which of these puzzles is more fun?

cookingfat

Veteran
Joined
Sep 1, 2008
Messages
904
Location
Sheffield - UK
WCA ID
2009HARP01
YouTube
Visit Channel
I'm getting a new puzzle soon and I'm either going to get a megaminx or a square 1.

With Mefferts being out of stock on megaminxs and also funds being low, it would be either a chinaminx or a DIY square-1. I plan on getting it from rubiks-fans ebay shop.

I've never tried either of these puzzles before, so before I buy I just wanted to ask a few things.

which is the most fun to solve?

which is the hardest to solve?

which would you buy?

so you have an idea of my skill, I can only solve a 3x3x3 and 4x4x4 and I'm not even fast.
 
Last edited:
Megaminx.
Square-1 is fun but its not intuitive at all, its just rote memorization.
Megaminx you can already solve everything except the last layer since you know 3x3, and even the LL you should be able to do with some thought.
Square-1 is not particularly hard to solve. I (when I practiced even the slightest bit) was averaging about a minute with minimal algorithms, maybe 3 and parity.
 
which is the most fun to solve?Square-1(IMO)

which is the hardest to solve?Square-1

which would you buy?megaminx

lol
totally contradicts the other statements, but I have to agree with hawkmp4.
Also, your times will improve faster on Minx...Sq-1 is just memorization except for when you have to get it back into a cube
 
thanks, I just watched a vid explaining the square-1 and tbh I think I would enjoy the megaminx more.

mmm, mefferts ones are way more expensive though, I might just plump for a cheaper chinese one for now, I have enough reward points to get one for free.

THIS is the one I'm thinking of getting

ooo, I'll ask this while I remember, I also want to make a puzzle from two 3x3s my other question is which is harder to solve and which is more fun from a siamese cube and a fused cube?
 
Last edited:
thanks, I just watched a vid explaining the square-1 and tbh I think I would enjoy the megaminx more.

mmm, mefferts ones are way more expensive though, I might just plump for a cheaper chinese one for now, I have enough reward points to get one for free.

THIS is the one I'm thinking of getting

ooo, I'll ask this while I remember, I also want to make a puzzle from two 3x3s my other question is which is harder to solve and which is more fun from a siamese cube and a fused cube?

Looks good! If you read the thread of megaminxes, you'll see that times of around 1:20 is possible on it.
 
The more fun to solve ? Depends on your taste, I like both of them.
The hardest ? Square-1 without hesitation. If you know the basic LBL method on the cube you can apply it to megaminx as well, the five algs work exactly the same way. (For more advanced methods you will need new algs, though). On square-1 algs from corners first methods will help, but only for corners, you still have to figure out the back-to-cube step and the way to handle edges.
And no, I won't make this thread into the Nth "which megaminx is better" thread. :D But if yours funds are low, don't hesitate, go for chinaminx.
 
mmm, mefferts ones are way more expensive though, I might just plump for a cheaper chinese one for now, I have enough reward points to get one for free.

THIS is the one I'm thinking of getting

Last night I ordered this megaminx and speedcube pair offered by puzl.co.uk which came in at a total cost of £23.74 (£20.99 + £2.75 postage). I have little or no idea of the quality of these two puzzles but have decided to buy them anyway since I seem to be unable to wait!
:)
When I receive the package I shall post my evaluations (to the best of my ability :) ).
 
thanks so much everyone, I've decided that I'm going to get the megaminx and I'm going to get it from puzl.co.uk. I've ordered from them before and Tony's service is very good. They do a good deal with a megaminx and a speedcube so I'm waiting for my birthday in a couple of weeks.

that said, I still need to use my points up so I might just get a square-1 as well unless I see something else.

can anyone answer the siamese cube question, which is harder/more fun a siamese or fused cube?

edit - you read my mind, we posted at the same time.
 
Hello to fellow Nottinghammer :)

Ahoy there! I don't know if that's the correct demonym but it's closer than anything I can think of right now :D

That speedcube is actually quite good. I can average ~18 with it, compared to ~16.5 with a Type D.

That is most welcome news: whilst I love my store-bought Rubik's 3x3x3 I find that I lock up when I'm not accurate enough with face turns. My V-Cube 7 will cut corners with ease but it unnerves me somewhat following a pop in a busy train carriage caused a minor panic and a frantic search for a fallen piece!

pop.jpgpop-oops.jpg
 
Wow! I came home from work to find my package had arrived from puzl: a 12-colour megaminx (yes, I know that's not 12 colours :) ) and a speedcube. I'm very impressed with both: the speedcube is a delight to handle and the megaminx is mind-boggling!
tux-minx-sc.jpg
I've never handled a megaminx and I was surprised to see how small it is - somehow I expected it to be about 50% bigger. Perhaps all those people on YouTube have tiny hands :D .
minx-size.jpg
I'm most impressed with the speedy delivery: I placed the order at 22:35 on Sun 5th Oct and it arrived some time today, Tues 7th Oct. This is somewhat quicker than a 7 week delivery from Asia forcast by some of the ebay sellers!

Now to try and work out how to do F2L (or it's logical equivalent) on the minx!
 
Now to try and work out how to do F2L (or it's logical equivalent) on the minx!
Exactly the same :)
Just pretend when you solve an entire face, that you're starting with another face that already has an X-cross and fill in the other slots.
 
Back
Top