7x7x7 Knockoff Rubikfans

  • Thread starter Thread starter grama
  • Start date Start date
G

grama

Guest
.......................

......................
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I agree with TomZ. You are clearly ignorant of the amount of time and effort that Verdes put into designing the cubes. He didn't just dream it up over night, it took years of working through, and probably cost thousands and thousands. Then you just shun off his work, and do what is convenient for you instead of doing the right thing. If anyone wants to get into an ethical debate then it's on, but look out because you will get slammed so bad.
 
It is bad because those people have made fake copies and are making money off of something that they didn't invent, and stealing money from those people who worked to earn it.

But you are supporting the people who are making easy money, which will eventually make the original v-cubes worthless, just the same thing that happened to the rubik's cubes, but that was acceptable.
 
Last edited:
It is bad because those people have made fake copies and are making money off of something that they didn't invent, and stealing money from those people who worked to earn it.

But you are supporting the people who are making easy money, which will eventually make the original v-cubes worthless, just the same thing that happened to the rubik's cubes, but that was acceptable.

why was it acceptable in the rubik's cube case?
 
What is the right thing to do? Why is it bad that people want to get copies of something? Because someone else "owns" the idea?

The right thing to do is to pay dues to the person that spent a great part of his life trying to get these made, so that you and me and everyone else can benefit from it.

you clearly didn't take the time to think a little more about his. There is absolutely no difference for Verdes Innovations, if i buy 1 v-cube 7 or, 1 v-cube seven + a knockoff, he is making the same amount of money.
An analogy to explain, if a movie comes out, you go to the cinema and watch it, then buy the dvd, and still download a pirate version, the company that made the movie doesn't lose any money for you downloading it, since you already gave them the profit the could get from you. I didn't want to discuss it, but calling me ignorant about verdes efforts makes absolutely no sense in this thread for what i've already said. This discussion already took place, and this thread clearly won't go the way i intended, so feel free to close ir, or delete it, i will not post further responses.

This analogy does not hold at all. Why would you ever buy the same DVD twice? That doesn't show that you have been a good person, it shows you're an idiot for buying the same DVD twice.
And of course he is making the same amount of money if you either buy 1 V7 and a knock-off, or just 1 V7. But he is losing money when the options are 2 V7s, or 1 V7 and a knock-off.
 
with rubik's it is acceptable for multiple reasons:
1: Rubik's already lost the patent and made enough money off it already in the years it had the monopoly (I mean, enough to cover the expenses of inventing the puzzle and a nice profit)
AND (unlike Verdes) still sells to "normal" people (normal as in not "power users")
2: Most (if not all) companies selling "fake rubik's" cubes have changed (and maybe improved) the design

I'll focus one 1b
Verdes has a smaller demographic (speedsolvers) and isn't sold in stores, so people choosing alternatives really hurt the company
 
Last edited:
Ok, i know i said i wasn't going to post anything further, but i just have to... here is precisely my point.

And of course he is making the same amount of money if you either buy 1 V7 and a knock-off, or just 1 V7. But he is losing money when the options are 2 V7s, or 1 V7 and a knock-off.

The thing is i would never buy 2 v-7, why would i want 2?, i bought the V-7 because i wanted a 7³ cube, and the knockoff just out of curiosity, if i ever wanted a second V-7 (so i would have the black and white pair for example) i would do so, and not the knockoff.
You are making the typical anti-piracy fallacy (not that i support piracy, just logical thinking), thinking that when a customer buys a copy of a product it's translated into money loss to the original company because it prevents from buying the original product. but that argument doesn't take into account that a more o less important number of the copy-buyers, wouldn't buy the original in the first place.

Verdes has a smaller demographic (speedsolvers) and isn't sold in stores, so people choosing alternatives really hurt the company

Same here, i didn't choose the alternative, because i BOUGHT THE ORIGINAL.
it was a reply to alan and tortin
 
The thing is i would never buy 2 v-7, why would i want 2?, i bought the V-7 because i wanted a 7³ cube, and the knockoff just out of curiosity, if i ever wanted a second V-7 (so i would have the black and white pair for example) i would do so, and not the knockoff.
You are making the typical anti-piracy fallacy (not that i support piracy, just logical thinking), thinking that when a customer buys a copy of a product it's translated into money loss to the original company because it prevents from buying the original product. but that argument doesn't take into account that a more o less important number of the copy-buyers, wouldn't buy the original in the first place.

