Should I get an 11x11 or 9x9 cube?

Status
Not open for further replies.
http://bucks.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/10/28/the-legality-of-buying-knockoffs/

After reading this and a few other articles the conclusion seems to be that, morality issues aside, you are fine buying knockoffs. Just don't sell them. This also follows common sense pretty well. (If you are in the US, at least)

Ya i read this article. Pretty much, a knockoff is not illegal, since it does not have symbols or labels that are exactly the same (counterfeit) and just resemble the original. These are legal to buy. It is also legal to buy counterfeit goods, but illegal to sell them, unlike what you said above, you can sell knockoffs, just not counterfeit. So, in conclusion:
IT IS OK TO BUY KNOCKOFF CUBES SO STOP WORRYING ABOUT IT!!!! IF IT IS A COUNTERFEIT THEN DON'T! BUT SERIOUSLY YOU HAVE TO BE A LAW STUDENT IF YOU ARE GOING TO UNDERSTAND IF IT IS ILLEGAL OR NOT (if you're picky) SO IT IS OK PEOPLE!!
 
Last edited:
It's just as illegal to buy as it is to sell knock-offs. But a $90 knock off children's toy is unlikely to cause any legal problems for you. By "unlikely" I mean "it's not going to happen". On the other hand, if you buy a knock-off piece of industrial equipment for $30,000,000 you're setting yourself up for legal excitement.

My point is that from a practical point of view, it's not possible for an amateur to determine whether most of these cubes are knock-offs or not. Because of that, your liability in buying them is quite small. That is, they can't sue you for more than the royalty. That would be something like $15 on a $90 puzzle and that's not enough to pay for a lawyer.

A lot of people have gotten in big trouble for stealing music using bit torrent and stuff like that. The reason you can get into trouble that way is because it is blatantly illegal so if you lose a lawsuit you may have to pay punitive damages. But when the lawyers come after you with a puzzle, they can't sue you for more than the amount owed in royalties. And since Verdes hasn't sold any 11x11s, how can they even figure out the damages? It's just not possible for them to make money suing people who could not possibly have been aware that what they were buying was infringing on a (seriously complicated and difficult to understand) patent. There wouldn't be any punitive damages and the actual damages wouldn't be enough to pay for a single legal letter.
 
Last edited:
It's just as illegal to buy as it is to sell knock-offs. But a $90 knock off children's toy is unlikely to cause any legal problems for you. By "unlikely" I mean "it's not going to happen". On the other hand, if you buy a knock-off piece of industrial equipment for $30,000,000 you're setting yourself up for legal excitement.

My point is that from a practical point of view, it's not possible for an amateur to determine whether most of these cubes are knock-offs or not. Because of that, your liability in buying them is quite small. That is, they can't sue you for more than the royalty. That would be something like $15 on a $90 puzzle and that's not enough to pay for a lawyer.

A lot of people have gotten in big trouble for stealing music using bit torrent and stuff like that. The reason you can get into trouble that way is because it is blatantly illegal. So when the lawyers come after you, they can't sue you for more than the amount. And since Verdes hasn't sold any 11x11s, how can they even figure out the damages? It's just not possible for them to make money suing people who could not possibly have been aware that what they were buying was infringing on a (seriously complicated and difficult to understand) patent. There wouldn't be any punitive damages and the actual damages wouldn't be enough to pay for a single legal letter.

I agree. What I meant was you really aren't gonna get in trouble over a CUBE. Then it is pretty much SAFE (ya thats what i meant... wow im a slow thinker..) to sell and buy...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top