Old Zhanchi vs. New Zhanchi. Different plastic? All hype or fact?

Are older Zhanchi's "better" than newer Zhanchi's?

  • Yes

    Votes: 63 57.3%
  • No

    Votes: 47 42.7%

  • Total voters
    110
In basic terms, I'm saying that there has to be some legitimate reason for the existence of the rumor, but a lot of people are saying it's completely blind and illogical.

No, in basic terms, you're saying that the existence of a rumor suggests that there is a legitimate reason for the rumor. Which is completely illogical. If there IS a legitimate reason to believe that there is a difference in plastic, then use THAT to support your argument. Don't say that the fact that a rumor exists means that there's a legitimate reason for the rumor. It's circular reasoning. I still haven't heard a legitimate and objective argument to support the "old is better" side of things. It's all "it feels better", "one is smoother through my computer speakers", or "this person contacted someone who knows someone that heard something and they said that it's true and everyone else is a straight up liar, also nobody would be saying it if it wasn't true, so obvious it's true".

I believe that there's a difference in plastic among ALL batches of cubes. If this didn't coincide with a slight change in cores, and wasn't overblown by YouTube, nobody would notice. I have a ZhanChi that I am positive that I could convince someone is an old plastic version. Why? It feels slightly smoother than the other ones I own, and the hype has created an expectation that will skew people's perceptions. It's why people think organic fruits taste better, when any objective study would show that there is no discernible difference to us.
 
Not again. They are different. I have 3 old ones, and several new ones. All the new ones suck. They get slow and the old ones just don't. The old ones are lighter (you don't need to turn them to notice a difference). They feel cheaper. They are much smoother and faster, even if the old ones are brand new (which 2 of mine are), and they don't lock like the new ones. The new ones feel fat and heavy. In light, you can see differences in the color. There are definite changes in the plastic. If you aren't able to notice them, you have poor attention to detail.
And to the person who thinks it's placebo.... I originally bought one when they were very first released, in July 11. In November 11, I bought my second one and noticed it was much crispier and just different overall. After buying a few more, and getting a few more old ones, I realized it was a plastic difference. No one told me, and I feel I was one of the first to even notice, at least out of people that I know. There are several other people that agree, who know what they are talking about. Its not placebo.
For the guy with all the Eeee's in his name, let me explain it this way:
The Gu Hongs started with one type of plastic, then it changed a few months later to what you get today.
The Gu Hong v2 has an even different plastic than the new v1 plastic.

The Ling Yun v1 and Lun Hui have the old, good plastic.
The Ling Yun v2 has the crappy, new plastic.
The Zhan Chi started out with the good plastic, (however, the old white ZCs is NOT the same plastic as the old white Gu Hongs, yet, it is still better than the new white ZCs)
and now has the crappy, new plastic.
My guess as for why it has happened this way is this:
As the Gu Hong and Zhan Chi started, they were made with a soft, cheaper plastic, and as they grew in popularity, they upgraded the plastic to a more expensive, sturdier plastic.
The Ling Yun v1 and Lun Hui never changed because they never really became that popular, therefore, there was no reason to upgrade to make them sturdier.
 
Last edited:
Everybody hast their own opinion. Feliks is an extraordinary cuber, but his opinions shouldn't apply to everyone unless they made that decision on their own. It's all preference. A better feeling cube can influence a person to practice more, to get faster, to improve. It's all up to the individual.
 
The term 'observational bias' comes to mind.

There is no significant difference because of the plastic.
I bought 2 DIY 55mm ZhanChis when they 1st came out. I assembled them at the same time, in the same way and used the same lube in the same places in the same quantities. They felt completely different.
 
I bought 3 Zhanchi at the same time, right after they were released. One of them is incredibly smooth and fast (my main). The second is really great but feels heavier, the third feels like it's made of really bad plastic and it feels lighter that the other two.

IMO it's just a matter of luck because every single cube is different !

Edit : All of them are white.
 
The term 'observational bias' comes to mind.

There is no significant difference because of the plastic.
I bought 2 DIY 55mm ZhanChis when they 1st came out. I assembled them at the same time, in the same way and used the same lube in the same places in the same quantities. They felt completely different.

I think the others are discussing 57mm ZhanChis.
 
They are incredibly better, so much so, in fact that I will never buy a new ZC ever again. I have 2 new ones and they just turn into garbage. All 3 of my originals are still going strong, and actually, I have 2 different kinds of original ones. I have the one I very very first got with the pre order, which is different to one that was from later on that same month. I have 2 black ones and one white one. The white one is like the second black one I got. I am not willing to sell them because they are my favorites, but I'm just letting it be known that there are 2 different kinds. Most people only seem to have the second kind though. They are all shown in this video. There is a short intro where I beat the crap out of an old man and steal his fig newtons, then the ZCs are after that, before the reviews.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=98_4uV55x6U

And I really hate this poor attention to detail people seem to have, or just plain disbelief that they exist. There is a HUGE difference, there is no mixing up the different ones.
You don't even have to turn them to know they are originals or new ones. The new ones are much sturdier and heavier / bulkier feeling. The originals are super fast with no effort while the new ones stay fast for a short time and just kind of die out and feel like garbage, with lockups. I could sit here blindfolded, have a thousand people put ZC's into my hands, and I'll tell you which ones are old and new before I even turn them. You can also see the difference by looking at the pieces. The old ones have a more solid, darker black color, while the new ones have this light black, with grey swirls thing happening.

