How would the perfect cube timer work?

coinman

Veteran
Joined
Jun 28, 2008
Messages
409
Location
Stockholm, Sweden.
WCA ID
2005GUST02
I have some time been thinking about how the perfect cube timer would work.

My idea is to contact a manufacturer to see if it’s possible to get them to make a timer for our needs. Preferably those that manufacture Stackmat timers so that the new fits directly with the displays we use today.

A prerequisite for them to be interested, of course, that there is a sufficient market. The question is if it is not sold more Sackmat Timers to cubers today than to those who stacks cups.

If a better timer that is more suited to the sport of speed cubing would come on the market, how many do you think was going to sell? I guess thousands per year.

What I would propose is as follows:
1. The timer should go to stop at every hundred part of a second.
2. There will be no way to stop it at times under the first four tenths of a second. This is to avoid the timer to stop at 0.03 and the like of that. None of the puzzle we are competing in today will ever be possible to solve under four-tenths.
3. It should not be shut down automatically before 60 minutes. This is so that it can also be used for multi-blind and big blind.
4. And why not have buttons that can calculate averages of 12 or of 5? If it would not make timers to expensive maybe they can make the screen bigger and add the ability for it to generate scrambles. Personally, I think it would be useful if it can generate scrambles and calculate averages. As, for example, you can sit on the train and do a average. (This is not to be used in competitions for average calculations.)
5. To avoid hitting the reset and ON/OFF buttons by mistake put a small raised ring around the buttons.
6. Millisecond measurement?
 
Last edited:
I would say it need the ability to get every possible time, and also lasts for 60 minutes like you said. Apart from that, its fine. Maybe try and remove the timer malfunction thing?
 
QJ make timers, and as far as I know they market them solely to cubers, so it should be possible to get some company interested. We really could do with a more accurate timer.
 
I'd say a timer that went down to milliseconds would definitely be useful - just look at the 2x2 single WR. And also, the reset button should probably be moved to a place that is just as easy to get to, but is less likely to be pressed by accident.

However, I think having buttons to calculate averages would be unnecessary, and just make the timer more complicated and expensive. Most cubers use computer timers to calculate their averages when practicing at home (sometimes in combination with stackmats), as these also have scrambles and other features. These would be illogical to put in a timer like this with a small black and white screen. And it wouldn't work in competition, because one competitor will be switching between timers in an average.

This is a good thread idea though.
 
To avoid hitting the reset button by mistake one can put a small raised ring around the button (and of course around the ON/OFF button as well). I have seen that there are those who have already done this on their timers. I'll add this in my list.

And milliseconds, what do the rest of you think about this? If we are measuring time in milliseconds, we must also redo all the record lists.
 
I'm just going to answer the title of the thread. It would start as the 1st move is performed and stopped when the puzzle is solved whilst being accurate to 4 decimal places.
 
I'm just going to answer the title of the thread. It would start as the 1st move is performed and stopped when the puzzle is solved whilst being accurate to 4 decimal places.

Hmm, yes it would be great if it were possible to do so that they only measure the actual time it takes to solve the puzzle. But it's probably technically very difficult to implement and very expensive. Rather come with realistic proposals :)
 
I could almost guess that this had been a topic before. Most of the improvements I have suggested is also mentioned in the previous thread. It's two years since that thread was written, but we have not seen a new type of timer yet. Has anyone sent a proposal for improvements to the manufacturer?
When I get enough suggestions here, I thought to contact the manufacturer of Stackmat Timers, if no one else has already done this alredy.

I think I'll make one list of the most important improvements and one of the less important, but desirable improvements.
 
If you want a perfect timer for practicing you're basically going to eventually want features on par with software timers like CCT/qqTimer/Prisma: scramble generation, saving a session's worth of times, calculating averages, tracking +2s and DNFs, allowing for inspection, and so on. This is fun to think about, but it gets kind of silly when you really think about it.

As far as the best timer for competitions, to be realistic, I agree with much that has been said. What we really need (or at least what is different from the currently used timer) is:
- precision to 0.01 or even 0.001 of a second
- continues timing a single solve for at least an hour
- hard to reset or turn off by accident
- does not easily "malfunction" and stop too early, but can still time very short things (0.2-0.5 sec)
- perhaps less "flashy" (the blinking lights), but still easy to see whether it is on/timing or not
 
1. Precision: preferably 0.0001, but 0.001 would be fine.
2. Prevent accidental stopping below 0.25 seconds (The highest accidental stop I've ever seen is 0.20)
3. Runs Android, has enough storage to record AT LEAST 1,000,000 solves (and be expandable with a MicroSD card). This would be best with a color touchscreen, meaning you could scroll through and sort results.
4. Keeps track of times for any number of puzzles (names of puzzles input by user)
5. Keeps track of multiple users?
I could see such a device selling for under $50 (This is a COMPLETELY reasonable price for a very basic android device. See here.)
 
I think markthema3 already sort of mentioned this, but being able to plug it into something like an iPhone and have it record times, give scrambles, ect., is a great idea. It wouldn't take much, all it would take is an app that works with the timer, and some way to plug it into the timer.
 
I really think that all we need is a way to make yourself not hit the reset/OnOff button on accident, and a timer accurate to .001 of a second. This is %100 possible and would still be available for a cheap price (Well, $30 ain't cheap). Like come on, why can't you just write out your times on paper, then use a calculator to calculafy.
 
Back
Top