GAN X vs Xv2 ?

JohnnyReggae

Veteran
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
578
Location
Cape Town, South Africa
WCA ID
2015BOSW01
I'm looking for some feedback from those that have or have tried both the GAN X and GAN Xv2. I use the X as my main and have since it came out. I do have the XS but don't like it as much as the X. The XS has a similar feeling as the SM had which I'm not all that fond of compared to the Air and X.

Is it worth upgrading to the Xv2 ?
 
I'm looking for some feedback from those that have or have tried both the GAN X and GAN Xv2. I use the X as my main and have since it came out. I do have the XS but don't like it as much as the X. The XS has a similar feeling as the SM had which I'm not all that fond of compared to the Air and X.

Is it worth upgrading to the Xv2 ?

If you're not a fan of the XS, it is probably best not to get the XV2. It uses the same core as the XS and therefore would have a very similar feel to the XS. What is it that you don't like about the X, I am sure we can recommend something that would be considered an upgrade.
 
None of them, jump and get a Moyu cube, Gan cubes are very similar to one another.
Not interested in Moyu or any other brands at the moment. I used various cubes from the host of manufacturers and I prefer the feel of the GAN cubes.

If you're not a fan of the XS, it is probably best not to get the XV2. It uses the same core as the XS and therefore would have a very similar feel to the XS. What is it that you don't like about the X, I am sure we can recommend something that would be considered an upgrade.
I find the feel of the XS to be quite "springy' for want of a better word. Turns click into place even with weaker magnet settings and it ends up being quite noisy despite the claim that it is quieter than the X. The X on the other hand is much smoother, turns don't "click", and it's quiet ... er ...

I love the X and was wondering if the Xv2 was a genuine upgrade of the X or just another GAN release. Similarly I love the GAN Air and still use my DIY magnetised one so I'm intrigued with the new GAN Air M, but again I'm not sure it is a genuine upgrade of the original or just another repackaged XS.
 
Not interested in Moyu or any other brands at the moment. I used various cubes from the host of manufacturers and I prefer the feel of the GAN cubes.


I find the feel of the XS to be quite "springy' for want of a better word. Turns click into place even with weaker magnet settings and it ends up being quite noisy despite the claim that it is quieter than the X. The X on the other hand is much smoother, turns don't "click", and it's quiet ... er ...

I love the X and was wondering if the Xv2 was a genuine upgrade of the X or just another GAN release. Similarly I love the GAN Air and still use my DIY magnetised one so I'm intrigued with the new GAN Air M, but again I'm not sure it is a genuine upgrade of the original or just another repackaged XS.

My XS with setup and lubrication is not too loud. It must just depend on turning style or setup. Feel free to have a look here to see if it is a setup thing. The springiness may be due to a loose spring compression. I haven't used the XV2 before, but I personally wouldn't see it as an upgrade, especially since you don't like the springiness of the XS adjustment system.

I would recommend giving a MoYu cube a try. If you like the feel of GAN cubes (smooth, fast and light), you probably won't like the feel of cubes from companies such as Qiyi, but with MoYu, there is some good overlap with cubes.

Alternatively, if you haven't already, you can try experimenting with different setups, magnets, lubricants to try and create a new feel. The GAN X is a great cube, but if you feel as though you're in need of an "upgrade" it might be worth giving something new a try.
 
If you are debating between the X and the XV2, based off of your previous "review" of the GAN X, I would stay with it. The XV2 just changes the core, and not much else. There's also a chance you might not like it, as it is a bit similar to the XS, which you stated you didn't like. The X is my main over the V2 and the XS, and I understand why you wouldn't change to the XS. Just stick with the X, but try the V2 if you want to.
 
My XS with setup and lubrication is not too loud. It must just depend on turning style or setup. Feel free to have a look here to see if it is a setup thing. The springiness may be due to a loose spring compression. I haven't used the XV2 before, but I personally wouldn't see it as an upgrade, especially since you don't like the springiness of the XS adjustment system.

I would recommend giving a MoYu cube a try. If you like the feel of GAN cubes (smooth, fast and light), you probably won't like the feel of cubes from companies such as Qiyi, but with MoYu, there is some good overlap with cubes.

Alternatively, if you haven't already, you can try experimenting with different setups, magnets, lubricants to try and create a new feel. The GAN X is a great cube, but if you feel as though you're in need of an "upgrade" it might be worth giving something new a try.
With the XS I've played around with all sorts of tensions and settings and settled on medium magnets, light blue 3, and 3 clicks spring compression. That's about the best setup feel that I like I can come up with. ITO lube I generally only use Silk in GAN cubes.

ITO Moyu I have a bunch of them ... Weilong v2, Aolong v2, Hualong, Tanglong, Aolong GT, Weilong GTS, GTS2, GTS3 .... Don't like the GT2 or GTS3, so I'm not venturing into anything new from Moyu as I assume the WRM has a similar feeling to the GTS3. The Moyu I do like the feeling of is my Aolong V2, probably because it's the one cube that still has the single most number of solves on.

Interested to see what the Air M is like.
 
With the XS I've played around with all sorts of tensions and settings and settled on medium magnets, light blue 3, and 3 clicks spring compression. That's about the best setup feel that I like I can come up with. ITO lube I generally only use Silk in GAN cubes.

ITO Moyu I have a bunch of them ... Weilong v2, Aolong v2, Hualong, Tanglong, Aolong GT, Weilong GTS, GTS2, GTS3 .... Don't like the GT2 or GTS3, so I'm not venturing into anything new from Moyu as I assume the WRM has a similar feeling to the GTS3. The Moyu I do like the feeling of is my Aolong V2, probably because it's the one cube that still has the single most number of solves on.

Interested to see what the Air M is like.
core swap the X and XS. The X with the XS core is literally an Xv2 without frosted plastic
 
With the XS I've played around with all sorts of tensions and settings and settled on medium magnets, light blue 3, and 3 clicks spring compression. That's about the best setup feel that I like I can come up with. ITO lube I generally only use Silk in GAN cubes.

ITO Moyu I have a bunch of them ... Weilong v2, Aolong v2, Hualong, Tanglong, Aolong GT, Weilong GTS, GTS2, GTS3 .... Don't like the GT2 or GTS3, so I'm not venturing into anything new from Moyu as I assume the WRM has a similar feeling to the GTS3. The Moyu I do like the feeling of is my Aolong V2, probably because it's the one cube that still has the single most number of solves on.

Interested to see what the Air M is like.
The air m is the xs without interchangeable magnets. If you don’t like the springiness of the xs, the Gan digital ges nuts are less springy than the ones that come with the xs.
Another option is to buy a lot of budget magnetic cubes like the meilong m, ms, yupo v2m, thunderclap v3m, guhong v3m, etc, so that you can buy a lot of cubes with different feels without spending a bunch of money on each.
 
Interested to see what the Air M is like.
It's just an XS without changeable magnets. That's literally it, no other differences whatsoever. Also, the X v2 is the exact same cube as the X just with a different core so you are wasting your money if you buy the v2 since you already have the v1.
 
Back
Top