Newb Review of nine 3x3x3 cube order from popbuying

Streakist

Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2010
Messages
20
Location
The BUTT of California
This review is my (a newb’s) first impressions of nine 3x3x3 cubes purchased from Popybuying.com. I’m hoping this is a useful resource for those like me that are new and wondering which cube to buy. I had a hard time with this decision so I decided to buy quite a few based on the favorites of some of the folks on this board. The FII, Ghosthand, YJ II and mini C came pre assembled, the rest I lubed fully disassembled with Jigaloo prior to assembly. I didn’t put a grade for pops as I generally don’t run so loose as to allow for pops, I’ve always felt it’s better to err on the side of caution with regards to pops.

FII
Resistance to lock ups: 9.5
Ability to cut corners: 8.5
Speed: 8
Comments: Feels smooth, like butter. Probably my favorite because it seems very consistent, there isn’t anything that bothers me about it. It’s not the fastest cube but it seems to be the smoothest and least prone to lock up. It’s just amazing out of the box with no need to break it in, which is a major plus.

Ghosthand
Resistance to lock ups: 8
Ability to cut corners: 8
Speed: 7.5
Comments: Feels like an FII but with more friction feeling, but not so much friction that it slows it down. Really a nice cube though, almost as good as the FII, maybe as good once it’s broken in. It locks up a bit more than the FII but it has a really nice feel to it.

Taiyan/Dayan
Resistance to lock ups: 8.5
Ability to cut corners: 9
Speed: 9
Comments: Feels like an FII only less smooth and more rough/bumpy. It is very fast and seems to lock up less than the Ghosthand. I think this or the Ghosthand will end up being my second favorite after I break them in.

YJ II
Resistance to lock ups: 6
Ability to cut corners: 8
Speed: 10
Comments: This thing is blazingly fast, like easy 180 degree single finger turns fast. It locks up badly and often which is probably from the cheap core/springs/screws. This thing is nothing similar to a type D like the original YJ 3x3x3 was, it’s more like a cheap FII. I’ll probably try to mod it to get rid of the locking problem.

Mini Type C 50mm
Resistance to lock ups: 6.5
Ability to cut corners: 4
Speed: 7
Comments: Does it cut corners well? No. Is it a bit locky? Yes. Is it still awesome cause it’s small, fast and fits nicely in my pocket? Of Course!

Type C
Resistance to lock ups: 7
Ability to cut corners: 7
Speed: 7.5
Comments: Feel’s like a really fast/good storebought. It’s fast and semi prone to locking up, less than the YJ II though. I feel this might get better with use, much like a storebought.

Haiyan Cube
Resistance to lock ups: 7.5
Ability to cut corners: 8
Speed: 9
Comments: This cube kinda sucks. It feels really cheap and my core (like many others) was defective. I had to boar out one of the holes to get the screw to go in far enough. Plus the center caps are just an awful design, you have to take your cube apart to remove them. This and the Type A both feel kind of wrong in my hands, they are so different from a storebought that I don’t think I’d recommend them for newbs, but maybe I’ll grow to like them in time.

Type AV
Resistance to lock ups: 7
Ability to cut corners: 8
Speed: 9
Comments: My initial reaction is that this cube is not for me, but I can see why some people like it. It’s super fast, which is nice but it locks badly. I fully intend to do the Haiyan Memory mod to this right away, so I’ll reply on how that went later. One interesting thing is that it came with and extra ultra tiny blue core in addition to standard yellow core. It's in the attached picture, I assume this was by mistake, anyone know what it’s for?

C4Y
Resistance to lock ups: 5.5
Ability to cut corners: 6
Speed: 8.5
Comments: I hate this cube. The cubies are terrible blocks that lock all the time. I fully expect this core will be consumed in some hybrid experiment in the near future.
 

Attachments

  • photo(2).jpg
    photo(2).jpg
    111.9 KB · Views: 80
Last edited:
It seems like you don't like the C or the C4U, but if you take the C4U core, screws, and springs (make sure to put them in backwards) to the C, it will be much better than the original. That's what I'm doing, and my C4U will just be a cube I bring to school and let others use.

On topic, it's good to have a review, because you were able to compare all of the cubes to each other. Thanks for typing it out!
 
Last edited:
Streakist;343350[B said:
Haiyan Cube[/B]
Resistance to lock ups: 7.5
Ability to cut corners: 8
Speed: 9
Comments: This cube kinda sucks. It feels really cheap and my core (like many others) was defective. I had to boar out one of the holes to get the screw to go in far enough.
About the core, same problem for me : I used a drill ! :D
 
It seems like you don't like the C or the C4U, but if you take the C4U core, screws, and springs (make sure to put them in backwards) to the C, it will be much better than the original.

Thanks, I'll try that today!

Well, I tried that and it made one hell of a cube. I instantly like it much better than either of the cubes in their pure state. It's still no FII but it's definitely in the top 4 now...
 
YJ II
Resistance to lock ups: 6
Ability to cut corners: 8
Speed: 10
Comments: This thing is blazingly fast, like easy 180 degree single finger turns fast. It locks up badly and often which is probably from the cheap core/springs/screws. This thing is nothing similar to a type D like the original YJ 3x3x3 was, it’s more like a cheap FII. I’ll probably try to mod it to get rid of the locking problem.
It seems that you disliked the YJ for the same reason I did. The lockups were making me want to pull my hair out, and I thought it was just me not being used to a faster, speedier cube. It also had pops, like, I couldn't even do the sexy move fast without a pop. But give it time to break in, because now it is really smooth and doesn't pop, before you mod it, and possibly hurt the design of a great design. Nice review, btw :)
 
Well, I tried that and it made one hell of a cube. I instantly like it much better than either of the cubes in their pure state. It's still no FII but it's definitely in the top 4 now...

:) You're welcome. Now I can't wait untill mine...

I'm totally content with my C, but if it can be any better... That and my FII will jockey for 1st place.
 
Last edited:
YJ II
Resistance to lock ups: 6
Ability to cut corners: 8
Speed: 10
Comments: This thing is blazingly fast, like easy 180 degree single finger turns fast. It locks up badly and often which is probably from the cheap core/springs/screws. This thing is nothing similar to a type D like the original YJ 3x3x3 was, it’s more like a cheap FII. I’ll probably try to mod it to get rid of the locking problem.

Did you adjust the tension at all or just leave it as is? I bought 5 YJ's and they all locked up and felt like they were going to pop until I tightened them. Tightening them magically transformed them into an ok cube for a beginner.
 
It seems that you disliked the YJ for the same reason I did. The lockups were making me want to pull my hair out, and I thought it was just me not being used to a faster, speedier cube. It also had pops, like, I couldn't even do the sexy move fast without a pop. But give it time to break in, because now it is really smooth and doesn't pop, before you mod it, and possibly hurt the design of a great design. Nice review, btw :)

I've since tightened the YJ quite a bit, it still locks but not nearly as much. I'll go ahead and break it in before I do anything crazy. I think you're right, sandng would probably mess up the texture of the plastic and slow it down/ruin it.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top