SuperSathanas
Member
DISCLAIMER: If you decide to try this mod, or to mod the core of any X3+ with a ball-core, expect to break at least a couple of the little tabs that help keep the two halves of the core together. They're fragile, and they're covered in glue. This won't make the core unusable, and you can still glue it back together, but it may not stay together as well in the long-term. Mod at your own risk.
This is a writeup for a simple mod for my fellow TianMa enjoyers, which, in my opinion, greatly improves upon the X3+ Full Magnetic. I don't want to just throw a mod out there without context or explanation, so expect a lot of text.
At the moment, I have no images to upload, because I didn't think to get any. I don't have the cube handy at the moment, but I should be able to get some later today and edit them into the post.
In an effort to keep things short(er) here, because I have a habit of going on forever while struggling to get to the point, instead of giving a breakdown of the Full Magnetic and MoreTry's different magnet configurations, I'll refer you to a Google spreadsheet and word doc that I made specifically to make finding English Language info on the TianMa's various versions easy. Both are linked in my signature. Let me know if I somehow managed to screw up accessibility/permissions.
The Mod
- Repelling Edge Magnets
This one is simple. Identify the side/pole of the magnet that is attracted to the core magnets, put a small dab of super glue on that side, and then press it against the center of the edge piece foot. Hold it until it's dry enough to stay in place, and then leave it alone for 20+ minutes until you're sure it's dry enough to insert back into the cube. Use the glue sparingly if you intend on being able to remove the magnets in the future.
I used the little magnetic screwdriver that comes with all the TianMas to hold and place the magnets. I'd hold the glued magnet against the edge feet until it was stuck well enough that I could remove the screwdriver without the magnet trying to come with it.
- Additional Core Magnets
This is slightly more involved, and a little risky.
We need to open the ball-core, so completely disassemble the cube. Unscrew all the center pieces and set all your pieces to the side.
Look at the core and see where the two halves connect around the "equator". You'll notice that there are 4 little slots that have locking tabs in them. Each half has 2 tabs and 2 slots. Ignore them for now.
Grip the core with both hands, one half in each hand, and start gently turning the halves a small amount back and forth in opposite directions. This will start to break the glue that's holding the halves together. You might take a razor or Xacto knife and trace between the halves to help break the glue. You can try to gently pull the halves apart at different points to see where the glue to still holding together at.
You should come to the point that you only have glue holding together around the slots and the tabs.
Take care of the slot parts, first, as in continue to break the glue holding the halves together. Use your razor/knife/thin flathead screwdriver/whatever to gently get between the halves and break the glue. You should be able to turn the halves against each other and see no areas that are still sticking together except for the tabs.
Now, for the tabs, you're going to be even more careful, because they're fragile. Really, the whole ball-core is fragile, but the tabs are especially easy to break off, even more so if they're completely covered in glue. Use your razor/knife/screwdriver to very gently and carefully start scraping away at whatever glue you can see around the tab/inside the slot. Every so often, press gently on the tab to see if it can move backward toward the inside of the core. DO NOT PRESS HARD. DO NOT MOVE IT MORE THAN A HAIR.
Once you can get some movement out of them, you're going to get your razor/knife/screwdriver and go over the top of the slot piece and gently bend it outward toward you, instead of pushing the tab inward to get them to release each other. The tab will break, but the slot piece can bend outward enough to get the tab to release.
Do that for all 4 tabs/slots and pull your core halves apart.
Now, simply drop an extra magnet on top of the ones already inside the core.
place a small amount of super glue around the equator/perimeter of one half of the core, but avoid the slots and tabs. Should you ever need to get the core back open, you'll thank yourself for this.
Press the halves of the core back together. It may help to bend the little slot pieces outward slightly again while you press each tab down into position individually. Wait 20+ minutes for the glue to dry.
Reassemble the cube.
Look at that, you're done.
So, what was the problem?
The problem was that even though I really liked the overall feel of the Full Magnetic, it's actual balance and performance were unreliable, leading to a lot of catching, lockups, and accidental double turns. It was way too easy to overshoot turns, and if I turned more lightly or slowed it down some, either through adjustments or lube, it would tend to undershoot and stop short of completion. All information I've ever been able to find on the Full Magnetic (which isn't a lot), says that it should have 45 degree auto-alignment. In practice, I found it to be closer to about 20-25 degrees sometimes.
