I have both the 'Pre' and Re-Tooled Revenge cubes here and... well. They are exactly what you said they were - loose, locky and generally bad.
I wouldn't recommend either of them although the Pre-Tooled has much better outer layers so because those are what you will be using for the majority of the time I would say anyone would get that.
Anyway you have bought one now and I'm afraid it will stay basically the same as it is now, it may improve slightly but unfortunately neither of mine have.
I have found however that my latest retooled version has excellent inner slice movement.. and that's about it. I got it directly from Seven Towns a few weeks ago so it might have had even more alterations, and also for some reason it has the Japanese colour scheme which I don't get along with.
I just wish I could twin the inner-slice movement from the re-tooled with the outer-slice movement of the old, that would actually make it good.