[WR] Kabyanil Talukdar 3BLD 27.63 mean

[aashritspidey]

Kabyanil Talukdar from India broke the WR mean with a mean of 27.63 and also got an NR single of 25.78
http://www.cubecomps.com/live.php?cid=677&cat=16&rnd=2

Edit: It's not WR mean because the judge forgot to keep the paper underneath the cometitior's eyes and he was given a resolve. I however think that the WR mean should stand

 

[Faz]

It says 28.57 mean though?

Still, congratulations!

 

[aashritspidey]

Cubecomps Entry error :'(

 

[Lazy Einstein]

Congratulations!

 

[aashritspidey]

Apparently he got 31,25,25 but the judge forgot to put the cover on the last solve. What an idiot

 

[amostay2004]

Apparently he got 31,25,25 but the judge forgot to put the cover on the last solve. What an idiot

How does that add 3 seconds to his time though?

 

[aashritspidey]

How does that add 3 seconds to his time though?

He had to be given a resolve

On further enquiry, It seems that the last solve was a 25 but the judge didnt place a paper in front of him during execution. Why is that not a legit solve?

 

[DeeDubb]

On further enquiry, It seems that the last solve was a 25 but the judge didnt place a paper in front of him during execution. Why is that not a legit solve?

Because rules are more important than fairness.

 

[Hari]

On further enquiry, It seems that the last solve was a 25 but the judge didnt place a paper in front of him during execution. Why is that not a legit solve?

I second this.. I have seen other solves with the same incident occurring(Angel Lim's 29BLD comes to mind first) and none of those were scrapped/given resolves.. On a sidenote, many congrats to Kabyanil He'll come back better and take the WR next time hopefully.. Guess it's also time to change my sig

 

[ottozing]

I second this.. I have seen other solves with the same incident occurring(Angel Lim's 29BLD comes to mind first) and none of those were scrapped/given resolves.. On a sidenote, many congrats to Kabyanil He'll come back better and take the WR next time hopefully.. Guess it's also time to change my sig

Angel Lim's no paper incident was only caught after the fact. Since the incident with Kabyanil was caught at the comp, it was dealt with then and there accordingly.

 

[Akash Rupela]

Angel Lim's no paper incident was only caught after the fact. Since the incident with Kabyanil was caught at the comp, it was dealt with then and there accordingly.

Even if after an event, if it was against rules it should have been DNF'ed like many other good solves. Strictness on rules is not unfair, inconsistency is!

 

[Iggy]

Well done Kabyanil! That incident on the last solve must really suck though :/

 

[Hari]

Even if after an event, if it was against rules it should have been DNF'ed like many other good solves. Strictness on rules is not unfair, inconsistency is!

Precisely. Couldn't have been put better and I know how you feel after your 6.91 was scrapped..

 

[CuberPanda]

Angel Lim's no paper incident was only caught after the fact. Since the incident with Kabyanil was caught at the comp, it was dealt with then and there accordingly.

Are you implying that,after a competition ends, A record that is found to be 'illegal' can stay?

 

[aashritspidey]

Lets wait for the video. Hopefully it should get reversed and get the WR back

 

[DeeDubb]

Angel Lim's no paper incident was only caught after the fact. Since the incident with Kabyanil was caught at the comp, it was dealt with then and there accordingly.

This is very inconsistent with previous issues of similar nature. When something is caught after the fact (wasn't there a misscramble that cost someone a NR a while back?), it seems to be constently DNF'd, even if the competitor should have received a new attempt.

 

[mns112]

This is very inconsistent with previous issues of similar nature. When something is caught after the fact (wasn't there a misscramble that cost someone a NR a while back?), it seems to be constently DNF'd, even if the competitor should have received a new attempt.

Indian NR single by Akash Rupela(he's up there in the comments)

 

[ottozing]

To everyone disagreeing with my statement, just know that I'm not saying I think it's right, but that it's how it goes in a situation like this.

 

[c4cuber]

Lets wait for the video. Hopefully it should get reversed and get the WR back

here is the video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qY-gVWRw33g&list=UUHARg8y7id1NR5sIEiuSb7w

the video is uncut...the error is on the last solve

 

[aashritspidey]

Guys the video is here. It's Unedited from first to last. Board members please look at it and decide