rubixwiz031
Veteran
- Joined
- May 24, 2011
- Messages
- 381
- Location
- A suburb of N.Y.C.
- WCA ID
- 2011ROTH01
- YouTube
- Visit Channel
Not proof, but my source: (scroll to the bottom)As far as I can tell, Verdes has never won a patent lawsuit in the US. If I'm wrong about this, please give me a link. Google is our buddy here.
It is not the job of consumers to determine which products infringe on which patents. (Note I use the word "infringe" not "illegal".) It is the job of the patent owner to enforce his patents. When the patent owner fails to do this, the only conclusion a consumer can make is that there is no patent infringement. Patents are complicated things and are difficult for people to understand. As consumers, we do not have, in general, the skills of determining whether a product is infinging or not. Hey, if we buy a purse that usually goes for $10,000 for only $20 we can be pretty sure we've bought an infringing item, but that's probably a trademark infringement, not a patent infringement like we're talking about here. These are complicated things determined by incredibly complicated trials that take many years.
I've read the Verdes patent. I own a Sheng Shou 7x7x7. I have read the Verdes patent carefully and I do not believe Verdes would be successful in an infringement claim against that puzzle. I don't own any larger cube so I can't comment on them. But if you are a lawyer and you read the Verdes patent, I think that you will agree with me that it is *not* a very broad patent. My opinion is that its scope is very narrow. If you don't understand how the "claims" in a patent work and you're worried about this, consult a patent attorney. Show him the patent. Pay him $500 and get an opinion on it. Share it with us.
From the point of view of a consumer in buying a large cube, it is silly to imagine that there is any risk in buying a large cube. If your large cube does turn out to violate a patent, what do you think the patent holder is going to do? Sue you? For what, about 15% of the price of the puzzle??? Even filing a lawsuit against you would cost far more than the amount that could be made by collecting on that lawsuit. You are completely safe in buying these puzzles. You are not a "deep pockets" target. If you think I'm wrong in this, google around and find an example of where a consumer spent $90 on a toy and then got into trouble for patent infringement. Go ahead. It's at least possible that there are some cases where consumers got into trouble for "trademark" infringement (where, for example, you buy a purse that is made to look like it was manufactured by a different company than the one that made it) , but I've never seen any and that's not what we're talking about here. Try googling "patent infringement against buyer" to find plenty of examples of this language in sales agreements for high dollar equipment but none of us have ever signed such an agreement when buying a toy over the internet.
In the unlikely event that the WCA decides to start a 9x9x9 puzzle competition you can be almost certain (based on previous experience) that they will not enforce 3rd party patents against prospective competitors. It's not their job. If Verdes feels that their patents are being infringed they can file the appropriate lawsuits. An individual who bought a cube is not going to be named in these lawsuits. If you think otherwise, please google around and find an example of where people were sued for buying an infringing toy.
I would really like to know more about this, please help me by googling for these examples of patent infringement by consumers.
http://www.twistypuzzles.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=15&t=16116&p=197346&hilit=trafficking#p197346
Last edited: