4x4 internal

SpeedCubeReview

Veteran
Joined
May 25, 2014
Messages
799
Location
Michigan
WCA ID
2016BOUC01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Can someone explain why a 4x4 has so many internal parts. More specifically Why are there three pieces between the edges instead of just one? What do those extra pieces do?


Now I understand an answer could be "It makes it turn better" but I am wondering how.
 
I believe the main reason the internal parts are increased is mainly down to the overall structural integrity of the puzzle itself, being able to cope with a large amount of moving pieces at once, without changing shape, I believe if the shape of the puzzle didn't stay the same it may just 'collapse'.
 
First of all, there are several different 4x4 mechanisms, you should really clarify which one you mean. I'm going to assume you're talking about the mech used in the SS/MoYu cubes though since those are the most common these days (other cubes also have essentially the same mech in some form). I'm also going to assume you mean that there are 3 internal pieces between adjacent centre pieces (internal centre pieces that the screws go through). The reason is that it's basically a 5x5 mechanism with the middle layers hidden inside, and some form of blocking is used to make sure that this layer doesn't misalign (like the V-cube 6 does sometimes). Making the group of 3 pieces into one piece would be like making the corresponding group of 3 pieces on a 5x5 into one piece, which prevents the outer layers from turning.

Hope that helps, if that isn't what you meant, please clarify.
 
It's one of a few choices of design. I don't know if you've ever owned a Rubik's Brand 4x4, but it's a completely different mechanism. Same with the Dayan+MF8 mechanism. In those cases, all of the pieces grab onto an inner, rigid spherical contraption. No internal pieces are necessary, besides the core.

Most "modern" designs pretty much adopt the same piece structure of a 5x5. The middle layer edges/centers are simply made smaller such that they don't show from the outside, and the outer layer pieces overlap them... hence "internal". It's a system that was shown to be reliable on the 5x5, so why not adopt it for other puzzles? I think the first cube to use this sort of design was the Eastsheen 4x4. Then later on V-Cube used it for their 6x6 and patented it for their 4x4 (and all their other even number ordered puzzles, of course). The rest is history.

Edit: pretty well ninja'd by bobthegiraffemonkey.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top