Just spamming algs on it, it would feel fine. At the start of solves, when I'm doing a bunch of short triggers and sequences of moves during cross and F2L, the cube would feel great. Once I'd get into last layer, or just had an awkward F2L case to deal with, it seemed like the feel and performance of the cube would go out the window and everything would start going wrong for me. Turns would over/undershoot, layers would be stuck out of alignment, I'd catch, I'd lock up, and I'd have to purposely slow down and use a lot more physical follow through with turns to try to ensure that everything ended up where I wanted it.
For some sort of frame of reference, I was performing better with an un-modded TengYun V1, which does not align itself well at all with it's stock magnets.
I tried really hard for several days to get used to it, made sure I had the cube setup and broken in about as well as I could, but it just wasn't doing it for me. This cube felt like it really wanted to be better behaved, though, so I did what I could to help it out.
Why was it a problem?
I can't say I know for sure exactly what the issue was, but my suspicion is that the addition of the ball-core on top of the Triple Magnetic's configuration introduced interactions between the core magnets and the foot-to-foot magnets on the corner feet, and the additional edge foot magnets, that just do not play well with the corner repulsion system
My reasoning for thinking this comes down to some part swapping and magnet experiments I did with an X3+ ZCube Enhanced a while ago. I had glued in the 3 additional corner magnets and inserted the 2 additional edge magnets so that I I would have the foot-to-foot "double magnetic" system in that cube. It gave it a heavier turn feel and made it a little snappier, but it also unbalanced things to a degree, to where I was getting a little more catchiness with it.
I tried out the corner and edge magnets individually, and found that they were indeed having a small interaction with the core magnets. The foot magnets specifically were making it harder for layers to glide into alignment while also slightly increasing turning resistance. The edge magnets were also having a small attracting affect on the core magnets, though it wasn't very noticeable during solves. Together, when interacting with the core magnets, they had less of a negative effect than you might assume from their individual effects, but they still unbalanced the feel and performance of the cube.
One other thing I did was flip the additional edge foot magnets, so that they would act like repelling edge magnets, and they actually ended up having more of a repelling effect than I assumed they would given their distance from the core, and actually kind of improved the feel and performance of the cube. I'm bringing this up just to further illustrate that the stock edge foot magnets of the Full Magnetic most likely are having a noticeable interaction with the core magnets, meaning that they will be attracted to the core, fighting against the foot repulsion of the corner-to-center repulsion system halfway through a turn. Combined with the additional corner foot magnets having a small repelling effect on the core, you might be able to intuit that the magnetic curve is kind of all over the place during a turn, with core attraction happening mid-turn and some repulsion happening near the end of the turn before the corner foot's center magnet can take over and attract the core.
Why does the mod work?
I think it works simply because I'm overpowering the undesirable magnetic interactions with desirable ones.
if the edge feet magnets have an attractive effect on the core mid turn, then placing a repelling edge magnet between those magnets and the core has a repelling effect that is greater and happens sooner than the edge foot magnets' attracting effect, especially when the core magnets are doubled up.
Similarly, with the core magnets doubled up, and the 3 corner center repulsion magnets being further from the core than the corner-to-core magnet, that corner-to-core magnet is better able to overpower the core repulsion effect near the edge of a turn, and starts having an attractive effect sooner than it used to.
I mean, look at the HuDong Light. It has the same additional piece-to-piece system going on, and it is a very balanced and stable cube. It just has repelling edge magnets built in instead of center rings, and through my own (very inaccurate) testing, those 3 additional corner foot magnets are positioned in a way that they don't have much of an interaction with the core magnets.
So now, I have 2 repulsion systems that are actually working mid-turn, and the doubled up core magnets are allowing the cube to snap well into alignment at the end with the help of those foot-to-foot magnets.
Additionally, it now auto-aligns from nearly any position. There's a range of maybe 2-3 degrees near mid-turn where a layer won't align itself, but in practice, if you give a layer enough momentum to make it half-way through a turn, the magnets will complete it for you, no under- or overshooting.
This has eliminated almost all catching and locking. The cube feels very fluid and stable, while still being more than flexible enough at looser settings.
