Kian
Master
- Joined
- May 22, 2008
- Messages
- 2,476
- Location
- East Brunswick, NJ
- WCA ID
- 2007BARR01
- YouTube
- Visit Channel
unless for BLD solving.
Why not, exactly? Do different rules apply?
They can be in practice. For example, the WCAhas declared that a Meffert's 4x4 with the original tiles is ok for speedsolving, but not for blindsolving because of the 4 engraved logos.
Those logos are on the corners, right? So wouldn't it be fine to do BLD if you were using different corners? I still don't really understand this. I also now can't see why the mefferts are legal for speedsolving if they have engravings that will allow you to tell similar pieces apart just from touch.
I'm not sure if you've seen a Meffert's 4x4, but it might make more sense if you do. The logos are engraved on one corner on every side. They're not really visible unless you take your time and look very closely. That would mean, then, that they are not dissimilar during speedsolving because you don't have the ability to take advantage of the difference. However, in blindsolving, it could play a crucial role. It could provide information to the solver that they may have forgotten or incorrectly memorized and clearly affect the solve. I think that's basically the logic.
To be honest, I didn't even notice the engravings until someone mentioned them. I can see them when I pay attention, but I have absolutely no idea which are engraved when I'm speedsolving.
I think it's just a question of dissimilarity and advantage, basically. It provides basically no advantage because it is dissimilar when speedsolving, but could present an advantage when blindsolving.
Edit: And yes, you can sticker the mefferts or use tiles without the engraving, that is absolutely legal for blindsolving.