Smooth Mod for “New” GuHongs

VReality

Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2011
Messages
2
Cliff Notes:

An almost superficial treatment smooths out the action of the “new” GuHongs:

“I took the emery board to all the little interior knobs, lips, and surfaces. Not enough to round them over or change their shape at all; just enough to micro-texture the interior locking and sliding surfaces. And it has completely transformed the feel of the cube.”​


The Long Story:

I'm not a speed cuber by any stretch of the imagination. I just like quality. So when I decided to learn cube solving again, I went looking for the best cubes.

At the time, the alpha series seemed to be on the verge of a new release, so rather than buy a soon to be second-best, I went with the F-II. Suffice it to say that apart from the factory stickers I was very pleased. Other cubes have generally not lived up.

I actually bought a GuHong because, after having a particularly bad experience with a highly touted sticker provider who shall remain nameless (turns out Maru tiles are better anyway), I noticed that DaYan's design allowed them to make a six-color, stickerless version of the GuHong.

I believe the cube I got is polyoxymethylene (POM). I've never had an ABS version or any other to compare it too.

Suffice it to say that despite the fact that it cuts corners like a dirty politician, never, ever pops, doesn't really lock, and turns really fast, for some reason it still felt terrible; almost unusable.

I think that, when it was all aligned, it would turn so easily that it was constantly misaligning and overshooting. And despite the fact that sufficient torque could always “cut” it back into alignment, with normal turning it always seemd to “stick” on the slightest misalignment.

And it felt “rattley”. Thinking that rattling, overshooting, and misaligning were symptoms of being too loose, I tightened it down to the point that I couldn't even disassemble it, and it still felt rattley. There was just something very wrong, and I didn't quite know what it was.

I noticed that compared to the F-II, all the edges between interior and surface faces were sharp and square, so I took an emery board and rounded most of them over, ever so slightly. This seemed to improve it a lot, but looking back, I couldn't really figure out why, since it would still stick in much the same way, and I couldn't see how those edges were involved.

But the action continued to improve over time, to the point where it's corner cutting, and refusal to pop or really lock up made it the cube I used most. It didn't feel anywhere near as nice as the F-II, but it was just more forgiving.

Then I ran across a thread here with an off topic discussion of the different plastics used in the GuHong over time, and the cube's real issue sort of hit me.

This plastic has a sort of “glassy” finish. If you hold it at the right angle to see a specular glare off it's surface, you can see that it's a bit uneven and wavy, but that glare tells you that at a smaller, more microscopic scale, its relatively smooth.

When two such surfaces press against each other they get lots of surface area contact which causes them to stick together and resist sliding. But when not pressed together or when already sliding over each other, they present very little friction. As a result, the cube faces overshoot when you turn them, and freely misalign when there's no pressure, and when they are misaligned and you try to turn them, they press together and like to “stick”.

So my initial mod eliminated contact at the very edges, but perhaps more importantly, it roughed up the interior surfaces which were still touching. This both reduced the sticking effect when misaligned, and reduced misalignments by adding a tiny bit more friction. And I think this is also why the cube was slowly improving. Working it out roughed up the interior surfaces ever so slightly, over time.

So on that theory, I took the emery board to all the little interior knobs, lips, and surfaces. Not enough to round them over or change their shape at all; just enough to micro-texture the interior locking and sliding surfaces. And it has completely transformed the feel of the cube.

There's no more “rattley” feel, and it's super smooth. It's not quite as fast turning as it was before, but the faces adhere a little more when you're not turning them, so they fall out of alignment less, and they resist turning a lot less when they are misaligned and get pressed together. Add to that the cube's corner cutting and anti-popping/locking qualities and it's now my favorite cube to work with.
 
“I took the emery board to all the little interior knobs, lips, and surfaces. Not enough to round them over or change their shape at all; just enough to micro-texture the interior locking and sliding surfaces. And it has completely transformed the feel of the cube.”​

I noticed that compared to the F-II, all the edges between interior and surface faces were sharp and square, so I took an emery board and rounded most of them over, ever so slightly.

Are the pieces rounded or not? D:
 
Are the pieces rounded or not? D:

The outer edges, where interior and exterior faces meet have been rounded over a little bit, but this is not the subject of the post, and not the thing that really changed the feel of the action. This was a first attempt which eventually led me to the the treatment I'm posting about.

The treatment is to sand the "glassy" finish off of the interior surfaces, being careful not to change the shape of the deeper inner works.

It is my opinion that the rounder shape of those outer edges did not significantly change or improve the feel of the cube. But it's hard to say for sure. I can't undo it at this point.
 
The outer edges, where interior and exterior faces meet have been rounded over a little bit, but this is not the subject of the post, and not the thing that really changed the feel of the action. This was a first attempt which eventually led me to the the treatment I'm posting about.

The treatment is to sand the "glassy" finish off of the interior surfaces, being careful not to change the shape of the deeper inner works.

It is my opinion that the rounder shape of those outer edges did not significantly change or improve the feel of the cube. But it's hard to say for sure. I can't undo it at this point.

this could make the cube lighter which can be good sometimes
 
Back
Top