Dayan Lunhui is not competition legal?

As for the "new moves possible" you could say that a pop is a new move. If it's a bit pop you could (technically) swap to edges which is definately a "move" that cubes aren't supposed to be able to do. So we can't use cubes that can (possibly) pop?
 
As for the "new moves possible" you could say that a pop is a new move. If it's a bit pop you could (technically) swap to edges which is definately a "move" that cubes aren't supposed to be able to do. So we can't use cubes that can (possibly) pop?
No, it just means that if you have a poppy cube, you have to add on the time it takes to fix a pop when you solve with a pop.

Also:
5b2) During the repairing of the puzzle, the competitor must not intentionally make the position easier to solve than before the defect. Penalty: disqualification of the solve

It's not cheating if you know which corner twisted/edge popped, but if you are aware of it then that's the only piece you should fix.
 
Corners aren't supposed to be able to twist on their own. You think that accidentally having a corner twist then being able using it to your advantage makes it lucky?

As lng as the corner twist is purely accidental, yes. If it was intentional then it would deserve a DNF.
 
As long as the corner twist is purely accidental, yes. If it was intentional then it would deserve a DNF.
Couldn't that cause bad sportsmanship though? One could use a cube that he knows sometimes does corner twists on its own and hope that he'll get "lucky" so he can abuse the rules.

edit: My point is to keep the corner twisting defect rules in place (having to take it out and put in properly instead of being able to simply twist it back in place).
 
Last edited:
Couldn't that cause bad sportsmanship though? One could use a cube that he knows sometimes does corner twists on its own and hope that he'll get "lucky" so he can abuse the rules.

Yeah you would get a lucky case on one twist out of say 10 and just waste time with it on all other times it happens. What a great advantage.

edit: My point is to keep the corner twisting defect rules in place (having to take it out and put in properly instead of being able to simply twist it back in place).

And mine is to make people understand that it's just a stupid way of interpreting the rules.
 
How are people this dense?

What do you mean?

My point is to keep the corner twisting defect rules in place (having to take it out and put in properly instead of being able to simply twist it back in place).

Which rules are that? I actually can't find it. Closest one I see is this, and that's a "may" and *upper* limit rather than "must" and lower limit:

5b3) If after repairing the puzzle, but still during the solve, the competitor notices that the puzzle is unsolvable, he may disassemble and assemble max. 4 pieces to make the puzzle solvable again.
 
I agree with Dan that it's sad that we don't seem to be making any progress on improving the regulations anymore. It seems to me that this is one place where the regulations are inadequate.

As I see it, you can view twisting a corner as one of three things:
1. It is a standard move. It's pretty obvious that most people don't think of it that way, but theoretically, I guess it's a possibility, since most cubes allow it. I certainly don't like this answer.
2. It is a "new move" according to rule 3h. If this is the case, then most cubes violate the rules, and technically most solves should be invalidated. I don't like this answer either.
3. It is a puzzle defect. Imagine that the piece popped and then unpopped. It didn't come completely out of the puzzle, but in a way you could consider it to have popped. If this is the case, one could argue that twisting the corner constitutes popping and repairing it. I admit I'm not crazy about this answer either, but I guess I like it better than the other two.

So I guess my inclination is to say that the rules might be best interpreted to allow twisting a corner as a legal puzzle defect repair. Any comments or arguments?

I'm genuinely interested - if this ever comes up in a competition, I want to know what the right ruling would be.
 
If someone was to rotate a corner to force an easier OLL, wouldn't they have to rotate more than one corner to actually do anything useful since having one corner twisted is an impossible position to begin with? Even if they did twist say 2 or more corners, how much benefit could it possibly have?
 
If someone was to rotate a corner to force an easier OLL, wouldn't they have to rotate more than one corner to actually do anything useful since having one corner twisted is an impossible position to begin with? Even if they did twist say 2 or more corners, how much benefit could it possibly have?

I think one time I had an entire LL that was just two corners twisted. In that case, it might be faster to twist the two corners by force than to perform an alg to twist them. Admittedly an outlandishly rare case, but it's possible.
 
