Vasseline Theory. Please leave feedback.

Boxcarcrzy12

Veteran
Joined
Apr 30, 2009
Messages
280
Location
Howell, MI
WCA ID
2009EDMO01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Ok, well as I'm sure you all know, vasseline "eats" you cube. Well I want to know what facts people have to show for this idea. The only even consiterable evidence is that there is tons of black gunk in the cube. But this black gunk is just plastic dust produced by breaking in the cube, whether the vasseline is there or not. The vasseline just acts as a "glue" to hold the plastic dustm becuase it has no where else to go. The cube gets loose over time because it has to move more than just internals, like putting sand in, it presses the parts apart stretching the springs and breaking it in. Just some food for thought. I find silicone will always be better, but just an idea that I thnk has some probablity behind it.
 
Last edited:
you could try taking some random edge (not from you fav. cube, of course ;) )
and put some vaseline on it. Then update us again in 1-4 weeks.

Ive done this, I put some in an edge (Gob) and on an edge, in a thin layer, and left them to set. When i cleaned them off there was nothing, no dust, and no thining of plastic. I did this for about 2 1/2 weeks,
 
I recently found some old cubes that have had vaseline in them for about 15 years. I cleaned them out and they were fine. The black gunk is, as you say, just the regular dust caused by friction mixed with the vaseline.

I use generous amounts of vaseline on my cubes and they do not melt or get eaten away by it. I have used it on Rubik's brand, some Type Cs, an Alpha F-II and a slew of other puzzles for many months on end.

I am confused by this supposed "petroleum dissolves plastic" thing. Plastic is made of petroleum. Vaseline comes in a plastic tub. If it dissolved plastic, it would not be a good substance to put on your hands. The label of a tub I have nearby doesn't warn about it being dangerous at all and even says it can be used "to care for babies' skin". And... it apparently has similar chemical properties to paint thinner? I don't buy that.
 
Last edited:
I put it in a store bought and left it in a year. I wiped it out and put in jigaloo. The cube is not ruined by any means.

Plenty of people put vaseline in storeboughts to break them in.


As for not melting the cube, I think the movement of the cube is what works the vaseline into the plastic and cases the damage. I had a storebought with vasline in and used it for a long time, and I must say that compared to other lubricants the amount of black dust that came out was unreal. One day the cube simply broke.

EDIT: After checking multiple sites on Google, I have determined that petroleum jelly melts latex.

Taken from Wikipedia:
"Petroleum jelly is commonly used as a personal lubricant. (Not recommended for use with condoms because it dissolves latex)."
 
Last edited:
I put it in a store bought and left it in a year. I wiped it out and put in jigaloo. The cube is not ruined by any means.

Plenty of people put vaseline in storeboughts to break them in.


As for not melting the cube, I think the movement of the cube is what works the vaseline into the plastic and cases the damage. I had a storebought with vasline in and used it for a long time, and I must say that compared to other lubricants the amount of black dust that came out was unreal. One day the cube simply broke.

EDIT: After checking multiple sites on Google, I have determined that petroleum jelly melts latex.

Taken from Wikipedia:
"Petroleum jelly is commonly used as a personal lubricant. (Not recommended for use with condoms because it dissolves latex)."



People use it with condoms all the time, but wiki isn't always the best source
 
I am confused by this supposed "petroleum dissolves plastic" thing. Plastic is made of petroleum. Vaseline comes in a plastic tub. If it dissolved plastic, it would not be a good substance to put on your hands. The label of a tub I have nearby doesn't warn about it being dangerous at all and even says it can be used "to care for babies' skin". And... it apparently has similar chemical properties to paint thinner? I don't buy that.

You say that something which dissolves plastic wouldn't be good to put on your hands. Sure? Solvents usually dissolve things because of a specific chemical property they have, and what's safe to touch has to do with an entirely different set of chemical properties. There's a plastic called PVA which will dissolve in water, and nobody would say water is harmful. Wikipedia also says that ABS (cube plastic) will dissolve in ketones (such as acetone, which is nontoxic in small amounts) and esters; these are quite large groups of chemicals. I couldn't find evidence of petroleum jelly dissolving ABS in a quick search, but that doesn't mean it doesn't do anything.

Anyway, my point is that it's wrong to think that being toxic or corrosive and being a solvent are the same. A lot of chemistry is due to interactions on the atomic level, and skin is microscopically totally different from inorganic materials.
 
I am confused by this supposed "petroleum dissolves plastic" thing. Plastic is made of petroleum. Vaseline comes in a plastic tub. If it dissolved plastic, it would not be a good substance to put on your hands. The label of a tub I have nearby doesn't warn about it being dangerous at all and even says it can be used "to care for babies' skin". And... it apparently has similar chemical properties to paint thinner? I don't buy that.

You say that something which dissolves plastic wouldn't be good to put on your hands. Sure? Solvents usually dissolve things because of a specific chemical property they have, and what's safe to touch has to do with an entirely different set of chemical properties. There's a plastic called PVA which will dissolve in water, and nobody would say water is harmful. Wikipedia also says that ABS (cube plastic) will dissolve in ketones (such as acetone, which is nontoxic in small amounts) and esters; these are quite large groups of chemicals. I couldn't find evidence of petroleum jelly dissolving ABS in a quick search, but that doesn't mean it doesn't do anything.

Anyway, my point is that it's wrong to think that being toxic or corrosive and being a solvent are the same. A lot of chemistry is due to interactions on the atomic level, and skin is microscopically totally different from inorganic materials.

WIN
 
I put it in a store bought and left it in a year. I wiped it out and put in jigaloo. The cube is not ruined by any means.

Plenty of people put vaseline in storeboughts to break them in.


As for not melting the cube, I think the movement of the cube is what works the vaseline into the plastic and cases the damage. I had a storebought with vasline in and used it for a long time, and I must say that compared to other lubricants the amount of black dust that came out was unreal. One day the cube simply broke.

EDIT: After checking multiple sites on Google, I have determined that petroleum jelly melts latex.

Taken from Wikipedia:
"Petroleum jelly is commonly used as a personal lubricant. (Not recommended for use with condoms because it dissolves latex)."



People use it with condoms all the time, but wiki isn't always the best source

And they're idiots.
 
Back
Top