What makes a speedcube 'good'?

guysensei1

Legend
Joined
Nov 24, 2013
Messages
5,143
Location
singapore
WCA ID
2014WENW01
If this is the wrong section to post in, mods feel free to move it.

Basically, I was wondering, from an engineering standpoint, what about the mechanism of modern speedcubes makes them 'better'? I can understand how a weilong is superior to a Rubik's Brand cube, but I can't figure out why a weilong might be superior to a zhanchi, or why the panshi was such a bad cube. Any thoughts?
 
It depends on your skill level.

For a beginner, a good speed cube is one that is slower and very controllable.
For an intermediate, a good speed cube is one that is fast but yet is also controllable.
For an expert, a good speed cube is one that is blazing fast.

For all levels, good corner cutting (lockup prevention) and anti-pop mechanisms are critical.

From an engineering perspective, the best beginner and intermediate cubes tend to have cylindrical designs while expert cubes tend to go with a more conical design, at least in 3x3's.
 
Last edited:
It depends on your skill level.

For a beginner, a good speed cube is one that is slower and very controllable.
For an intermediate, a good speed cube is one that is fast but yet is also controllable.
For an expert, a good speed cube is one that is blazing fast.

For all levels, good corner cutting (lockup prevention) and anti-pop mechanisms are critical.

From an engineering perspective, the best beginner and intermediate cubes tend to have cylindrical designs while expert cubes tend to go with a more conical design, at least in 3x3's.

What makes you think an expert wants a blazing fast cube? I'm sub 9 but I prefer a more controllable cube.
 
What makes you think an expert wants a blazing fast cube? I'm sub 9 but I prefer a more controllable cube.

What makes me think that is the fact that I fall into the beginner/intermediate range and therefore I don't know for sure what fast cubers like.

I would also like to point out that what is controllable to a sub 9 solver probably isn't controllable to a 50 second solver or a 30 second solver.
 
I don't think different skill levels require different cubes. I started on a Zhanchi and moved between that and an Aolong even when I was only ~45 seconds.

Really a "good" cube is a cube that you prefer using. But if you wanted a more quantitative measurement of a "good" cube, I would say your times. Do large averages with different cubes and compare the times, this should be a good indicator.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top