Another option:
in case of a 'non-possible' corner twist (one corner or two corners in the same direction) the cube could be considered unambiguously solved.

Question is then: do you allow stopping the timer with the corner still twisted of should the defect be fixed before stopping the timer?
I think I'm in favor of the first.
The latter leaves the possibility that a competitor quickly twists two remaining corners as described by Mike.

If you allow the timer to be stopped you are either 'unambiguously solved' or you have a DNF in case of a solvable two corner twist.
 
Another option:
in case of a 'non-possible' corner twist (one corner or two corners in the same direction) the cube could be considered unambiguously solved.

An interesting suggestion, but do the words "non-functional parts" exclude this possibility? I admit I'm not sure, one way or the other. I guess I also consider the word "functional" here ambiguous.
5b5) If, after the solve, non functional parts of the puzzle are still defect (like a centre cap of a cube) or not fully rotated (like a 5x5x5 centre piece twisted in its spot), but the puzzle is otherwise unambiguously solved, the puzzle is considered solved. (discretion of the main judge)

In any event, it feels inappropriate because then you could have the case I mentioned where the entire LL is two corners twisted - you could twist one corner in place to be correct and then stop the timer.
 
Last edited:
Current regulations indeed exclude this option, that is why I did not reference to 5b5 :-)

Your LL scenario is yet another resaon why it would be better to just stop the time without fixing.

Proposal In short: no corner twists allowed, puzzle is considered solved when there is an unsolvable corner situation left.
 
Current regulations indeed exclude this option, that is why I did not reference to 5b5 :-)

Your LL scenario is yet another resaon why it would be better to just stop the time without fixing.

Proposal In short: no corner twists allowed, puzzle is considered solved when there is an unsolvable corner situation left.

In order to require "no corner twists allowed", you mean that the puzzle cannot be capable of a corner twist? Otherwise the judge is responsible for watching for surreptitious corner twists, which is a pretty challenging requirement for judges. Keep in mind that judges are sometimes volunteer parents of competitors at small competitions - my opinion (for what it's worth) is that it's asking too much of judges.

And in general, I'm somewhat interested in proposals for how to fix the rules, but I guess I'm a little more interested in what the community as a whole thinks is the correct way to interpret the current rules. I want to know how to handle it if it comes up at the next competition.
 
Proposal In short: no corner twists allowed, puzzle is considered solved when there is an unsolvable corner situation left.

Uhhhhh no. Aside from the whole issue of the puzzle NOT BEING SOLVED, it can always be reduced to one twisted corner.

And in general, I'm somewhat interested in proposals for how to fix the rules, but I guess I'm a little more interested in what the community as a whole thinks is the correct way to interpret the current rules. I want to know how to handle it if it comes up at the next competition.

Define corner twists as puzzle defects, and clarify that you are allowed to fix them without removing any edges. Easy.
 
In order to require "no corner twists allowed", you mean that the puzzle cannot be capable of a corner twist?.
No, I mean the competitor is not allowed to twist corners in place.

Regadring judging: I think people should know enough about cubing and pay enough attention to be able to recognize something like this.

Afterall LL with 2 or more corners twisted in place do happen so corner twist cheats could already be reality.
 
Last edited:
Define corner twists as puzzle defects, and clarify that you are allowed to fix them without removing any edges. Easy.
I think this is my favorite approach to dealing with it under the current rules. If we don't like this as an interpretation of the rules, I think we need to change the rules.

Regadring judging: I think people should know enough about cubing and pay enough attention to be able to recognize something like this.
Operative word here is "should". Most judges have probably had moments where they're not watching the solver. (I admit that I too am unfortunately guilty of this sometimes.)

Afterall LL with 2 or more corners twisted in place do happen so corner twist cheats could already be reality.
Unfortunately, this is true. I thought of this after my last post - it is already theoretically a problem. If we go with David's interpretation of the rules, the problem is solved, and the only negative is some DNFs (such as Dan's) that perhaps shouldn't have been DNFs.
 
Back
Top