Personally, I have felt some pretty good florian modded SS 5x5s, and the Aochuang after 100 solves and lube is better than them. I have a pretty lockup-prone turning style on big cubes, and and lockups I may have on the Aochuang are minimal compared to what I would have on the SS. I'm wondering if some people just haven't taken the time to adapt to their Aochaung like I have. Also, I tried a few people's Aochuangs at comps, and they were not that great. Out of the box, the Aochuang simply isn't that great, it's scratchy, not very well tensioned, and slow. It's hard to put a finger on it, but my times were just bad when I first got it.
So I think that some people are expecting the Aochuang to be better than the cube that they are adapted to, have broken in, modded, lubed, and tensioned, without doing the same to the Aochuang. (With the exception of modding of course)
What I did to mine: about 160 solves, some maru and weight 1 lube, and minute tensioning. That made it great.