Should I get an 11x11 or 9x9 cube?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Lolwut12345

Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2012
Messages
8
EDIT:

Okay guys I think this thread has run it's course, thanks for all the input.
 
Last edited:
I have the Yuxin. It's been used a bit on the Dutch Open by various people, and it never popped. However I DO have to state that ALL cubes that I own have been taken apart, relubed and tensioned as the defaults usually suck bananas ;) So.. you might have to do that.

51morefun is legit, does not take Paypal though if you are wanting to use that.

The SS is out. You can order it. But not everywhere just yet. I have seen people get it on videos, so.. yeah it is out.

Note that when you buy such an expensive cube from outside the country you might have to deal with import fees which can get quite hefty (I did, ugh).

Glow in the dark you can go to cubesmith. They have glow in the dark stickers. There is no glow in the dark out there that keeps glowing, nor is there one out there that has colors. If there is, I would love to hear about that!
 
I do know that the ShengShou 9x9 is out, and you can get it at cubedepotusa.com or icubemart.com. Icubemart is cheaper though. I know that the Yuxin 11x11 can pop, but the 9x9 is pretty good at not popping. If you wanted to, you could speedcube the 9x9... as for the glow in the dark, i think Kattenvriendin above answered that.... 51morefun is legit too.... i would go with the 9x9 just because it wont pop as much if at all and the stores above (esp. icubemart.com) are having black friday thru cyber monday sales...
 
I have the 11x11 too and it's quite a good cube. Not being a speedcuber (turning mostly slowly and carefully) I have little experience with popping, lubing and that stuff but the 11x11 seems solid to me and after 6-7 solves it turns even smoother than out of the box.
 
I do own both the SS9 and the 11x11 cube and they are both very good products. Both were obtained from 51morefun.com .

I live in Australia and because of the very good Australian dollar against the US dollar, they are not super costly.

I paid $105.15 AUD (including S/H) for the SS9 and $153.19 AUD (also including S/H) for the 11x11 cube.

And at the moment there is no GST payable on items brought online overseas under $1000 which are imported into Australia.
 
The quick answer to your question is the 11x11 is quite a good cube, but ShengShous tend to be excellent. Now to elaborate:

The Yuxin 11x11: I have a Yuxin 11x11 and while it is a very good cube, a speedcuber may get nervous solving it. While it turns smoothly enough, the pieces don't necessarily move together well. This is not a criticism, but it seems as though the issue of cubie size versus functionality could not be reconciled. Simply put, the centre cubies are too small and the internal mechanisms, while similar to what we are currently seeing from "big cubes," don't handle it as well as one would hope- they shift around more than you would like. Not only this, but stickers come off all the time. Nevertheless, I really like it;).

The ShengShou 9x9: I have nothing but praise for their cubes and I was especially pleased with the ShenShou 8x8. As soon as I can afford it, I'm getting the SS 9x9........................And now for a gratuitous rant: Of all the 9x9s on the market, my advice would be to stick with SS. Despite what some sellers tell you there are only 3 companies that make 9x9s as of 2012: YJ, Shen Qi and ShengShou. Sorry to all those people who purchased what they were told was a Yuxin 9x9 (contact Yuxin for more information). Some sellers are calling YJ 9x9s "Yuxin" so that they can get rid of them.....You could call it a Witlong and superglue the bugger together and the YJ it would still pop within 1 solve!

51morefun: I have used this website many times and they are fantastic. I know they have had their issues with PayPal, which means that you now can't pay via PayPal. Credit card payments are fine though; I've never had an issue. I will be buying my SS 9x9 with through them at Christmas.:tu

Sorry I can't help with the 3x3 question- I don't know anything about glow in the dark cubes except that sometimes I buy them by accident, then sit them on my bedside table, then try to go to sleep and....Hello :p
 
Last edited:
Yeah.. that includes all other big cubes too, including ShengShou, right?

Is it illegal in itself to OWN one, or is it illegal to COPY one?

The two are quite different.
 
Just FYI, the 11x11 is illeagal in the U.S. Verdes has gone to a huge effort to make this so. It is only legal in china. Should you bring one into the states, you are technically traffiking illegal goods.

