SpeedStacks WCA Timer

In general, it is best to not worry about the cost implications in a discussion like this. If you're not a Stackmat engineer, it is very hard to know what the price implications of different features really are. Leave it to the pros to figure that stuff out. Our expertise is what cubers really want.

It is also not good for creativity to self censor ideas. Some times you have an idea that solves a problem, but costs too much, but someone else can come up with a variation that is simpler. That would not have happened had you not mentioned the first unbaked idea.

The end result of this discussion is probably a wish list of features, that Stackmats will then look at and evaluate how feasible they are, and then this reiterates several times.
Definitely sound logic.

An interesting side question would be: How much would you pay for a timer? Assuming that it had the majority of the main features *you* would like to see, regardless of what they are, what would you be willing to pay for it? Especially think about buying more than one, since I have one at home and one on my desk at work and I like that.

I don't really see me spending more than $35 or $40 for a timer. I think the $20 price point the current timer is at is a good one.

More on topic: I agree that official support for a computer interface would be really, really good. With an open API so we don't have to rely on SpeedStacks to support platforms like Linux.
 
Last edited:
Mat: Not quite as wide but a little "deeper." It is often a tight fit to get two mats side-by-side on many of the tables that we have used. The mats could also stand to be slightly thicker.

Timer: I like the idea of the usb interface. At the most basic level, this could simply dump times into a text file on a flash drive. It would be nice to also have the ability to connect to a pc. I will leave the dicussion of the possibilities on this to the experts. One additional thought on this: wouldn't it be great to have the ability to flash the (insert technical term here) or whatever it utilizes with a new firmware?

I hate that the timer does not have a true "off" setting. Please fix this... not that the simple time/date display drains that much juice, it's just annoying.

Perhaps there could be some modification to the general shape of the timer so that the competitor cannot touch the puzzle and both sensors at once. I would say that the sensors could just be placed further apart, but that would make the timer pretty large.

Tournament Display: Someone mentioned an external power supply. I don't see that we really need to make any changes to the display. It functions great already, and why spend money on new ones. I am planning to mod my display to run on external power soon... maybe even this afternoon. This should be a fairly cheap and very easy mod that most anyone can do themselves. If it works out ok, I will make a youtube vid explaining it.
 
All the caltech displays have already been modded to accept external power, so it's obviously a wanted feature.

A good speedcubing timer will have a big enough display to show it easily on video. Maybe use a bit bigger screen and numbers like the red ones on the display (but smaller). It would make it easier for judges standing/sitting off to the side to read the times as well.
 
- To avoid 0.02s, they could raise the minimum time threshold to 0.25 or something like that to avoid this problem.
- For longer events, it would be nice to see that 10 minute limit removed/raised.
- Moving the reset button so that it's not on the top would avoid more timing errors. It doesn't happen that often, but I have slammed my hand/cube onto the reset button accidently and erased my time.
- I know Tyson mentioned statistics as frills, but I would love to see avg5/12 on screen as well as USB connection.
- Backlighting the screen like on the glow-in-the-dark models would be nice for all models. If this were to happen though, coin batteries would need to go, as the power drains much faster on my glow-in-the-dark timer rather than my competition timer. It would be nice to see AA batteries used instead of coin batteries anyway, they're much more accessible.
 
To avoid 0.02s, they could raise the minimum time threshold to 0.25 or something like that to avoid this problem.
This would be bad for ball-in-cup. I like my idea of using buttons instead of pressure-sensitive pads better :)

It would be nice to see AA batteries used instead of coin batteries anyway, they're much more accessible.
Excellent idea.
 
The timers, not just the displays should accept external power. I would like the timers to be rechargeable like cameras or cell phones.
Also it would be nice to be able to save times onto a USB drive if it is plugged in.
I also agree with making it more durable, precise, and accurate.
The mat isn't so much of a deal, just bring your padding.
 
The top of my timer has small dents in it because the cube has slammed into it so harder to dent would be nice and the .02 thing I know has been brought up and definately that.
 
Personally, I would rather pick up the cube from the sides rather than the front. I think the new timer should be similar to the Gen 1 timers, in that, the touch pads are part of the timer and the display is not "". I think a pad the size that Swordsman Kirby suggested would be good, except it would have the small display on the bottom (with buttons and the like). I would also like larger, red numbers, for the display, and AA batteries as previously stated.
 
- Backlighting the screen like on the glow-in-the-dark models would be nice for all models. If this were to happen though, coin batteries would need to go, as the power drains much faster on my glow-in-the-dark timer rather than my competition timer. It would be nice to see AA batteries used instead of coin batteries anyway, they're much more accessible.

I can see why you'd want backlit for cupstacking. Glow-in-the-dark cups, and you're set. But for cubing, you need decent lighting to cube.
 
Competition Timer:
- Extend max time from 10min to 1hr
- Thinner and sleeker design
- Increase surface area of sensors
- Hardier surface
- Larger LCD that's closer to the top for easy viewing
- Durable buttons
- Move 2.5mm socket?

Personal Timer:
- Have preset formats to save Average/Best times per puzzle
- USB connector to upload data and to interface with a PC

Tim.
 
I can see why you'd want backlit for cupstacking. Glow-in-the-dark cups, and you're set. But for cubing, you need decent lighting to cube.

I find that the lighting needed to cube (especially just for practice) is lower than the light needed to easily read those liquid crystal displays.
 
it would be nice to hav etimers communicate with computers via bluetooth/usb but then theres the problem of ensuring the times go under the correct competitor
the giant mats arent neccesary either they barely fit on my desk
external power supply or AA/AAA batteries
a reset button thats more difficult to acidently press
 
I also think the timers should be significantly less sensitive. Ideally, they should never stop in under (say) 0.1 second, never stop when only one hand is there (even if the timer is well-used), and never turn off or reset because of hitting the table/timer hard when stopping it (I believe this fault is not always due to physically hitting the reset button).

I'd also like a larger or more obvious display (a small, relatively dim, red LED display would be nice, for the judges as well as for low-light situations). We don't need date/time, and I don't think it's really essential to have any kind of feature where PBs and averages can be stored/computed (if you need stuff computed or stored, you should just do it on your computer), so I wouldn't suggest adding that kind of stuff unless it can be done for no extra money (ha!). If you insist on having those kind of features, it would be nice to be able to buy a stripped-down version that's just a timer.

Few people here have mentioned this, but I think it's important that the timer have a pretty much equal distribution of times with respect to hundredths. That is, it should run on 100 Hz, not 60 Hz. This is important for any event that is sufficiently popular to have many ties in the single solve rankings (such as magic or even 3x3x3). Similarly I agree that the timer should go up to 60 minutes for the longer events.
 
Definitely a more durable surface. I would lol if the timer split in half when I dropped a puzzle on it. Maybe a mat that had a rubber coating for awesome non-slipperiness.
 
I see a problem with the timer keeping track of averages. At a lot of competitions, the same person will not use the same timer 5 times in a row. There often times are more cubers than timers, and even with 2 groups, people often will need to share.

I think the timer should be flat, like the Gen 1. It will make it harder to hit while solving.

It should be extended past 10 minutes. It seems like it would be easier to keep track of big cubes BLD on a stackmat rather than a stopwatch.
 
Back
Top