CRC silicone causes cancer?

nicjsb

Member
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
19
On the can, it says that it is "known by the state of California" to cause cancer.

From: http://hpd.nlm.nih.gov/cgi-bin/hous...3003032&query=CRC+silicone&searchas=TblBrands
(this is the marine lube version, but the normal one says the same thing on the can)

"This product contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer, birth defects and reproductive harm."

This makes me hesitant to use it. I really, really don't want to get any kind of cancer, it's just not worth having a fast cube.
 
Ummm... According to someone, everything cause cancer.
Don't breath! You don't want your DNA to be oxidated. :P
I've been painting each week for years, and the paint contains lead, cadmium, cobalt, etc, which is definitely worse than silicone spray. I don't have cancer.
Crazy Californians.
 
i inhaled silicone before,i got real dizzy,but after that it was okay.

stupid wind blowed the silicone to me.

now i use MR Mckenic(lol singapore brand) which is a wet lube but you do not need to wait for it to dry and it wont cause cancer cuz water,the chance of u inhaling water is like 1%. unless u spray it into ur nose=.='
 
CRC Marine Silicone Lubricant

Check out the MSDS for this product first!

The following agencies did not find any components that would warrant the product being labeled as carcinogenic:
- Occupational and Safety Health Administration (OSHA)
- International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC)
- National Toxicology Program (NTP)

That's two federal government agencies and one international agency who think the concentration of benzene and toluene is low enough to not cause cancer (under normal use).

The State of California probably has that warning with large companies in mind. These products are used occupationally and employees are exposure to such carcinogens over a long period of time (e.g. working the same job for 20 years). So the risk of getting cancer may increase from "negligible" to "one-in-a-million" depending on the concentration. Spraying your cube once every couple of months is nothing compared to using 1-2 cans a week for 20 years. You've probably got a higher risk of getting skin cancer from the sun.

Personally, I use CRC 808 Silicone Spray. Although, here the state government does not go against federal governments warnings or lack thereof.

Tim.
 
Last edited:
You see those warnings everywhere in California. It's mostly just a legal thing. If you try hard enough, you can probably show that anything has the potential to cause cancer.
 
Last edited:
Actually evertything can be harmfull for your body as long as you take too much of it, like water...
But seriously, do you really think they'd sell a product (when you buy it in a normal store of course) where if you use it (even heavy usage) always, or most likely will get cancer? Probably the chance of getting cancer of this using it for 10 years is probably even smaller then smoking one cigarette in those 10 years.
 
"But seriously, do you really think they'd sell a product (when you buy it in a normal store of course) where if you use it (even heavy usage) always, or most likely will get cancer?"
Tobacco?
 
And also why I'm brilliant yet can barely pull a weighted 3.0 GPA. I just sometimes forget to do that thinking thing.
 
i think so long as you're not huffing the stuff you'll be ok. you can only come in contact with a very minimal amount of any of the substance, especially the extraordinarily low percentage of which might be carcinogenic (assuming you're taking reasonable precautions).

basically, so long as you don't like the smell, and god knows you shouldn't, you should be fine.

here's to happy, cancer-free cubing. :)
 
Back
Top