Find the flaw in the proof

brunson

Master
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Messages
1,119
Location
Westminster, CO
WCA ID
2008BRUN01
I first read this one in middle school and didn't find the answer myself. If you know it be sure to use a spoiler tag.
  • start with: a = b
  • mutiply both sides by a: a^2 = ab
  • add a^2 to each side: 2(a^2) = a^2 + ab
  • subtract 2ab from each side: 2(a^2) - 2ab = a^2 + ab - 2ab
  • simplify the RHS using [ab - 2ab = -ab]: 2(a^2) - 2ab = a^2 - ab
  • factor out the 2 from the LHS: 2(a^2 - ab) = a^2 - ab
  • divide both sides by (a^2 - ab): 2(a^2 - ab)/(a^2 - ab) = (a^2 - ab)/(a^2 - ab)
  • reduce both sides using (a^2 - ab)/(a^2 - ab) = 1
  • final result: 2 = 1, Q.E.D. :-)
Without all the comment, because it gets a bit confusing:

a = b
a^2 = ab
2(a^2) = a^2 + ab
2(a^2) - 2ab = a^2 + ab - 2ab
2(a^2) - 2ab = a^2 - ab
2(a^2 - ab) = a^2 - ab
2(a^2 - ab)/(a^2 - ab) = (a^2 - ab)/(a^2 - ab)
2 = 1

Where is the mistake in the algebra?
 
Last edited:
this is the same as
x^2 - x^2 = x^2 - x^2
(x+x)*(x-x) = x(x-x)
x+x = x
2x = x
2 = 1
 
Find the flaw in this proof:

let x be non-0.

x+x+x... (x times) = x^2
d/dx(x+x+x...) = d/dx(x^2)
1+1+1... (x times) = 2x
x = 2x
1 = 2
 
Find the flaw in this proof:

let x be non-0.

x+x+x... (x times) = x^2
d/dx(x+x+x...) = d/dx(x^2)
1+1+1... (x times) = 2x
x = 2x
1 = 2

"x times" only applies for a positive integer x.

Because of that, taking the derivative is impossible because it isn't differentiable.
 
"x times" only applies for a positive integer x.

Because of that, taking the derivative is impossible because it isn't differentiable.

Actually, I think you may be able to apply it to non-integers. I've considered what would happen if you took, say, 1.5, 1.5 times. This may not be legitimate, but: 1.5 once is 1.5, and 1.5 the remaining .5 times is .75, so 1.5+.75 = 2.25 = 1.5^2.

In other words, to give an explicit definition for non integers:
f(x) = x+x+x... (x times)
= (x+x+x...)(floor(x) times) + (x%1)(x)
= sum(x, from 0 to floor(x)) + x(x%1).
This should even make it continuous, as it is equivalent to x^2 for every value of x, yet interestingly still non-differentiable.
 
"x times" only applies for a positive integer x.

Because of that, taking the derivative is impossible because it isn't differentiable.

Actually, I think you may be able to apply it to non-integers. I've considered what would happen if you took, say, 1.5, 1.5 times. This may not be legitimate, but: 1.5 once is 1.5, and 1.5 the remaining .5 times is .75, so 1.5+.75 = 2.25 = 1.5^2.

In other words, to give an explicit definition for non integers:
f(x) = x+x+x... (x times)
= (x+x+x...)(floor(x) times) + (x%1)(x)
= sum(x, from 0 to floor(x)) + x(x%1).
This should even make it continuous, as it is equivalent to x^2 for every value of x, yet interestingly still non-differentiable.

Hrm, x%1 nor floor(x) is continuous.
 
Here's a classic:
1 - 1 + 1 - 1 + ... = 1/2

Proof:
Let x = 1 - 1 + 1 - 1 + ...
x = 1 - x
2x = 1
x = 1/2
 
find the flaw in this one.
x = √(1/2)
2x^2 = 1
6x^2 = 3
2x^2 + 1 = 4 - 4x^2 (add x^4 to both sides)
x^4 + 2x^2 + 1 = x^4 - 4x^2 + 4
(x^2 + 1)^2 = (x^2 - 2)^2
x^2 + 1 = x^2 - 2
1 = -2
 
January has 31 days. That means that the last 28 days (4 full weeks) include 4 mondays and 4 fridays. The only 3 consecutive days on the beginning of the month that don't include monday or friday are tuesday/wednesday/thursday. So January 1 was a tuesday.
I couldn't defend my answer as rigorously you did, but I read the problem and said "Tuesday". :-)
 
find the flaw in this one.
x = √(1/2)
2x^2 = 1
6x^2 = 3
2x^2 + 1 = 4 - 4x^2 (add x^4 to both sides)
x^4 + 2x^2 + 1 = x^4 - 4x^2 + 4
(x^2 + 1)^2 = (x^2 - 2)^2
x^2 + 1 = x^2 - 2

1 = -2

'Nuff said.
 
Back
Top