Side story on how I originally realized there was a change:

First off, I should say that my first pre order, original original ZC I had first. The second type of original from later that month and the white one which is the same as that second type, I bought much more recently from other people. The black one came from Phil Yu of the Cubicle and the white one was from izovire who still had some whites left from his first batch.
So, I bought my original ZC and it was great, smooth, fast, effortless to use (and I'll mention here that I tension ALL of them the EXACT same)
I had it starting July 2011, and wanted to try my first Lubix cube, so in November 2011, I bought a ZC from Lubix. I got it and it was really hard and scratchy. I thought, "wow, the Lubix cubes really do feel different!" No one ever told me there were different plastics, no one even mentioned this before I brought it up to CBC (I got him his original from the same Phil Yu batch which was originally sold to Aryn Scheulkin (Modcuber)).
After about 2 months, my Lubix ZC started to wear out, so I went back to using my first one. I couldn't believe how different they felt. Then, I realized, my old one was still really good, but my brand new Lubix one was crap. I ordered another ZC from a regular store, unmodded, etc. It felt exactly like the Lubix one. Then, it hit me, the plastics were different. That's why my first one is so much better. That's why the Lubix one felt different. Not because it was modded, but because it was changed.
** I will admit, the white ones are harder to tell apart. The new white ones are really good, but still sturdier and heavier feeling than the old ones. Also, the old white ones are a solid, bright, pure white, while the newer ones are an off white / grey color.
 
Last edited:
Looking for an Original Plastic Zhanchi

Blah blah blah

It's because of ridiculous posts like these that people are willing to pay through the nose for original ZhanChi's.

I have new, original, coloured and mini ZhanChi's.

They all, like all other cubes, start to feel a bit worse when it's been a while since they've been cleaned, tensioned and lubed.
Once you've done that they feel like much better cubes again.

I also bought 2 55mm DIY ZhanChis at the same time, built, tensioned and lubed them exactly the same and guess what, they felt completely different.

Ps I liked the bit where you said your new ZhanChis turn into garbage. Cute.
Try solving a Rubik brand cube straight out the box and compare it to your 'garbage' ZhanChis. Even compare them to Alpha Vs and F2s.
 
Last edited:
It's because of ridiculous posts like these that people are willing to pay through the nose for original ZhanChi's.

I have new, original, coloured and mini ZhanChi's.

They all, like all other cubes, start to feel a bit worse when it's been a while since they've been cleaned, tensioned and lubed.
Once you've done that they feel like much better cubes again.

I also bought 2 55mm DIY ZhanChis at the same time, built, tensioned and lubed them exactly the same and guess what, they felt completely different.

Ps I liked the bit where you said your new ZhanChis turn into garbage. Cute.
Try solving a Rubik brand cube straight out the box and compare it to your 'garbage' ZhanChis. Even compare them to Alpha Vs and F2s.

Ask anyone who has ever trusted my opinions on anything if I've ever been wrong. I have a very trusted opinion for many people, because I have a serious attention for detail.
And I've never had to clean or relube any of my originals. Only the garbage new ones.
When I say garbage, I'm not comparing them to brand new Rubik's brands. Hell, I even have a Rubik's brand that isn't bad. It cuts 45 and I can sub 12 with it. I am also a huge fan of ALL of the Alpha cubes and the first 2 type F cubes. There's absolutely nothing wrong with them. I know what I'm talking about because I own all of these cubes and have been studying and comparing them for a few years now. This is why people trust me. A ZC should not feel like the new ones. Sorry.
 
Last edited:
Looking for an Original Plastic Zhanchi

So you want me to ask someone who trusts your opinion if they trust your opinion?

Your opinion can't be 'trusted' to be true. After all it is just an opinion. Do a double blinded study and I'll trust the results.

What I do know is a new ZhanChi is one of the best, if not the best cube, you can buy new. Your opinion could cost people money unnecessarily.
 
So you want me to ask someone who trusts your opinion if they trust your opinion?

Your opinion can't be 'trusted' to be true. After all it is just an opinion. Do a double blinded study and I'll trust the results.

What I do know is a new ZhanChi is one of the best, if not the best cube, you can buy new. Your opinion could cost people money unnecessarily.

No no, I would never ask anyone to pay loads of money for any cube. Are they better than new ZC's? YES, by far. Are they worth more than new ZC's? Yes, because they're harder to find. I even just recently had someone offer me $100 for one of mine, but I can't get rid of them because they are THAT good. Even the original plastic Gu Hongs and Ling Yun v1's are better than new ZC's. They're all great cubes that you can rarely find nowadays, and therefore, priceless to me.
 
Looking for an Original Plastic Zhanchi

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree. My collection in running into the several thousand dollar range now and I would never buy a previous version of a puzzle for well over the odds just because some people's opinions of them are high. I have original GuHongs, LingYuns, ZhanChis and a couple of SS4 V IIIs I would never sell for a high price because it is just perpetuating an unproven belief IMO.
 
Last edited:
I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree. My collection in running into the several thousand dollar range now and I would never buy a previous version of a puzzle for well over the odds just because some people's opinions of them are high. I have original GuHongs, LingYuns, ZhanChis and a couple of SS4 V IIIs I would never sell for a high price because it is just perpetuating an unproven belief IMO.

Then would you sell them for the regular prices then? I also don't see how Shengshous are relavant in your argument.
 
Not planning on selling them. I tend to give puzzles I don't use anymore to friends who I've taught.

SS4 version III is regarded by some as the best SS post modding I think. Some people seem to be willing to pay crazy money for them.
 
Back
Top