Why is it illegal to own a Yuxin 11x11 cube? Yuxin is the only company I'm even aware of who even make 11x11 cubes. So some jackass in the U.S. made the only 11x11 cube illegal..........

Well if you're correct, then I'm not going to be purchasing one. I'm not taking that risk and I'm also not spending over $100 dollars on a product that's illegal.

EDIT: What the heck is Verdes? Verdes = The company the makes V-cubes?

I don't understand why it's illegal for a company in China to make 11x11 cubes? Does Verdes have some fricken monopoly/intellectual property right over cubes or something? Wow this is really frustrating and disappointing that I can't get the 11x11 cube. That's definitely a big disappointment, was looking forward to a big cube for Christmas but I guess this news has killed that for me.

I'm looking at other threads on this site talking about "big cubes" and I hear lots of people say that cubes that are bigger than 7x7 are "knock offs." I don't understand how a cube can be a knock off, if it's a cube then it's a cube. What I don't understand is the legal reasoning behind this, are you honestly telling me that it's legal for a company in the United States to monopolize and set restrictions over a plastic cube?
 
Last edited:
Why is it illegal to own a Yuxin 11x11 cube? Yuxin is the only company I'm even aware of who even make 11x11 cubes. So some jackass in the U.S. made the only 11x11 cube illegal..........

Well if you're correct, then I'm not going to be purchasing one. I'm not taking that risk and I'm also not spending over $100 dollars on a product that's illegal.

EDIT: What the heck is Verdes? Verdes = The company the makes V-cubes?

I don't understand why it's illegal for a company in China to make 11x11 cubes? Does Verdes have some fricken monopoly/intellectual property right over cubes or something? Wow this is really frustrating and disappointing that I can't get the 11x11 cube. That's definitely a big disappointment, was looking forward to a big cube for Christmas but I guess this news has killed that for me.

I'm looking at other threads on this site talking about "big cubes" and I hear lots of people say that cubes that are bigger than 7x7 are "knock offs." I don't understand how a cube can be a knock off, if it's a cube then it's a cube. What I don't understand is the legal reasoning behind this, are you honestly telling me that it's legal for a company in the United States to monopolize and set restrictions over a plastic cube?
Let me clarify. It is not illegal (yet) for the company to make the cubes. It is not illegal (yet) to have the cubes IN CHINA. What IS illegal is having the 11x11 in the U.S.
Regarding your questions about KO's: http://www.twistypuzzles.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=12721
That's a generally good rule to go by.
TLDR: Although Verdes (V-Cubes) have not released the V-Cubes larger than 7x7, they have filed patents for it, and gotten them approved. They have spent huge amounts of money on this, and people (Yuxin, ShengShou, YJ, LanLan, etc) have stolen their designs, cheaply put them into production, and sold them without giving credit/ royalties to Verdes.
 
Last edited:
Let me clarify. It is not illegal (yet) for the company to make the cubes. It is not illegal (yet) to have the cubes IN CHINA. What IS illegal is having the 11x11 in the U.S.
Regarding your questions about KO's: http://www.twistypuzzles.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=12721
That's a generally good rule to go by.
TLDR: Although Verdes (V-Cubes) have not released the V-Cubes larger than 7x7, they have filed patents for it, and gotten them approved. They have spent huge amounts of money on this, and people (Yuxin, ShengShou, YJ, LanLan, etc) have stolen their designs, cheaply put them into production, and sold them without giving credit/ royalties to Verdes.

Yes I understand that in China these products are not illegal, however in the United States they are and I'm in the United States.

But I'm confused now because just a second ago in your last post you said that the ShengShou 9x9 is not illegal yet. So are the Shengshou 9x9's illegal or not to own in the U.S.?

Yeah so Verdes basically put a patent on products that they don't even make (8x8 all through 11x11 they have patents on even though they don't make cubes these sizes).

Also if these products are illegal how come so many people have them? I mean you can go on Ebay (I'm assuming all the 11x11's there are Yuxin cubes since they look exactly like them), go on YouTube and you see a ton of people have the Yuxin 11x11 cubes.
 