This is a writeup for a simple mod for my fellow TianMa enjoyers, which, in my opinion, greatly improves upon the X3+ Full Magnetic. I don't want to just throw a mod out there without context or explanation, so expect a lot of text.
At the moment, I have no images to upload, because I didn't think to get any. I don't have the cube handy at the moment, but I should be able to get some later today and edit them into the post.
In an effort to keep things short(er) here, because I have a habit of going on forever while struggling to get to the point, instead of giving a breakdown of the Full Magnetic and MoreTry's different magnet configurations, I'll refer you to a Google spreadsheet and word doc that I made specifically to make finding English Language info on the TianMa's various versions easy. Both are linked in my signature. Let me know if I somehow managed to screw up accessibility/permissions.
The Mod
- All magnets used are cylindrical 3x1mm N48, taken from an LBL HuDong upgrade kit
- Addition of repelling edge magnets directly to the edge piece feet
- Doubled the core magnets, as in I just dropped another magnet on top of the existing core magnets
- Better mid-turn repulsion
- Better alignment over almost the full range of a turn
- More snappy at turn completion
- Greatly reduced catching and locking from mis-alignment
- Slightly greater initial turning resistance
- Overall heavier with more weighty turn feel
- This cube is now my main
- Repelling Edge Magnets
This one is simple. Identify the side/pole of the magnet that is attracted to the core magnets, put a small dab of super glue on that side, and then press it against the center of the edge piece foot. Hold it until it's dry enough to stay in place, and then leave it alone for 20+ minutes until you're sure it's dry enough to insert back into the cube. Use the glue sparingly if you intend on being able to remove the magnets in the future.
I used the little magnetic screwdriver that comes with all the TianMas to hold and place the magnets. I'd hold the glued magnet against the edge feet until it was stuck well enough that I could remove the screwdriver without the magnet trying to come with it.
- Additional Core Magnets
This is slightly more involved, and a little risky.
We need to open the ball-core, so completely disassemble the cube. Unscrew all the center pieces and set all your pieces to the side.
Look at the core and see where the two halves connect around the "equator". You'll notice that there are 4 little slots that have locking tabs in them. Each half has 2 tabs and 2 slots. Ignore them for now.
Grip the core with both hands, one half in each hand, and start gently turning the halves a small amount back and forth in opposite directions. This will start to break the glue that's holding the halves together. You might take a razor or Xacto knife and trace between the halves to help break the glue. You can try to gently pull the halves apart at different points to see where the glue to still holding together at.
You should come to the point that you only have glue holding together around the slots and the tabs.
Take care of the slot parts, first, as in continue to break the glue holding the halves together. Use your razor/knife/thin flathead screwdriver/whatever to gently get between the halves and break the glue. You should be able to turn the halves against each other and see no areas that are still sticking together except for the tabs.
Now, for the tabs, you're going to be even more careful, because they're fragile. Really, the whole ball-core is fragile, but the tabs are especially easy to break off, even more so if they're completely covered in glue. Use your razor/knife/screwdriver to very gently and carefully start scraping away at whatever glue you can see around the tab/inside the slot. Every so often, press gently on the tab to see if it can move backward toward the inside of the core. DO NOT PRESS HARD. DO NOT MOVE IT MORE THAN A HAIR.
Once you can get some movement out of them, you're going to get your razor/knife/screwdriver and go over the top of the slot piece and gently bend it outward toward you, instead of pushing the tab inward to get them to release each other. The tab will break, but the slot piece can bend outward enough to get the tab to release.
Do that for all 4 tabs/slots and pull your core halves apart.
Now, simply drop an extra magnet on top of the ones already inside the core.
place a small amount of super glue around the equator/perimeter of one half of the core, but avoid the slots and tabs. Should you ever need to get the core back open, you'll thank yourself for this.
Press the halves of the core back together. It may help to bend the little slot pieces outward slightly again while you press each tab down into position individually. Wait 20+ minutes for the glue to dry.
Reassemble the cube.
Look at that, you're done.
So, what was the problem?
The problem was that even though I really liked the overall feel of the Full Magnetic, it's actual balance and performance were unreliable, leading to a lot of catching, lockups, and accidental double turns. It was way too easy to overshoot turns, and if I turned more lightly or slowed it down some, either through adjustments or lube, it would tend to undershoot and stop short of completion. All information I've ever been able to find on the Full Magnetic (which isn't a lot), says that it should have 45 degree auto-alignment. In practice, I found it to be closer to about 20-25 degrees sometimes.
