Noticed a very probable "copying" in GuHong's Mechanism

daniel0731ex

Master
Joined
Dec 10, 2008
Messages
2,294
So while people in the other thread are getting carried away arguing about irrevalent topics, I noticed a very suprising connection between the V-cube and the Guhong design....

Quoting from the post I made (which is being ignored completely) in the other thread:

I just realized...although the Guhong have no resemblence to the V-cube 3 at all, if you look at the big V-cubes as a reduced 3x3 cube
(as in, moving the outer layers only), the structure is very similar to the Guhong. Perhaps Verdes though the Guhong was a KO because of that?

PS: If you couldn't understand what I am saying, just look at your V-cube 5 or 7. If you glue all the small edge pieces into one single edge, and all centers into one big center, it becomes almost identical (except for some minor tweaks) to the Guhong if you could somehow make it proportional.

This is what I meant:

vqvsgh.png


You could clearly see the similar inverted-pyramid shaped center, the slanted circular path composed of the edges and center pieces, and not to mention the stalked corner that everyone knows.



A lot of you guys noticed the resemblence in the corner stalk of the Guhong, but then it just ends there. Because people were all distracted by the blizzare design of the V-cube 3, but never realized the similarity beyond that.


I think this is where Verdes sees the infringment of his patent; the conical structure is actually a very general concept, anyone with basic understanding of puzzle mechanisms could easily figure this out on their own. It is not right for Verdes to patent this general design in the first place.


But now I am wondering why is our dear Katt avoiding to reveal this information all along?
 
Last edited:
Copied or not, it's still no good to take it off the market if he doesn't plan on making one himself.
 
I would disagree. In the patent it clearly refers to that as a "cone". And we can see in the image that there is indeed a cone shape.
But if you look at the inside of a guhong, is there really a cone there? Sure, there is an indention because its not flat, but a cone? I don't see it. And if its not a cone, then its not copying the v-cube mechanism, because v-cube specifically patents the cone shape.
 
I would disagree. In the patent it clearly refers to that as a "cone". And we can see in the image that there is indeed a cone shape.
But if you look at the inside of a guhong, is there really a cone there? Sure, there is an indention because its not flat, but a cone? I don't see it. And if its not a cone, then its not copying the v-cube mechanism, because v-cube specifically patents the cone shape.

Yes, but that's just a play one word now. What I am trying to get across is that the concept is the same as the VCUBE design.
 
I'm not trying to play on the words or whatever, I just genuinely do not see this as copying the v-cube mechanism. Maybe I simply don't understand the v-cube patent very well (it is very complicated), but it just doesn't look to me like the inside of the guhong is similar to the inside of the v-cube.
 
Ya, I tried this already with the 5x5 and I still no. I feel that if you have to look this much for an infringement that you can barely notice in the product, it's probably not an infringement. There are probably other cubes out there that actually come closer to an infringement but they probably don't make as much money. Which, as has been noted by myself and many before, is the main, if not only, issue.
 
I can see a resemblance - definitely more of a resemblance than to the V-3 - but I don't think the GuHong is copied. I can easily see how the ideas of basing a 5x5 off an internal 3x3 and making a 3x3 with a 'smaller' 3x3 mech inside could have been developed independently, although I can also see how it could have been copied and then improved.

PS: Would a design that was borrowed from a different interpretation of a cube, and then significantly modified, still count as an infringement? I haven't read the full text of the patent but it looks like it is specifically giving designs for the various sizes.
 
Last edited:
Um, ok... Are you guys all suddenly saying it does look like a GuHong referring to the 5x5x5 or that 6x6x6? The latter looks pretty much like the V-3 drawings, so how does it look like the GuHong but the V-3 drawings don't?
 
Back
Top