Type C III Review -- not bad, but not good either

daniel0731ex

Master
Joined
Dec 10, 2008
Messages
2,294
So I got this Type C III a couple months ago in a test-review giveaway on the MF8 forum, but never had the time to actually write it up. I decided to just play with it a little longer before making up my mind.

First impression
First thing I noticed when I take it out of the box is that the size is slightly smaller than the average 5.6cm lengths. It is approximately 5.5cm on each side, and although this doesn’t seem like much difference on paper, it is quite noticeable when you are actually playing with it. Adjusting the tension until all pops and lockups disappear, I noticed that the turning isn’t as fast as I’d have preferred. This kinda disappoints me, because I expected it to be a good OH cube with its small size. But it is good enough as a speedcube, plus the speed of a cube isn’t everything anyway. The corner-cutting of this cube is good, with forward being exactly 1 piece max (which most cubes could do with proper tuning) and 1/4 piece for reverse (which is quite good for one with the classical mechanism and not having tracks). With the tension I have, lockup and pops are pretty much of zero possibility, though this is already a mandatory requirement for proper tensioning in the first place. The cube itself is actually quite solid, compared to many DIYs having a “deformable” frame.

Mechanism Analysis
Looking at the interior, like many other recent cubes the C3 this cube has a reduced interior radius (to enhance corner-cutting), and the corner and edges have some plastic shaved off to reduce weight. The edge pieces have some circular edges (or should I call them “stoppers”?) filling the hollow side, which stops the center pieces from catching onto the edge, contributing to the smoothness by eliminating the “crispy” feel of the original Type C. The center pieces have indents similar to the A5 to reduce contact surfaces and thus turning resistance.

The molding quality of this cube is extraordinary; the best of what I have ever seen besides the C4U DIY. You couldn’t find any flashes or even abrupt molding lines and the plastic surface is relatively smooth. The only complaint I have in terms of the quality is that the center caps falls off very easily, which I noticed is because the plastic tabs are slightly bent inward, making it useless. This one is a test model, so it seems that they have corrected it in the final version.

One thing to note is that this cube no longer uses the Type C’s traditional thin black screw with wide teeth. This time the screws are similar to Alpha’s (Thick small-headed screw with big + small washer and fine teeth), but you could easily tell one from another if you put the two together. The biggest difference is that there are a bit of “buffering length” (not sure what it’s called exactly) at the tip of the screw like ones on the C4U cube. This makes sure that when you assemble the fittings the screws are perfectly aligned with the core (which has been a big problem especially with Type C’s old black screws). However, even if the screws are aligned to the core, if the core itself has misaligned screw holes it’s still pointless. So this time they have a new core with the cube. The core has a opaque brown-white color and slightly conical shape on the arms (similar to the ones in the 国佳 cube). The conical shape is actually from the “fleshing-out” at the center of the core where the core arms connect. The thickness of the screw makes a stable frame, and with the good core-screw alignment this resulted in a solid cube.

The spring that comes with this cube is also different. Instead of the old short, soft springs, they are longer this time. This is probably the main reason why it’s not a very fast cube. Taking off the washers would help, but you must sand down the sides of the spring, otherwise it’ll deteriorate like a V-Cube. I’d have preferred changing the springs to the ones in the C1, but I don’t have extra springs lying around at the moment.

Lubrication and Maintenance
I suggest washing the factory oil off first when you get the cube and use silicone sprays or thick silicon. This cube does not seem to like Maru lube because it’s relatively tight, so you’ll need stronger lubes.

Rating
Tolerance: 8/10
Speed: 7/10
Solidness: 10/10
Stability: 9/10
Smoothness: 10/10
Reliability: 10/10
Handling: 9/10 (a bit small for 2H)

Comment
Don’t be tricked by the ratings because, I am actually a bit disappointed with this cube. Although there are all these designs that should theoretically make a cube good, when they put it together the result just isn’t spectacular. Despite all the neat little details on this cube, they just don’t seem original enough to give me a new impression. There is no sense of innovation in this cube, and even as a “wrapping up” of previous successful designs, it just didn’t meet my expectation. In every way, this cube makes me feel that it’s “just like any other cube”

I would recommend it if you are looking for you first decent speedcube. But if you are looking for some fun with this cube, I doubt you'll find any.

Conclusion
It’s a Rubik’s cube.
 
Last edited:
That's a shame...I ordered one of these on Monday :o(
Thanks for the review though. If there had been one earlier, I wouldn't have purchased the cube...
 
I'd like to agree with everything you've said.

It's the same with my C-III, quite a disappointment.
I've played a bit with the tensions since I've gotten mine, and I still have issues with lockups.

It's quite a shame because the pictures of the internals looked so nice too.
 
I'd like to agree with everything you've said.

It's the same with my C-III, quite a disappointment.
I've played a bit with the tensions since I've gotten mine, and I still have issues with lockups.

It's quite a shame because the pictures of the internals looked so nice too.

I have no lockup problems on my C3 at all and the corner-cutting is great. It's just that this cube just doesn't give me a fresh feel.
 
Back
Top