siwoo
Veteran
Cubing is awesome, but not so much when we are in public such as libraries or school classrooms, since we have to be mindful of others. (or just say f**k it and reverse corner cut with a gan 14 but i'm not THAT confident)
So, over the last year or so, I have tried many different 3x3's in public and school to see which one was the best in terms of quietness and feel.
Now, the decision to rank them was a bit tough. Some of these turn quieter at low TPS, but some are more consistent and less in high TPS.
So I have forth 3 criteria:
1) Sub 2 TPS (wrist turn speed)
2) Sub 6 TPS (normal/competition turning speed)
3) Overall (a mix of both)
SUB 2 TPS:
Dayan Tengyun V1
- It's pretty much dead silent. This was my go-to travel cube for a long time. If you're turning really slowly, its almost completely silent. While it gets snappy at higher TPS, if you are doing one turn at a time, this is the one for you. Dampen the hell out of it with Lubicle Silk or Strefa Kostek's XMT-10 and you're good to go.
Dayan Zhanchi Pro M
- This cube was recommended to me by @Bingus Ringus McDingus and it did not disappoint. It's very good at low TPS. It took a while to figure out the most quiet setup, but I landed on using the weakest edge magnet settings with a low tension.
GAN 356 Maglev
- This one was shocking. I got this not because it was quiet but because I liked the feel of older GAN cubes, and this was similar. However, once setup with 4-2 settings and used silk, XMT-10, fz-calm, and DNM-37, I ended up liking this a lot for doing really slow turns. Like the tengyun, it's very snappy at high TPS but I think this one is really good for slow turning, as it barely makes noise when <2 TPS.
SUB 6 TPS:
X-Man Tornado V2
- This one was the winner of Basilio Noris's quietest cube study and it did not disappoint. Even though its a smidge louder than the GAN 356 Maglev at sub 2 tps, you can interchange the two. Additionally, unlike the Tengy V1 and the GAN 356 Maglev, it stays eerily consistent at higher TPS. This was setup at lowest magnet settings and with FZ-Calm and XMT-10. Corner cutting also doesn't make a sound, putting this one at the top.This one is my favorite right now, but it might just be due to recency bias as I got this cube last week (It's out of stock everywhere, so I had to get it from mastercubestore in Denmark)
Dayan Zhanchi Pro M
- Its second silver medal thus far and well deserved. It stays consistent, although less consistent than the TV2. Also, corner cutting is a little loud.
Dayan Tengyun V1
- This was my go-to cube for over 2 years when traveling or going to public. As it goes higher in TPS, the cube makes more noise and gets a LOT more snappy. Also, if you reverse corner cut by accident at this TPS, you may as well jump off a cliff. The reverse corner cutting is LOUD on this thing. If you reverse corner cut, good luck to you lmao. You will be judged forever by everybody.
Overall:
X-Man Tornado V2
- The consistency is unmatched. In Basilio Noris's own words when I asked him for advice, "I'd still say that the Tornado v2 is noticeably less noisy. It still has a winning combo of not too noisy and low pitch, which feel more silent than other cubes that might be just a low in dB, but due to higher pitch feel noisier." In addition, you can get close to your actual 3x3 times with this!
Dayan Tengyun V1
- Except for the reverse corner cutting and snappiness at high TPS, this one's a winner.
Dayan Zhanchi Pro M
- Consistent at high TPS and quiet, although far less enjoyable than its alternatives.
Other honorable mentions: Haitun Waverider, WRM 2021, Tornado V3
What are your thoughts? Are there any cubes I slept on?
So, over the last year or so, I have tried many different 3x3's in public and school to see which one was the best in terms of quietness and feel.
Now, the decision to rank them was a bit tough. Some of these turn quieter at low TPS, but some are more consistent and less in high TPS.
So I have forth 3 criteria:
1) Sub 2 TPS (wrist turn speed)
2) Sub 6 TPS (normal/competition turning speed)
3) Overall (a mix of both)
SUB 2 TPS:
- It's pretty much dead silent. This was my go-to travel cube for a long time. If you're turning really slowly, its almost completely silent. While it gets snappy at higher TPS, if you are doing one turn at a time, this is the one for you. Dampen the hell out of it with Lubicle Silk or Strefa Kostek's XMT-10 and you're good to go.
- This cube was recommended to me by @Bingus Ringus McDingus and it did not disappoint. It's very good at low TPS. It took a while to figure out the most quiet setup, but I landed on using the weakest edge magnet settings with a low tension.
- This one was shocking. I got this not because it was quiet but because I liked the feel of older GAN cubes, and this was similar. However, once setup with 4-2 settings and used silk, XMT-10, fz-calm, and DNM-37, I ended up liking this a lot for doing really slow turns. Like the tengyun, it's very snappy at high TPS but I think this one is really good for slow turning, as it barely makes noise when <2 TPS.
SUB 6 TPS:
- This one was the winner of Basilio Noris's quietest cube study and it did not disappoint. Even though its a smidge louder than the GAN 356 Maglev at sub 2 tps, you can interchange the two. Additionally, unlike the Tengy V1 and the GAN 356 Maglev, it stays eerily consistent at higher TPS. This was setup at lowest magnet settings and with FZ-Calm and XMT-10. Corner cutting also doesn't make a sound, putting this one at the top.This one is my favorite right now, but it might just be due to recency bias as I got this cube last week (It's out of stock everywhere, so I had to get it from mastercubestore in Denmark)
- Its second silver medal thus far and well deserved. It stays consistent, although less consistent than the TV2. Also, corner cutting is a little loud.
- This was my go-to cube for over 2 years when traveling or going to public. As it goes higher in TPS, the cube makes more noise and gets a LOT more snappy. Also, if you reverse corner cut by accident at this TPS, you may as well jump off a cliff. The reverse corner cutting is LOUD on this thing. If you reverse corner cut, good luck to you lmao. You will be judged forever by everybody.
Overall:
- The consistency is unmatched. In Basilio Noris's own words when I asked him for advice, "I'd still say that the Tornado v2 is noticeably less noisy. It still has a winning combo of not too noisy and low pitch, which feel more silent than other cubes that might be just a low in dB, but due to higher pitch feel noisier." In addition, you can get close to your actual 3x3 times with this!
- Except for the reverse corner cutting and snappiness at high TPS, this one's a winner.
- Consistent at high TPS and quiet, although far less enjoyable than its alternatives.
Other honorable mentions: Haitun Waverider, WRM 2021, Tornado V3
What are your thoughts? Are there any cubes I slept on?