Seriously, don't worry about legality. If you want to avoid customs, just order from stores within the US. I'm pretty sure icubemart has both the cubes you are interested in.
 
Yes I understand that in China these products are not illegal, however in the United States they are and I'm in the United States.

But I'm confused now because just a second ago in your last post you said that the ShengShou 9x9 is not illegal yet. So are the Shengshou 9x9's illegal or not to own in the U.S.?

Yeah so Verdes basically put a patent on products that they don't even make (8x8 all through 11x11 they have patents on even though they don't make cubes these sizes).

Also if these products are illegal how come so many people have them? I mean you can go on Ebay (I'm assuming all the 11x11's there are Yuxin cubes since they look exactly like them), go on YouTube and you see a ton of people have the Yuxin 11x11 cubes.
ShengShou's are legal. However, they are still KO's and stealing from Verdes
 
EDIT:

Nevermind not buying a 9x9 or an 11x11 cube because some company (Verdes) in the United States decided to make it illegal to own 9x9 and 11x11 cubes made by other companies.

I'm seriously thinking about writing hate mail to Verdes, telling them that they ruined my Christmas (apparently they put patents on products they don't even manufacture............) I know it's immature, but I'm just really disappointed right now. I was looking forward to having a big cube but I guess this news of legality totally ruined it for me.

It's ILLEGAL now??? What??
 
As far as I can tell, Verdes has never won a patent lawsuit in the US. If I'm wrong about this, please give me a link. Google is our buddy here.

It is not the job of consumers to determine which products infringe on which patents. (Note I use the word "infringe" not "illegal".) It is the job of the patent owner to enforce his patents. When the patent owner fails to do this, the only conclusion a consumer can make is that there is no patent infringement. Patents are complicated things and are difficult for people to understand. As consumers, we do not have, in general, the skills of determining whether a product is infinging or not. Hey, if we buy a purse that usually goes for $10,000 for only $20 we can be pretty sure we've bought an infringing item, but that's probably a trademark infringement, not a patent infringement like we're talking about here. These are complicated things determined by incredibly complicated trials that take many years.

I've read the Verdes patent. I own a Sheng Shou 7x7x7. I have read the Verdes patent carefully and I do not believe Verdes would be successful in an infringement claim against that puzzle. I don't own any larger cube so I can't comment on them. But if you are a lawyer and you read the Verdes patent, I think that you will agree with me that it is *not* a very broad patent. My opinion is that its scope is very narrow. If you don't understand how the "claims" in a patent work and you're worried about this, consult a patent attorney. Show him the patent. Pay him $500 and get an opinion on it. Share it with us.

From the point of view of a consumer in buying a large cube, it is silly to imagine that there is any risk in buying a large cube. If your large cube does turn out to violate a patent, what do you think the patent holder is going to do? Sue you? For what, about 15% of the price of the puzzle??? Even filing a lawsuit against you would cost far more than the amount that could be made by collecting on that lawsuit. You are completely safe in buying these puzzles. You are not a "deep pockets" target. If you think I'm wrong in this, google around and find an example of where a consumer spent $90 on a toy and then got into trouble for patent infringement. Go ahead. It's at least possible that there are some cases where consumers got into trouble for "trademark" infringement (where, for example, you buy a purse that is made to look like it was manufactured by a different company than the one that made it) , but I've never seen any and that's not what we're talking about here. Try googling "patent infringement against buyer" to find plenty of examples of this language in sales agreements for high dollar equipment but none of us have ever signed such an agreement when buying a toy over the internet.

In the unlikely event that the WCA decides to start a 9x9x9 puzzle competition you can be almost certain (based on previous experience) that they will not enforce 3rd party patents against prospective competitors. It's not their job. If Verdes feels that their patents are being infringed they can file the appropriate lawsuits. An individual who bought a cube is not going to be named in these lawsuits. If you think otherwise, please google around and find an example of where people were sued for buying an infringing toy.

I would really like to know more about this, please help me by googling for these examples of patent infringement by consumers.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top