A month ago I built three new type-A DIY, so I want to give my 2 cents after testing them...
I think the new type-A DIY is better than the old type-A DIY for several reasons. First and foremost it is the fastest and smoothest cube I have ever built (I build and tweak a lot of DIY cubes for friends as I have a rep for having super fast cubes). The new type-A is amazing for finger tricks and if you have good technique will really reward you with blistering cornering.
Other benefits:
1) The extra fins on the center pieces really do work... the screws can be kept very loose and the fins prevent popping while doing finger tricks. The new DIY type WILL pop, but much less often than the old DIY type... and when it does pop usually one or two pieces gently pop, instead of 2-6 pieces exploding all over the floor like the old DIY.
2) Being more hollow, the cube is lighter and gives less hand fatigue over long sessions.
There are a couple of drawbacks:
1) All the fins, and less weight mean more pieces to assemble. I use super glue to assemble them and they are a real pain in the butt. This is not a beginner's DIY kit as glue and sanding will be necessary.
2) The small washers are inferior to the old DIY and sometimes get jammed in the thread of the screws, losing the tension on that side. Care must be taken to ensure when the pieces are assembled the spring still has tension.
I took my new type-A DIY cube (assembled for 2 days) to the Toronto Open Winter '08 and one of the scramblers (a speedcuber) actually told me that I had the smoothest cube in the entire competition, and it turned corners amazingly. In the same field was a few world-class cubers (like Harris Chan) so I know the judges had some people serious about their cubes to compare mine to.
I have fully converted to the new type-A DIY cubes, and now own two and have built three.