Why is it G perm gets such mixed reviews?

[esquimalt1]

Don't mind them.

 

[Faz]

I wuv G perms.

Especially the ones with the opposite colours

 

[Tim Major]

I love all except for one of them. G perm c (name on Wiki)

It's probably just because I have a really bad alg for it.

 

[Hyprul 9-ty2]

I love all the G perms. I hate left hand R perms.

Edit: Like Fazrulz says, opposite colors!

 

[Lucas Garron]

If you ever practice 2-sided PLL recognition, the R2u... G-perm, its mirror and AUFs will really annoy you. Everything els eis really nice, but those 8 are the ugliest and most confusing compared to the others -they have few distinguishing color features, and subtle stickers matter much to distinguish them (compared to, say, an H-perm, which is really easy from all angles).

And if you don't practice 2-sided recog, the same difficulty is still there.