Old Zhanchi vs. New Zhanchi. Different plastic? All hype or fact?

Are older Zhanchi's "better" than newer Zhanchi's?

  • Yes

    Votes: 63 57.3%
  • No

    Votes: 47 42.7%

  • Total voters
    110
There are very few big cube shops in China. I get the cubes in China when my relatives come to Perth from several taobao shops. Go on taobao and search "zhanchi." There are lots of results and different shops that sell the ZhanChi. I contacted a small shop that sold the ZhanChi and they said that they don't sell many and that they have ZhanChi's from the original batches. For other shops, it could be complete luck.

I might have been lucky but in China, you have a higher chance of landing an OP ZhanChi.

You bought the "OP" zhanchi assuming it would be great. Now you think it's great. It's obvious that you're not a reliable source.

How is a small store that doesn't sell many cubes going to know it came from the original batch? All they know is that they got them a long time ago. Again, I believe they just gave you the answers you wanted in order to guarantee a sale.
 
I've decided this thread is pointless.

The 'true believers' are never going to entertain the idea of it being a placebo effect.

The 'skeptics' are never going to accept that the originals are better without a largish blinded study.

I'm out.

*wipes hands*
 
I have felt one briefly at a comp, it feels different to my zhanchi, yet I believe it is either a placebo effect (this one had the original plastic colour), or it was lubed differently to mine.

I wouldn't be surprised if they used slightly different plastic in mass production though.
 
Hhhmmm, it'd be interesting to really test this, but I can't come up with any experiment designs that don't lend themselves to a bunch of biases.

I have a feeling it's mostly about the way they're assembled, tensioned and lubed, though. I've got two Zhan Chi, both the old ones (actually, one's supposed to be a prototype), and even though they're both amazingly fast, they feel quite different, probably because I assembled one of them.

I kind of agree withcube-o-holic that this discussion probably won't get anywhere, though XD
 

I set up an experiment to test this plastics fiasco. Unfortunately, I only got 8 people at World Championships :( (too busy with my events)
I would like to see other people design these experiments too.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

I set up an experiment to test this plastics fiasco. Unfortunately, I only got 8 people at World Championships :( (too busy with my events)
I would like to see other people design these experiments too.

Awesome video! I really thought the new one was the old, I thought it was softer lol. I don't think I'm a believer anymore :p xD
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm glad someone finally did a blind test. However, I have something like ~6 zhanchis and they all feel different to the point that I could identify each of them without looking at them. I'm sure that if I took 2 of them and then told people that one of them was an "OP" zhanchi, they would perceive them as being different (which I agree, they are different) and one is staggeringly better than the other. I totally agree that there's variation among zhanchis, and among all cubes of a certain make for that matter. I just don't believe in some mythical rare zhanchi that's better than the rest. It's not unusual that what's rare is also generally perceived as better, that's the nature of our psychology. I don't think it's actually true.
 
Original zhanchi identification (core and mech)

i have 2 zhamchis, one is old and broken and has a opaque core and was bad and the other is my main and is really good and smooth and has a translucent core (not totaly transparent) and the core is more white. is there a different core in original plastic zhanchis to more newer ones? i bought the bad one in early 2013 and the new one more recently but the person who sold it to me had it for ages
 
IDK but I also have both cores. The two cubes were very different, the one w/ the opaque tannish core was smoother but slower (though I think it was more broken in), the creamy white core one was faster and also has weird texturish patches on some of the edges, and the plastic is less shiny. I don't know if that means anything.
 
How can you even tell the core makes a difference in speed? It stays fixed without any motion...
 
I have 3 different types of ZhanChi, and they are definitely not "all hype". It's so tiring hearing about this subject because people can't seem to accept that there are more than one kind of ZhanChi, in terms of plastic feel. It's not even like it's a tiny difference, either. They are some pretty noticeable differences.
The very first kind that ever was released was only around a matter of a couple of weeks. This was the kind I got with my pre order (and this is not including the prototypes). This very first kind was really cheap feeling, very "thin and light" allowing effortless turning and cutting, literally. This was, by far, the best kind, but because it was so fragile, it was changed to a harder grade of ABS.
This second kind is what most people today think of as the original because this is what most people first received, since there seemed to be so few of the first kind. This is the kind that CBC has, I have a couple, and most other people who have what they think is an original I have yet to see another one of the first kind, other than the one I own. This upgrade was still very thin, cheap, and light feeling, but not nearly as cheap as the first kind (this exact same "upgrade" was made with the LingYun v1's as well). Because of this harder and slightly heavier plastic, the cube isn't quite AS fast as the real original, but still very fast compared to the new laggy, slow, heavy ones, made with PC.
The new ones (ABS/PC) are by far, the heaviest and bulkiest feeling of the 3. Lube doesn't seem to help much with these, at least not for very long, and they lock up quite a bit compared to the other 2, which are incredible.
If you MUST get a ZhanChi today, do yourself a favor and buy the 55mm. It is much better than the 57's you can get today. The plastic in the 55mm seems to be the same as the plastic used in the megaminx and 2x2. Not sure how its different from the ABS/PC, but it is.


How can you even tell the core makes a difference in speed? It stays fixed without any motion...

The core has NOTHING to do with the change in feel. It's the plastic of the cube. The old cores (pure white ish) were not only used in the originals, but were in the new ones for a while, up until the GuHong v2 came out, which then the core changed. And to the guy above you, there is no original plastic LunHui. The only person that I know of, who has ever used that term, is Womack. LunHuis seem to be the ONLY Dayan (not including the v2's or PanShi) which never changed. It's been a while since I've bought one though, so I may just get one to find out for sure.

IDK but I also have both cores. The two cubes were very different, the one w/ the opaque tannish core was smoother but slower (though I think it was more broken in), the creamy white core one was faster and also has weird texturish patches on some of the edges, and the plastic is less shiny. I don't know if that means anything.

That one with the weird texture / less shiny, is one of the originals. Not sure if its the first or second kind, but that's one of them.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top