Legal 4x4?

PeterNewton

Regular
Joined
Mar 3, 2009
Messages
166
i bought a 'new 4x4' from c4y and during lubrication with crc, some of the corners got stuck to the core (i have no idea why). i ended up wrestling with it for a bit and it resulted in 2 of the corners breaking.
so i ordered 8 rubiks corners from cubesmith and it seems that the rubiks corners fit in quite well, but they are very slightly smaller than my broken ones. oh and they are also slightly more rounded.
my question is, would this cube be legal in competitions?
the rules say:
Puzzles must be clean and must not have any textures, markings, elevated pieces, damages, or other differences that distinguish one piece from a similar piece.
what is your interpretation of the rules?
note that i have replaced all 8 corners.
 
could you post a picture?

my first answer would be that it's legal, since all corners are the same

i wish i could put up a pic, but my camera is at school.

the thing is, the rubiks corners are maybe 1/10 of a millimeter smaller in each dimension. but since they are also more rounded, they look like 1/2 a millimeter smaller in each dimension. so in the end, it looks like the edges and centers are elevated by a lot even though its only 1/10 of a millimeter.

edit: its just for regular speedcubing.
 
People can assume that you feel for the elevated and unelevated corners.

I just don't see how that's an extra advantage if they are all the same, and least an advantage that doesn't apply to speedsolving also.

Edit- Peter, I think the rule says that elevated pieces are not allowed only if they can be used to distinguish pieces from other similar pieces, which isn't the case.
 
Last edited:
ok thanks guys, thats a relief. because i did NOT want to buy from that ******** rubik/james guy from c4y again. i am so done buying from him. even if diys g through z come out and he is the only one selling, i will not even go near his site.
again, thanks.
 
The WCA shouldn't have any problems unless the corners are easy to distinguish from each other just by feeling them. If it's easy to tell a corner from an edge, there's no real problem. So the WCA will be fine, just look out for the DEA.
 
Corners and edges are not similar pieces, and people have made hybrid cubes where the edges and corners have different colored plastic. It's perfectly legal.
 
ok thanks guys, thats a relief. because i did NOT want to buy from that ******** rubik/james guy from c4y again. i am so done buying from him. even if diys g through z come out and he is the only one selling, i will not even go near his site.
again, thanks.

May I ask why? To me it sounds like you overlubricated/used the wrong lube and were absurdly ungentle, since breaking corners should be quite hard to do, if not your lube weakened the plastic. My 4x4x4 from c4y turns really nicely after I loosened the screw and lubed it.
 
[/QUOTE]May I ask why? To me it sounds like you overlubricated/used the wrong lube and were absurdly ungentle, since breaking corners should be quite hard to do, if not your lube weakened the plastic. My 4x4x4 from c4y turns really nicely after I loosened the screw and lubed it.[/QUOTE]

well it was my first time using crc so i must done something wrong. (off topic: is it normal for crc-lubed cubes to have some parts of the plastic turn white??)

i duno, even when i first popped out the corners, i was quite surprised at how weak the bond between the main part of the cubie and the curved triangular part was.

also, we may be thinking of different cubes. when i loosened the screw on my one, the two sides of the ball core kept spinning away from each other with the slightest turn.
this is the one i bought: http://cube4you.com/427_New-4x4x4-Cube(Black).html
 
Regarding the CRC fusing your pieces together, this is typical and always a concern with cubes bigger than 3x3. You need to twist very, very soon after applying until the propellant has dried enough that the pieces will no longer stick together. I had that happen to my Rubik's Professor (5x5). I took it apart no problem, and separated the fused pieces, but when I reassembled it I broke a corner piece. (UGH!) I hope to superglue it someday, if I cannot find a replacement piece. In the meantime my V-5 and Eastsheen 5x5's are great.
 
unless for BLD solving.

Why not, exactly? Do different rules apply?

They can be in practice. For example, the WCAhas declared that a Meffert's 4x4 with the original tiles is ok for speedsolving, but not for blindsolving because of the 4 engraved logos.

Either way, that's certainly legal, it's no different than a hybird with different edges and corners.
 
unless for BLD solving.

Why not, exactly? Do different rules apply?

They can be in practice. For example, the WCAhas declared that a Meffert's 4x4 with the original tiles is ok for speedsolving, but not for blindsolving because of the 4 engraved logos.

Those logos are on the corners, right? So wouldn't it be fine to do BLD if you were using different corners? I still don't really understand this. I also now can't see why the mefferts are legal for speedsolving if they have engravings that will allow you to tell similar pieces apart just from touch.
 
Back
Top