Why is 7x7 round?

I've only seen stuff like Stephan's diagram and the video which only talk about the corner being fully exposed over the edge.
Yes. On all three inner sides (the diagram only shows it for one side). How do you connect the stalk if the corner cube is cut off on all three inner sides?
 
I've only seen stuff like Stephan's diagram and the video which only talk about the corner being fully exposed over the edge.
Yes. On all three inner sides (the diagram only shows it for one side). How do you connect the stalk if the corner cube is cut off on all three inner sides?

Yea, it makes sense. When I see a diagram like what you posted I don't really imagine what the stalk would look like on the inside. I see a line going over the edge, but that's as far as I imagine. I do see the problem now.
 
As Stefan and others point out, it is impossible to make a cubical 7x7 with every layer the same size (without using some kind of tricks, like Etienne de Foras's 7x7 which bulged out when you did an outer layer turn). However, it is possible to make a cubical 7x7 with thicker outer layers - in fact, the thicker the outer layer (in proportion to the rest of the cube), the more stable the corners can be. That is because a thicker outer layer allows you to use a thicker corner stalk.

The problem is that having such a thick outer layer will significantly increase the size of the puzzle (or else significantly decrease the size of the already-tiny center pieces). For 7x7x7 this is not a huge problem, but the larger the cube gets, the larger the outer layers will have to be. On an 11x11x11 you would have to make them about twice as wide for the mechanism to even function! That begins to not only look kind of ugly, but also put a lot of stress on the pieces (because the spindly stalks are now carrying these huge boxes).

Verdes's answer to this problem was pillowing. Although it might look like the centers are being pushed out - and this is typically how pillowing is done on the small cubes (which don't need to be pillowed at all) - what is actually happening is that the corners, edges, and most of the centers have effectively been shaved down. Thus, instead of having an extra-wide outer layer, it seems to be about the same size as the other layers, and ends up rounded. The height of the center-centers show the true width of the outer layers. Pillowing also has the nice effect of making the puzzle more comfortable to hold when it becomes large.
 
Back
Top