Noticed a very probable "copying" in GuHong's Mechanism

Um, ok... Are you guys all suddenly saying it does look like a GuHong referring to the 5x5x5 or that 6x6x6? The latter looks pretty much like the V-3 drawings, so how does it look like the GuHong but the V-3 drawings don't?

I couldn't agree more with you (except if you added "I like peanutbutter") :)

I woul say that the modded v6 definitely looks like the V3, but not like the GuHong.
 
The Modded V6 definitely looks a lot like a GuHong, but I don't think it looks much like Figure 3.1 and Figure 3.2 of page 24 on the patent that izovire linked to in the previous thread (found here for ease of clicking to see the comparison). I think the corner actually looks a lot more like a 2x2 (Eastsheen, ShengShou) corner shell more than it does a GuHong. I haven't seent his full patent before, I've only seen the Figure 3 images. However, Figure 4 images do show some similarities, but those are for 3x3, not 4x4 (and I'm unsure if a claim can be made against different order of cubes, as I do not understand a lot about the specifics about patents).
 
Have you read any of the posts in the threads at all? Mr. Stefan clearly mentioned the cone early on.

Err, I guess not. People were all carried away with irrevalent stuff like proverty, world hunger, and Hitler. So I didn't bother to look at them...

I couldn't agree more with you (except if you added "I like peanutbutter") :)

I woul say that the modded v6 definitely looks like the V3, but not like the GuHong.

Because, it IS based on the V3. But that's not what I am talking about here, I'm referring to the outer layer of the V5.


The Modded V6 definitely looks a lot like a GuHong, but I don't think it looks much like Figure 3.1 and Figure 3.2 of page 24 on the patent that izovire linked to in the previous thread (found here for ease of clicking to see the comparison). I think the corner actually looks a lot more like a 2x2 (Eastsheen, ShengShou) corner shell more than it does a GuHong. I haven't seent his full patent before, I've only seen the Figure 3 images. However, Figure 4 images do show some similarities, but those are for 3x3, not 4x4 (and I'm unsure if a claim can be made against different order of cubes, as I do not understand a lot about the specifics about patents).

No, no, NO! First the Guhong does not look like the V3 at all. Second the modded V6 is exactly what the V3 looks like, wtf are you talking about?
 
No, no, NO! First the Guhong does not look like the V3 at all. Second the modded V6 is exactly what the V3 looks like, wtf are you talking about?

Confusing... So from the first post, the V5 looks like a guhong(by your reasoning). Many people have said that the V5 illustration in the first post looks like the modded V6 posted later on in the thread. So we can assume that your illustration is what the modded V6 would looks like but just not as large. But from your first statement in this quotation the guhong does not look like a V3. Even though from your second statement in this quotation, the V6 looks exactly like a V3. So the modded V6 looks like a V3 which looks nothing like a guhong but the modded V6 looks exactly like a guhong. So the guhong looks like a modded V6 which looks exactly like the V3 but the guhong does not looks like the V3. Furthermore, the V3 looks exactly like the modded V6 which looks like the guhong but the V3 does not look like the guhong even though it looks like the modded V6 which looks like the guhong.

Here's my illustration.
57833064.png
 
You don't know what "the V3" looks like (the patent drawings just show one possible implementation, and the actual official product has not been shown (built?) yet).

Well, the final product obviously would have minor tweaks to the details (like, for example the drawing of V-5's cross-section in the patent documentm showed that the "big center-piece" forms a perfect trapizoid, even though the final product have a flat edge at the very top), but the basic concept is still the same thing (assuming VCUBE is not trashing their patent and uses the conical design instead). The V3 will have the winged center and edge pieces inlaying into the corner piece.

The Guhong uses the conical structure to make maximum interior radius reduction possible (which you could see as a problem on the A4's fragile corner piece). V-cubes also uses the same concept for their big cubes.
 
Confusing... So from the first post, the V5 looks like a guhong(by your reasoning). Many people have said that the V5 illustration in the first post looks like the modded V6 posted later on in the thread. So we can assume that your illustration is what the modded V6 would looks like but just not as large. But from your first statement in this quotation the guhong does not look like a V3. Even though from your second statement in this quotation, the V6 looks exactly like a V3. So the modded V6 looks like a V3 which looks nothing like a guhong but the modded V6 looks exactly like a guhong. So the guhong looks like a modded V6 which looks exactly like the V3 but the guhong does not looks like the V3. Furthermore, the V3 looks exactly like the modded V6 which looks like the guhong but the V3 does not look like the guhong even though it looks like the modded V6 which looks like the guhong.

Here's my illustration.
57833064.png

big V6 ≡ V-cube 3
Guhong ≠ V3
V5 outer layer ≡ Guhong
 
I did not say the V3 looks like the GuHong, in fact I said they look quite different than the figure 3 images in the V-Cubes patent page(s). The GuHong looks so similar to the Modded V6 though. It's actually interesting that you brought that up, because I was going to take pictures for my previous post, but my camera was dead so it was charging, until now.

Here are the pictures, to me it looks quite a bit like that Modded V6, and it looks quite a bit different than page 24, Figure 3 images (of the link I included in my last post).
 
I did not say the V3 looks like the GuHong, in fact I said they look quite different than the figure 3 images in the V-Cubes patent page(s). The GuHong looks so similar to the Modded V6 though. It's actually interesting that you brought that up, because I was going to take pictures for my previous post, but my camera was dead so it was charging, until now.

Here are the pictures, to me it looks quite a bit like that Modded V6, and it looks quite a bit different than page 24, Figure 3 images (of the link I included in my last post).

Ok, sorry. What I am saying is that the modded V6 is like the V3 but not the Guhong.
 
Why do you say it is not like the GuHong? The corners have longer stems on the GuHong, and the edges in the modded V6 have a weird piece on each side of it, otherwise they look insanely similar (to me, anyhow). Did you take a look at the pictures I took of an inverted first layer? The pictures didn't come out as clear as I hoped, but I was hoping they'd be enough to show the similarities. I can try again if you want. Also, did you look at the link for the European Patent that izovire linked to, and reference the Figure 3 images? The Figure 4 images are actually pretty similar, and the Figure 5 are somewhat as well, which is why I specific Figure 3.
 
Last edited:
Why do you say it is not like the GuHong? The corners have longer stems on the GuHong, and the edges in the modded V6 have a weird piece on each side of it, otherwise they look insanely similar (to me, anyhow). Did you take a look at the pictures I took of an inverted first layer? The pictures didn't come out as clear as I hoped, but I was hoping they'd be enough to show the similarities. I can try again if you want. Also, did you look at the link for the European Patent that izovire linked to, and reference the Figure 3 images? The Figure 4 images are actually pretty similar, and the Figure 5 are somewhat as well, which is why I specific Figure 3.

:fp

the wings makes a huge difference, it's a completely different concept.

I am saying that the V6 picture shows the inner layer of the big cube, which bears the same concept as the V3, while the Guhong is rather similar to the outer layer of V-big cubes.

Guhong - outer layer
V3 - inner layer
 
Ok I changed my opinion now (on whether if Dayan copied VCUBE design or not). The conical structure is a very general concept, anyone with basic understanding of puzzle mechanisms could easily figure this out on their own. It is not right for Verdes to patent this general design in the first place.
 
Back
Top