Why is 7x7 round?

GalPro

Regular
Joined
Dec 31, 2008
Messages
98
Hi,
I once saw a video on youtube showing the math behind the round shape of the 7x7,

does anyone have a link to it?

ty
 
The way I see it a V7 could be made with flat sides. Just imagine adding plastic to the cubies on a pillowed V7 until you get flat sides. It could be done. However there would be more stress and a bit too much flexibility at the extremities if it were not pillowed. I would worry about its stability.
 
I didn't know that or thought of that. Thanks for that information!
 
The way I see it a V7 could be made with flat sides. Just imagine adding plastic to the cubies on a pillowed V7 until you get flat sides. It could be done. However there would be more stress and a bit too much flexibility at the extremities if it were not pillowed. I would worry about its stability.

It would be just as stable as the 6x6. I imagine that I would almost prefer the longer edge length, rather than the pillowedness. Past 7x7 though, I think it would get too ridiculous. I wonder if someone who has some experience with putty would be willing to do this?
 
I do recall seeing a thread similar to making a cubic 7x7 by casting parts for extra wide outer layers.

It was somewhere on twistypuzzles a few months back, however, i was unsure if anyone did it.
 
I've been using these two mathematical expressions to explain why a corner of a cube would fall off if cube is bigger than 6x6x6.
6x6x6: 2 x sqr2 < 3
7x7x7: 2,5 x sqr2 > 3,5

Peedu
 
Here's a picture I just drew to illustrate the problem (click it to enlarge). Wanted to do this for a while already.
 

Attachments

  • 7x7x7_round_reason.PNG
    7x7x7_round_reason.PNG
    27 KB · Views: 52
I still don't fully understand why a corner going slightly over the edge is such a huge problem. Can someone elaborate?

I can hold my V6 from just a corner that has an exposed stalk and there's pretty much no chance of it coming out, unless the whole cube goes with it.

I know I'm wrong here. I just need someone to point out the error I've made that I've never been able to see.
 

Attachments

  • DSC00517.JPG
    DSC00517.JPG
    142 KB · Views: 24
  • DSC00520.JPG
    DSC00520.JPG
    132.6 KB · Views: 20
I still don't fully understand why a corner going slightly over the edge is such a huge problem. Can someone elaborate?
I can hold my V6 from just a corner that has an exposed stalk and there's pretty much no chance of it coming out, unless the whole cube goes with it.
I know I'm wrong here. I just need someone to point out the error I've made that I've never been able to see.

The problem is very, very simple. As you can see on your V6, while there is little chance of the corner coming off, you can see that the stalk or stem holding it in is quite thin. The problem is that for 7x7x7 and higher, the thickness of this stem goes below zero. Now there's your problem!

Now you might say, why can't I make the stem any thicker? The answer to that is a bit more complicated. The problem is that for the cube to function, there need to be certain symmetries. The simplest way to view it is that the internal geometry of the cube needs to be circular (or conical, spherical...). Making the "circle" larger makes the stem thicker, but for a 7x7x7 to be made you need the circle to go outside the cube. V-Cubes solve this problem by changing the proportions slightly and adding extra material to the cube to have it approach a sphere. You can obviously make the circle slightly "stretched". This is done on the floppy cube where the faces flex slightly to allow for the pieces to pass.
 
Last edited:
I still don't fully understand why a corner going slightly over the edge is such a huge problem. Can someone elaborate?
I can hold my V6 from just a corner that has an exposed stalk and there's pretty much no chance of it coming out, unless the whole cube goes with it.
I know I'm wrong here. I just need someone to point out the error I've made that I've never been able to see.

The problem is very, very simple. As you can see on your V6, while there is little chance of the corner coming off, you can see that the stalk or stem holding it in is quite thin. The problem is that for 7x7x7 and higher, the thickness of this stem goes below zero. Now there's your problem!

ok thanks, I could see that being a pretty big problem :)

I've never heard it explained like that. I've only seen stuff like Stephan's diagram and the video which only talk about the corner being fully exposed over the edge. Maybe I was just completely misunderstanding the argument all along.
 
I can hold my V6 from just a corner that has an exposed stalk and there's pretty much no chance of it coming out
Yeah. Because the V6 works.

Look at the circle under your thumbnail in your picture. That's below the blue surface. The bottom of that corner cubie is still further below. But if you look at my drawing, with a 7x7x7 made of cubes, it would be outside, *above* the blue surface. How are you going to turn your imagined stalk *through* the blue surface?
 
Back
Top