Hang on, what? I've never heard of this made up fallacy. What you say doesn't make sense. You brought it because you were curious? That's just a lame excuse for "I wanted two 7x7s but I'm cheap".
As already stated in this thread, by buying knock-offs you are supporting a negative trend. By doing so you are indirectly taking money away from V-cubes. (Not that I actually believe your silly excuse).
 
Rubik's has a lot of money from his old monopoly of the market, and we do buy his DIY cubes. Mr. Verdes has patents and need all the money he can get if we want v-cubes 2, 3, 4, 6b, 8, 9, 10, and 11.

He has a much smaller market and a small buissness owner rather than a large corporation.
 
But he is losing money when the options are 2 V7s, or 1 V7 and a knock-off.

I would have to side with grama on this one. Buying the knock-off does not hurt Verdes directly. It simply generates more revenue for the knock-off maker. Assuming the ATC is less than MR, then he is making a profit and staying in business and being a competitor to Verdes. However, you really don't need to attack grama. He's done more to help Verdes than hurt him. At least he bought a V-cube, so he is helping Verdes a lot more than I am (I haven't bought a single V-cube yet). I believe his excuse of buying a knock-off out of curiosity; he definitely would not have bought 2 V-7. Buying 1 V-7 and 1 knock-off is better than buying nothing at all. Dene, it's silly to say that he is taking money away from Verdes. He is just supporting Verdes and the illegal competitor. Net profits for Verdes increase, but market share of Verdes is unchanged.

Edit: I'm not saying that I support buying knock-off V-cubes, just that your economics is flawed.
Emotionally, you might not agree with grama's choice. Other than that producing knock-offs is (*illegal* ?) in a country that doesn't care, it's tough to have a logic response that counters grama's argument.

I actually think an on-topic discussion of this thread would be worse than the action of buying the knock-off itself. A favorable review of the knock-off cube would definitely reduce the demand for authentic V-cubes.
 
Last edited:
okey, first of all, i don't want another discussion started about the ethics implicated in this cube existence, and/or copyrights/patents.

I want to discuss quality here, i bought one of these cubes (i also bought a complete V-cube set, so don't bash me about it). I want to know what other people think about this cube if they have one or at least tried one.

I don't speed with this cube, but i've solved it about 6 times, my first impressions were pretty good, feels really solid, the stickers are definitely better than v-cube original stickers (not that stickers are an important issue really). It's pretty smooth, a little tighter than my V-7, but i like that, in my V-7 the center pieces kind of "wobble" but in the R-7 (rubikfans-7 lol) every piece is just in place, you need to keep it better aligned in order to turn, but it's also harder to pop in my little experience with big cubes.

First my sympathy goes to Mr Verdes who invest a lot and help many cubers to give us a great puzzle. In the early days Mr Rubik had the same problem, but than a big company Ideal got the license and defend succesfully the brand name. Today this is still needed even for the Rubik brand. We live in this world where this is needed, I guess Mr Verdes Legal actions will take all there energy and attention and it is very difficult to fight a Chinese company as a foreigner.

We can help with not promoting this 7x7. btw I use Rubik DIY
 
Last edited:
I agree with OP as well. He bought a V-7. He wouldn't have bought another V7. There's no point. Sure, this did benefit an illegal copier. But I think in this case it's clear that Verdes hasn't lost a single sale due to Grama's purchase.

I still think, that funding a company that is using another persons invention, is wrong. Because if people keep buying KO 7x7s then the company will continue to produce them. Which will harm Verdes.
 
YES i bought it out of curiosity, to try it out, test quality, etc. why would i even want 2 of them????.
Now, the point you make afterwards, that's a logical point (arguable but at least it makes sense unlike before).
Now, for the remarks about being cheap and making up an excuse, i find that unnecessarily aggressive, offensive, and completely out of line when it comes to have a mature, logical discussion/debate about any kind of issue, no need for personal attacks ok? i haven't disrespected you in any way.

I can think of many reasons why you would want two of them. I always wanted to have two of them, which I do now.
And I'll be aggressive if I have to defend Verdes. People are stealing his ideas and you only support that and show that you have no care for market integrity, and show that you have no respect for what he has done, by purchasing that product.

fanwuq: as I say I do not believe his excuse that he was "just curious". It still makes no sense to me. "I'm going to go and stand on that mock bridge because I'm just curious to see how well it will hold up." And then you plummet to your death.
 
Back
Top