Shengen-FIII vs Dayan Guhong (poll)

[houngpong]

I'm deciding whether or not I want a Shengen-FIII or a Dayan Guhong DIY. I do have Lubix, and I can tension.
Can you guys help? Please stay on topic and not discuss something else like "they both suck, get a fangshi instead"
What are the pros and cons of both?

I really do like the Sheng-En FII (F2). It's bubbly, round, and smoother than something like a Zhanchi. Also awesome for one-handed.
How does the Shengen-FIII perform one-handed? Two-handed? How about the Guhong?

Oh, and I turn accurately; I use the F2 as my main so it really helped me learn that

 

[tx789]

All I know about the f-III is it's not as good as the f-II. Some people liked their f-ii more than their guhong. I prefer the f-II to guhong for oh but I like the zhanchi more. It's all your preference. Those these are old cubes and a lot of new ones are out.

 

[rj]

Guhong is good, but newer cubes are better. Try Moyu Weilong, Gans III, Maru CX-3, YJ Sulong, and Dayan Zhanchi.

 

[kcl]

Guhong is good, but newer cubes are better. Try Moyu Weilong, Gans III, Maru CX-3, YJ Sulong, and Dayan Zhanchi.

Eh guhong v2 is as good as those..

 

[XTowncuber]

I've not heard anyone say that the F-III is better than the F-II, so go for a guhong.

 

[TheNextFeliks]

I'm deciding whether or not I want a Shengen-FIII or a Dayan Guhong DIY. I do have Lubix, and I can tension.
Can you guys help? Please stay on topic and not discuss something else like "they both suck, get a fangshi instead"
What are the pros and cons of both?

I really do like the Sheng-En FII (F2). It's bubbly, round, and smoother than something like a Zhanchi. Also awesome for one-handed.
How does the Shengen-FIII perform one-handed? Two-handed? How about the Guhong?

Oh, and I turn accurately; I use the F2 as my main so it really helped me learn that

Guhong is good, but newer cubes are better. Try Moyu Weilong, Gans III, Maru CX-3, YJ Sulong, and Dayan Zhanchi.

Did you even read the original post?

On-topic:
I think the F2 is better than the FIII. Guhong vs. F2 is pretty close. Guhong is great cube. Some really fast cubers like Alex Lau use it still.

 

[DavidCip86]

I don't really have a lot of the new 3x3's, but I still like my guhong more than my fangshi and zhanchis

 

[Ninja Storm]

I haven't heard a single good word about the FIII. On the contrary, the Guhong is a great piece of cubing and will probably go down in history as the first cube of a generation.

 

[rudra]

FIII was my first speedcube, it was horrible. It always popped in 5 solves. Corner cutting is not good too. Don't get an FIII

 

[ducttapecuber]

Guhong v2 in my opinion is the best speedcube on the market.

 

[houngpong]

Guhong v2 in my opinion is the best speedcube on the market.

I think I saw your comparison of guhong v2 and guhong v1. Which would you say is better for OH?
and the shape, is the guhong v2 more "square" than the guhong v1? or are they both the same?