you're probably thinking of this:
http://www.mission-designs.com/timer/
That doesn't use weight but light (the journal explains why).
 
Concerning the weight panel, I'm afraid you're missing the key advantage the current timers use.... you could put the cube back on the panel while still doing an AUF.. too much room for cheating.
 
I don't think the weight timer would work...

1foot x 1foot? I think that's kinda big, no? Also as some people already said, it would make things awkward for those who place the cube/megaminx/whatever on the table for some moves.

It's better that we keep the current procedure, since it's not that hard and it's easily standardisable (does that exist?)

For the timer, some realistic improvements would be:
- Being able to give every 0.01 (and not having gaps like it has today)
- Lights don't blink, just stay on/off.
- Get rid of the "red...wait...green, go". I don't know why they put it there in the first place. Make it just light up the red, then turn it off and turn the green on while running.
- Don't stop before 0.2 or something like that.

I personally don't have a problem with hitting the reset button by accident, and don't see a good solution as a place to put it...maybe on the bottom part, where it says STACKMAT.

For the 0.001 (or 0.0001 O_O), maybe it would be good, but current records would be in conflict...
 
Concerning the weight panel, I'm afraid you're missing the key advantage the current timers use.... you could put the cube back on the panel while still doing an AUF.. too much room for cheating.

This would be up to the judges to determine. This wouldn't be that hard, the competitor would just be required to drop the cube and put their hands on the side of the timer. If they didn't, DNF.
 
Because it's open source and runs on mass-produced SoC's (System on a Chip). It would allow for connecting to WCA's site and downloading records. It would allow for reduced software development time, and thus make it cheaper. I could go on for a while.

EDIT:
Like what conn said.
It would be great if you could be able to save multiple times and multiple sessions (eg one for 3x3, one for 4x4 etc)
Also, you could connect it to your computer, iPod, or phone.
It could connect to the internet (would probably cost way too much though) to teach you algorithms and other internet stuff.
Give you each scramble for each solve.
Conn, very low end Android devices sell for less than $50, it'd be a bit expensive, but not ridiculous.
 
Back
Top