Just spamming algs on it, it would feel fine. At the start of solves, when I'm doing a bunch of short triggers and sequences of moves during cross and F2L, the cube would feel great. Once I'd get into last layer, or just had an awkward F2L case to deal with, it seemed like the feel and performance of the cube would go out the window and everything would start going wrong for me. Turns would over/undershoot, layers would be stuck out of alignment, I'd catch, I'd lock up, and I'd have to purposely slow down and use a lot more physical follow through with turns to try to ensure that everything ended up where I wanted it.
For some sort of frame of reference, I was performing better with an un-modded TengYun V1, which does not align itself well at all with it's stock magnets.
I tried really hard for several days to get used to it, made sure I had the cube setup and broken in about as well as I could, but it just wasn't doing it for me. This cube felt like it really wanted to be better behaved, though, so I did what I could to help it out.
Why was it a problem?
I can't say I know for sure exactly what the issue was, but my suspicion is that the addition of the ball-core on top of the Triple Magnetic's configuration introduced interactions between the core magnets and the foot-to-foot magnets on the corner feet, and the additional edge foot magnets, that just do not play well with the corner repulsion system
My reasoning for thinking this comes down to some part swapping and magnet experiments I did with an X3+ ZCube Enhanced a while ago. I had glued in the 3 additional corner magnets and inserted the 2 additional edge magnets so that I I would have the foot-to-foot "double magnetic" system in that cube. It gave it a heavier turn feel and made it a little snappier, but it also unbalanced things to a degree, to where I was getting a little more catchiness with it.
I tried out the corner and edge magnets individually, and found that they were indeed having a small interaction with the core magnets. The foot magnets specifically were making it harder for layers to glide into alignment while also slightly increasing turning resistance. The edge magnets were also having a small attracting affect on the core magnets, though it wasn't very noticeable during solves. Together, when interacting with the core magnets, they had less of a negative effect than you might assume from their individual effects, but they still unbalanced the feel and performance of the cube.
One other thing I did was flip the additional edge foot magnets, so that they would act like repelling edge magnets, and they actually ended up having more of a repelling effect than I assumed they would given their distance from the core, and actually kind of improved the feel and performance of the cube. I'm bringing this up just to further illustrate that the stock edge foot magnets of the Full Magnetic most likely are having a noticeable interaction with the core magnets, meaning that they will be attracted to the core, fighting against the foot repulsion of the corner-to-center repulsion system halfway through a turn. Combined with the additional corner foot magnets having a small repelling effect on the core, you might be able to intuit that the magnetic curve is kind of all over the place during a turn, with core attraction happening mid-turn and some repulsion happening near the end of the turn before the corner foot's center magnet can take over and attract the core.
Why does the mod work?
I think it works simply because I'm overpowering the undesirable magnetic interactions with desirable ones.
if the edge feet magnets have an attractive effect on the core mid turn, then placing a repelling edge magnet between those magnets and the core has a repelling effect that is greater and happens sooner than the edge foot magnets' attracting effect, especially when the core magnets are doubled up.
Similarly, with the core magnets doubled up, and the 3 corner center repulsion magnets being further from the core than the corner-to-core magnet, that corner-to-core magnet is better able to overpower the core repulsion effect near the edge of a turn, and starts having an attractive effect sooner than it used to.
I mean, look at the HuDong Light. It has the same additional piece-to-piece system going on, and it is a very balanced and stable cube. It just has repelling edge magnets built in instead of center rings, and through my own (very inaccurate) testing, those 3 additional corner foot magnets are positioned in a way that they don't have much of an interaction with the core magnets.
So now, I have 2 repulsion systems that are actually working mid-turn, and the doubled up core magnets are allowing the cube to snap well into alignment at the end with the help of those foot-to-foot magnets.
Additionally, it now auto-aligns from nearly any position. There's a range of maybe 2-3 degrees near mid-turn where a layer won't align itself, but in practice, if you give a layer enough momentum to make it half-way through a turn, the magnets will complete it for you, no under- or overshooting.
This has eliminated almost all catching and locking. The cube feels very fluid and stable, while still being more than flexible enough at looser settings.