Allow The Use Of Headphones During Our Competition Solves

Status
Not open for further replies.

Vishal

Regular
Joined
Jun 12, 2010
Messages
90
Location
Florida us
Hello as many others do I solve better while I listen to music. There was a huge debate about this a few years ago as I have been told, but I think I have an ansewer to all the issues people were having with allowing headphones.
1. People thought that others would blast their music and they would be disturbed.
The only way music leaks is when you are wearing over ear headphones, on ear headphones or earbuds. On ear and over ear are pretty self explanitory. Ear buds are the things that come wirth your ipod. They sit on the outside of your ear which means they can leak at high volumes. So my fix is that it is manditor to use in ear headphones. Other names are in ear monitors and earphones. In ear headphones will never leak sound son their will be no disturbances to others who don't like using headphones. Something I reccomend is comply foam tips http://complyfoam.com/ These eartips will not leak, are supremely comfortable and block out 99% of ambient noise. You can isolate yourself from the outside would and just focus on cubing.
2. I canot afford expensive headphones.
Most people have a device they listen to music on ipod, iphone, mp3 player and other smartphones. So those come with earbuds which can leak sound. For only 10 dollars you can buy the Whoomp earbud enhancers. http://complyfoam.com/products/index.php?strProductName=Whoomp!-Earbud-Enhancers these will make your earbuds in ear headphones. These will also isolate you from the outside world.
3. You will not be able to hear the judge.
As stated in the WCA regulations if some one canot hear the judge will use hand signs. The same could be implimented here.
4. I don't like listening to music while i solve and concentrate better without music.
Thats fine this is not a manditory thing.

I think that fixes all the problems. For me atleast when im isolated and cubing i don't even listen to the music and I concentrate much better. This will also make people who are nervous fell less nervous. I know it would have helped me at my first competition. This will also help blind solvers as many of you know. Please leave your thoughts and comments below. If there is a general interest we can make a thread on the WCA fourms and when time comes to change the regulations hopefully we can get earphones legalized seeing i have found a fix to the problems with legalizing them before.
 
What if someone has an MP3 player constantly playing their voice saying "R U R' U' R' F' ... etc..."

Would be so easy to cheat yeah?
 
This will also help blind solvers as many of you know
Listening to music helps blind solvers?! Non-electronic headphones used to block out noise are already allowed (and many blind solver use them)

How about the image of cubing? I don't think it's great to see people listening to music while they do official solves. And I don't think it's a great image for the general public to see if, say, Felik's 3x3 WRs had him listening to music.
 
Having an algorithm constantly spamming in your ear would be so annoying, it would make you slower rather than faster.

And if you're in competitions, you'll probably know your algorithms so well you don't need to listen to them from headphones. And if you do need to, then you probably still suck at cubing so miserably that you wont get a good time anyway, so it doesn't matter.
 
They would have to record the scramble backwards and they do not get the scrambes so that is void. I promise you there is no way to cheat. If it did just say R U R' U' R' F' it would not be the right moves and there is no way to get the right moves on to your mp3 player usless you stole the scrambing sheets which is cheating anyway.
 
Listening to music helps blind solvers?! Non-electronic headphones used to block out noise are already allowed (and many blind solver use them)

How about the image of cubing? I don't think it's great to see people listening to music while they do official solves. And I don't think it's a great image for the general public to see if, say, Felik's 3x3 WRs had him listening to music.
Many other big tournaments allow people to listen to music and those are ear muffs not headphones and they do not block out that much noise.
 
what about someone who doesn't know OLL parity. how bout that huh?!?

For real though, no sport except for EXTREME SPORTS (X Games stuff) allows participants to listen to music while competing.

World poker allows music. If someone does not know OLL parity then they are not very fast. And if the OLL parity algorithm was playing throughout the solve you would get messed up and when you need to use the alg you would have to wait for the algorithm to restart.
 
but you said they weren't very fast to begin with...
say you have someone that knows everything about 4x4 but never memorized the parity algs, so instead he/she goes up and competes with those two algs playing in his/her ears, as they will surely come up in a 4x4 solve...now, suppose we have another person who actually knows the algs, but it slower at edge pairing...does the first person deserve to outplace the second?
 
Could this mean that the judges have to evalutate the headphones you have, as well as your cube, sounds just more work for the judges.
I get where the OP is coming from, but I think you have to just get used to it. Competitions by their very nature are stressful.
 
Many other big tournaments allow people to listen to music and those are ear muffs not headphones and they do not block out that much noise.
I use Peltor Optime III ear protecting headphones with foam earplugs under them (all within the current regs), and I can sit in a room with people playing guitar hero loudly, and blindsolve with no problem. So they do block out a lot of noise
 
It'd be quite annoying to have to instruct competitors while they're listening to music both before, during and after a solve when they're not accustomed to relying primarily on sight for communication.

Judge: "McCuber!"
*competitor sits down with headphones on for a 3x3 solve*
Judge: "Ready?" (signals)
Competitor: "Yes." (signals)
*judge removes cover*
*competitor inspects, and then starts the solve*
Judge: "Your timer didn't start!"
*competitor ignores*
*judge taps competitor on the shoulder*
*competitor removes headphones*
Competitor: "ERRRRGH! DON'T TOUCH ME!"
Random: "Calm down!"
Competitor: "I DON'T LIKE IT WHEN PEOPLE TOUCH ME!"
Judge: "Huh?"
*competitor storms off*

Tim.
 
I agree with the above poster.
There needs to be a communication between the judge and the competitor and if the competitor is listening to music the lack of communication can cause problems.

Personally, I think it's disrespectful listening to music without paying attention to the judge and others.

As a competitor one needs to be aware of ones surroundings, aware of the judge, aware of others and that's a part of competing one needs to adjust to. It's another thing cubing at home. You just have to get used to it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top