• Welcome to the Speedsolving.com, home of the web's largest puzzle community!
    You are currently viewing our forum as a guest which gives you limited access to join discussions and access our other features.

    Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community of 40,000+ people from around the world today!

    If you are already a member, simply login to hide this message and begin participating in the community!

Add Team BLD event to the WCA (Proposal)

turtwig

Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2015
Messages
656
I think this would be hard to organize in a competition. The problem that seems most obvious is that teams may interfere with each other since oral communication is necessary. It may be hard to hear when many attempts are happening concurrently and hearing others' solutions would bring cheating potential (it might even just inadvertently affect the blindfolded person's state of mind - very hard to unhear something). Personally, I'm not a big fan of introducing new 3x3 variants. Team BLD seems to be quite optimized already, and the solving style is almost identical to normal 3x3 speedsolving from what I understand, as long as both teammates have names for a sufficient number of F2L and last layer cases.

Additionally, the number of people that would be able to compete at a high level would be severely limited through circumstances not their own. You would generally need a partner at or higher than your level in speedsolving ability and knowledge to reach your "full potential," and naturally it would be even harder to have record-breaking potential.
Maybe conventions would develop so that people "in the know" could partner with anyone else with knowledge of the same convention, but to me that sounds quite uninteresting on its face. This would further exacerbate the problem of people hearing others' solutions (imagine you're sitting in a waiting area and happen to (or intentionally) hear someone's solution). Additionally, it would likely still be advantageous to practice and compete with fixed partner or small group of people, for example it would be near impossible to innovate without a dedicate partner. I think we should stick with individual events only. Knowing/competing with other fast speedcubers should not be a prerequisite to becoming fast yourself and team events would essentially bar people from certain areas of the world where there are not many fast people from being competitive on the world stage. (I understand not everyone competes to become world-class, but if it's just for fun I don't see a problem with simply holding it as an unofficial event.)
 
Joined
Mar 16, 2016
Messages
269
Location
Earth
I'm pretty sure I saw a video on the cubicle's channel where two people (I think it was Rami and someone else, don't remember who) were doing team BLD solves and getting like 16 second solves, and they pointed out that it would not be a good official event because the optimal solution would just be to get two really good BLDers with the same memo words, have one person tell the memo to the other during inpsection and have the other person execute it.
 

mookiemu

Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2016
Messages
54
I'm pretty sure I saw a video on the cubicle's channel where two people (I think it was Rami and someone else, don't remember who) were doing team BLD solves and getting like 16 second solves, and they pointed out that it would not be a good official event because the optimal solution would just be to get two really good BLDers with the same memo words, have one person tell the memo to the other during inpsection and have the other person execute it.
That totally makes sense. I wonder why none of the videos I've seen do this. Every video I've seen with people doing team bld has them using CFOP or something and yelling out individual moves such as R or L and named algs like "sune" or "antisune". Why wouldn't the person looking on just call out memo words or letter pairs? The person looking on doesn't even have to be a good solver, they just have to know Speffz naming.
 
Top