When are the new V-cubes coming out? (2, 3, 4, 8+)

How long will it take?

  • 1~4 weeks

    Votes: 3 3.5%
  • 1~3 months

    Votes: 3 3.5%
  • 4~6 months

    Votes: 5 5.8%
  • 6months~1 year

    Votes: 11 12.8%
  • 1year+

    Votes: 64 74.4%

  • Total voters
    86
Status
Not open for further replies.
The v12 is not possible with the current Design. The middle edge width becomes too great or something along those lines. There would need to be a slight tweak in the design in order to accomplish this, as a 12x12 would require a 13x13 mechanism.
 
they just have to make it more spherical and some of the middle edges would be tiny, but mathmatically it can be done according to what i've figured from verdes' site.
 
The v12 is not possible with the current Design. The middle edge width becomes too great or something along those lines. There would need to be a slight tweak in the design in order to accomplish this, as a 12x12 would require a 13x13 mechanism.
If I recall correctly, the problem is that the middle edge is twice the size of the smaller edges on a 12x12. I don't know exactly what mechanical problems this would cause though.

For the record, the highest order cube that can be made cube shape using conventional methods is a 20/3 x 20/3 x 20/3

Then why does the VCube site state that they cannot make 12x12x12

Because 12 is bigger than 20/3...
 
I would love for someone to show me where they say that they can't make a 12x12x12... I remember the line being 'an unlimited number of layers...'
 
I would love for someone to show me where they say that they can't make a 12x12x12... I remember the line being 'an unlimited number of layers...'
They don't. Rather, they say that it becomes less practical to go over an 11x11x11. From the European patent:
[0022] The practical reasons why the present invention finds application up to the cube N=11 are the following:
a) A cube with more layers than N=11 would be hard to rotate due to its size and the large number of its separate pieces.
b) When N>10, the visible surfaces of the separate pieces that form the acmes of the cube lose their square shape
and become rectangular. That’s why the invention stops at the value N=11 for which the ratio of the sides b/a of the
intermediate on the acmes rectangular is1, 5.
So the puzzle will start looking more distorted beginning with 12x12x12.

And while we're at it, let me bring up a couple of other points. First, I wish people would stop saying, "I wouldn't want an 11x11x11 because one that big would be almost spherical." Not true. From the patent:
from N=7 to N=11 the six solid faces are no longer planar but spherical, of long radius
compared to the cube dimensions, the shape of said spherical surfaces being almost planar, as the rise of the solid
faces from the ideal level, is about 5% of the side length of the ideal cube.
So the 11x11x11 is essentially the same shape as the 7x7x7 and all the other cubes in between. And I like the shape of the 7x7x7, so I'm sure I'll equally like the shape of the others. (You can also see this from the pictures in the patent - all of the cubes from 7x7x7 up have approximately the same shape.)

And another thing, I hadn't seen this (again from the patent):
[0181] It is suggested that the construction material for the solid parts can be mainly plastic of good quality, while for
N=10 and N= 11 it could be replaced by aluminum.
They seem to be implying that plastic couldn't handle the stresses on the really big cubes. That's kind of disappointing - I wonder how well aluminum would really work.
 
I would love for someone to show me where they say that they can't make a 12x12x12... I remember the line being 'an unlimited number of layers...'
They don't. Rather, they say that it becomes less practical to go over an 11x11x11. From the European patent:
[0022] The practical reasons why the present invention finds application up to the cube N=11 are the following:
a) A cube with more layers than N=11 would be hard to rotate due to its size and the large number of its separate pieces.
b) When N>10, the visible surfaces of the separate pieces that form the acmes of the cube lose their square shape
and become rectangular. That’s why the invention stops at the value N=11 for which the ratio of the sides b/a of the
intermediate on the acmes rectangular is1, 5.
So the puzzle will start looking more distorted beginning with 12x12x12.

exactly... and also, there's really no point to anything larger than 11x11x11. Can you imagine how long edge pairing would take?
 
http://twistypuzzles.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=10225
That thread makes a very brief mention of a problem in creating a 12x12, but I am unable to find the math behind this. I know I've seen it before, maybe on the old olympiccubes site?

Wow, best story I've seen in a long time. Thanks!

By the way, my white V5,6,7 set just came in today, and it was the best quality shipment I have gotten from them (I've had 3 shipments in total). They all had perfect tension (not too loose), and this time all stickers were placed perfectly. There were minor bubbles under some stickers, but still I would rate the cubes 10 on a scale of 10.
 
The v12 is not possible with the current Design. The middle edge width becomes too great or something along those lines. There would need to be a slight tweak in the design in order to accomplish this, as a 12x12 would require a 13x13 mechanism.
If I recall correctly, the problem is that the middle edge is twice the size of the smaller edges on a 12x12. I don't know exactly what mechanical problems this would cause though.

For the record, the highest order cube that can be made cube shape using conventional methods is a 20/3 x 20/3 x 20/3

Then why does the VCube site state that they cannot make 12x12x12

Because 12 is bigger than 20/3...

And seven isn't?
 
The v12 is not possible with the current Design. The middle edge width becomes too great or something along those lines. There would need to be a slight tweak in the design in order to accomplish this, as a 12x12 would require a 13x13 mechanism.
If I recall correctly, the problem is that the middle edge is twice the size of the smaller edges on a 12x12. I don't know exactly what mechanical problems this would cause though.

For the record, the highest order cube that can be made cube shape using conventional methods is a 20/3 x 20/3 x 20/3

Then why does the VCube site state that they cannot make 12x12x12

Because 12 is bigger than 20/3...

And seven isn't?

And the 7x7 isn't cube shaped...
 
He mentioned how the technology isn't capable of creating puzzles larger than the 11x11x11 (or 12, I'm not sure) whatsoever, pillowed or not. He was asking why they can't make puzzles >12.

"The solution to the present invention finds applications up to the cube N=11"
- From V Cube website.
If he meant just cube puzzles, then they would have said N=6.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top