Should I get an 11x11 or 9x9 cube?

Status
Not open for further replies.
As far as I can tell, Verdes has never won a patent lawsuit in the US. If I'm wrong about this, please give me a link. Google is our buddy here.

It is not the job of consumers to determine which products infringe on which patents. (Note I use the word "infringe" not "illegal".) It is the job of the patent owner to enforce his patents. When the patent owner fails to do this, the only conclusion a consumer can make is that there is no patent infringement. Patents are complicated things and are difficult for people to understand. As consumers, we do not have, in general, the skills of determining whether a product is infinging or not. Hey, if we buy a purse that usually goes for $10,000 for only $20 we can be pretty sure we've bought an infringing item, but that's probably a trademark infringement, not a patent infringement like we're talking about here. These are complicated things determined by incredibly complicated trials that take many years.

I've read the Verdes patent. I own a Sheng Shou 7x7x7. I have read the Verdes patent carefully and I do not believe Verdes would be successful in an infringement claim against that puzzle. I don't own any larger cube so I can't comment on them. But if you are a lawyer and you read the Verdes patent, I think that you will agree with me that it is *not* a very broad patent. My opinion is that its scope is very narrow. If you don't understand how the "claims" in a patent work and you're worried about this, consult a patent attorney. Show him the patent. Pay him $500 and get an opinion on it. Share it with us.

From the point of view of a consumer in buying a large cube, it is silly to imagine that there is any risk in buying a large cube. If your large cube does turn out to violate a patent, what do you think the patent holder is going to do? Sue you? For what, about 15% of the price of the puzzle??? Even filing a lawsuit against you would cost far more than the amount that could be made by collecting on that lawsuit. You are completely safe in buying these puzzles. You are not a "deep pockets" target. If you think I'm wrong in this, google around and find an example of where a consumer spent $90 on a toy and then got into trouble for patent infringement. Go ahead. It's at least possible that there are some cases where consumers got into trouble for "trademark" infringement (where, for example, you buy a purse that is made to look like it was manufactured by a different company than the one that made it) , but I've never seen any and that's not what we're talking about here. Try googling "patent infringement against buyer" to find plenty of examples of this language in sales agreements for high dollar equipment but none of us have ever signed such an agreement when buying a toy over the internet.

In the unlikely event that the WCA decides to start a 9x9x9 puzzle competition you can be almost certain (based on previous experience) that they will not enforce 3rd party patents against prospective competitors. It's not their job. If Verdes feels that their patents are being infringed they can file the appropriate lawsuits. An individual who bought a cube is not going to be named in these lawsuits. If you think otherwise, please google around and find an example of where people were sued for buying an infringing toy.

I would really like to know more about this, please help me by googling for these examples of patent infringement by consumers.
Not proof, but my source: (scroll to the bottom)
http://www.twistypuzzles.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=15&t=16116&p=197346&hilit=trafficking#p197346
 
Last edited:
Thanks rubixwiz031, but what I'm looking for is a Court Opinion. Here's a sample "Judgement" on an infringement case:
http://www.med.uscourts.gov/Opinions/Hornby/1996/dbh_2-95cv415_wheela_v_longwood_doc01_dec.pdf

I know of no such judgement which involves Verdes. I'll keep looking, but I've got to get some homework done that is due tomorrow.

Yeah, that's just the expession of a personal opinion on the Twisty Puzzles website. I believe there are no links to any Verdes infringement court opinions because I believe they do not exist. And hey, I just expressed my own personal opinion (no infringement, at least for the 7x7x7) above. You don't need to assume either of us is correct because, as a consumer buying a cheap toy, you're under no risk whatsoever.

Ethically, if you can determine that a product infringes, you may convince yourself that you have a moral obligation to not buy it. Howevrer, you should consider the possibility that you do not understand the law deeply enough to determine whether or not that product infringes. If you're buying a Rolex (tm) watch for $50 you can make that determination pretty easily. With twisty puzzles it may not be so easy for you to make that determination. Going to law school and learning how to read Claims is going to be very expensive.
 
Last edited:
Ah, the age old V-cube/knockoff argument...
All I have to say about that is if Verdes doesn't want other companies to make knockoffs, he shouldn't build inferior (IMO) cubes and sell them for double the price. It's a no-brainer in my books

Lolwut12345 about the legality of owning a "knockoff" cube, don't worry about it. I own plenty of "knockoff" cubes and trust me.. Nobody cares.
As for which one to buy, I recommend the Shengshou 9X9. It's not quite the perfect cube that some reviewers have made it out to be, (again, IMO) but it is a very solid cube. As for the 11X11, it's cool to have as a head turner and a really long solve every once in a while, but it lacks a little bit on the build quality. Not saying that it's bad but I find that the alignment a major problem and it actually holds me back on a solve having to realign every row when I want to change axis' when turning. And whether I tighten or loosen the screws, the inside layers always seem to have quite a loose feeling. I think this loose center thing is the main cause for lockups as the pieces always get hung up on each other since they're not nice and tight (like a Shengshou). Maybe I'll just wait for Shengshou to release a "knockoff" 11X11. :)
 
Last edited:
I think the whole knockoff/illegal debate is pretty silly when talking about 8x8x8+ cubes. Let's look at the facts: Verdes hasn't mass-produced, or even shown they have made any serious progress towards mass-producing, any of these cubes; and yet other companies are doing this very thing. There is no real V-cube they are reverse-engineering and copying, and none of the 8x8x8+ cubes claim they are produced by V-cubes, or are even sold with similar packaging. This is not a "knockoff" in the traditional sense, and has very little relation to the cheap Gucci or Rolex replicas that people typically think of when they hear that word. It might be patent infringement - but who am I to judge? I'm not a lawyer and I don't know exactly what parts of the patent are required for infringement to occur, and I certainly don't know what was changed in the mechanisms, if anything.

What I do know is that these companies have made good higher-order cubes available where there weren't any before, and sometimes their cubes are of a quality that are superior to what I think V-cube would produce anyway (compare SS8 and V-6). As a speedcuber I'm a lot more interested in having a high-quality cube now than an unknown-quality cube someday. Sure, I could see that from a cube producer's side it's very annoying to have competing cubes with mechanisms similar to your own. But what money are you losing when someone takes a design you aren't even producing, many years after you promised you would start, and makes it available?


Note that some types of 7x7x7 and lower brands do piggyback off the V-cube brand by using similar cube designs, similar names and sometimes even similar packaging. I don't support this and I wouldn't encourage buying those brands. There is a big difference between "a different brand of cube with arguably similar internals" and "a Chinese copy of the original intended to fool you into buying it".
 
You guys are so serious about the whole legality of owning a 11x11x11.

Frankly, nobody gives a f*** except Verdes. Even if he does find you with a 11x11x11 I am sure you can knock him out if he tries to take the cube away from you :)
 
Is it only illegal in the US?

This whole thing is total bs though. Verdes is blocking us from getting good quality cubes for lower quality ones that he hasn't even produced yet.

I hope he knows how much the cubing community hates him and his descisions. :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top