New "E-Cubes" - as posted on tp forum

Last edited:
I agree with Tim pretty much.

I'm not that impressed with his designs. Seems like he just makes a bunch of complicated paths through a cube and assumes that since it is complicated it will work well. The 3x3 designs all look ridiculous honestly, I'm really skeptical of them.

I could easily be completely wrong, but until I see some real evidence that these cubes are good, I'll be skeptical.

Is it true that you have a physical version of the E-cube 5x5? Video?
 
CX3 = inspired from other 3x3s (obviously), custom designed and printed.

"ESkewb" = sanded LanLan with Anchors. You can't take another company's work, mod it and expect me to "respect" his designs.

I think being a 10 year old or female is fine. I do however find the use of a voice changer stupid. If the only printed one of his designs isn't his design, how do we know he's made other, legitimate prints?

Whatever, impossible to argue against people blindly supporting him like Womack and RJ.
Wonderful. You can see the difference between the CX3 and the E-Skewb. I see it too. Your point there is valid, the E-Skewb wasn't entirely his.

My point though was about his other designs, the ones that were fully his, compared to other speedcubes on the market. You can't take on of his designs that isn't fully his, ignore every other one, and then basically say you have no respect for him.

Well actually I guess you can since you did. Unfortunately I highly disagree with you doing so. And the way you did it.

I'm not even saying his cubes are good, blindly or not. You're essentially blindly saying he's not legitimate, then insulting him and people backing him up. That's my point.

Also you could try and be constructive. Here, I'll start. I probably overreacted a bit. I also may have misunderstood some of our meanings. I don't know you so I don't know. Maybe try not to come straight out and accuse people though. It's usually not well taken.
 
Last edited:
I agree with Tim pretty much.

I'm not that impressed with his designs. Seems like he just makes a bunch of complicated paths through a cube and assumes that since it is complicated it will work well. The 3x3 designs all look ridiculous honestly, I'm really skeptical of them.

I could easily be completely wrong, but until I see some real evidence that these cubes are good, I'll be skeptical.

Is it true that you have a physical version of the E-cube 5x5? Video?

This. I also feel he has no reason not to release an "E5" video. He already has the designs published, so if his printed one is actually good, then why not show a video?

Then again, unless he sent one to Feliks, Kevin, etc, it'd be hard to judge. I could make a V-cube 5 look better than a ShenShou in a short video.

And his comment "make a skewb better than mine blah blah". Several people have already made Skewbs with similar sanding and torpedoes. There's a youtube video showing how to make torpedoes for a Skewb.

And I'll repeat, if he is a 10 year old that made those designs I don't care, but the use of a voice changer is just stupid, if he actually was 10 (which it's unlikely) why would he hide his voice anyway?
 
I agree with Tim pretty much.

I'm not that impressed with his designs. Seems like he just makes a bunch of complicated paths through a cube and assumes that since it is complicated it will work well. The 3x3 designs all look ridiculous honestly, I'm really skeptical of them.

I could easily be completely wrong, but until I see some real evidence that these cubes are good, I'll be skeptical.

Is it true that you have a physical version of the E-cube 5x5? Video?

I agree to but I think he's showing his designs to get opinions on them make improvements and then make the physical cube.
 
This. I also feel he has no reason not to release an "E5" video. He already has the designs published, so if his printed one is actually good, then why not show a video?

Then again, unless he sent one to Feliks, Kevin, etc, it'd be hard to judge. I could make a V-cube 5 look better than a ShenShou in a short video.

And his comment "make a skewb better than mine blah blah". Several people have already made Skewbs with similar sanding and torpedoes. There's a youtube video showing how to make torpedoes for a Skewb.

And I'll repeat, if he is a 10 year old that made those designs I don't care, but the use of a voice changer is just stupid, if he actually was 10 (which it's unlikely) why would he hide his voice anyway?
I believe he said he was working on the videos. Hope he'll put them up soon so we can indeed see if they are good. Which they may or may not be, I'm not saying either one.
He also has a thread on the TP forums recently that's asking about possible testers for his designs.
I'm not going to comment on the Skewb thing.
Not sure why his fear of internet stalkers is that surprising to you. A lot of people like to be anonymous. Nothing wrong with that IMO but I guess you have a different opinion.

As Michael said as far as I can tell he's just trying to make good cubes. What would he get from hyping his cubes to heck? It's not like he's actually doing much hyping himself. He's just asking for opinions of his designs, and maybe will eventually get off the ground and start producing.
 
This. I also feel he has no reason not to release an "E5" video. He already has the designs published, so if his printed one is actually good, then why not show a video?

Then again, unless he sent one to Feliks, Kevin, etc, it'd be hard to judge. I could make a V-cube 5 look better than a ShenShou in a short video.

And his comment "make a skewb better than mine blah blah". Several people have already made Skewbs with similar sanding and torpedoes. There's a youtube video showing how to make torpedoes for a Skewb.

And I'll repeat, if he is a 10 year old that made those designs I don't care, but the use of a voice changer is just stupid, if he actually was 10 (which it's unlikely) why would he hide his voice anyway?

Just saying: His Skewb wasn't just sanding and torpedos, he said he also used springs in the edges.
What's actually impressing to me though is many of the other puzzle designs he has posted, which prove a lot of creativity and hard work. The mixup 5x5 and Curvy Copter/ Dino cube hybrid he hand made out of existing puzzles seem very cleverly made. Printing his 3D puzzles is propably not cheap, especially for a 19 years old. Let's just wait and see what video comes next.
 
I can't understand the hostility towards E-Cubes. He has posted a lot of interesting designs, both of existing puzzles and of new things that have never been done before. The CAD designs are already more than a lot of puzzle designers do. Yes, he hasn't made a ton of videos, but so what? Printing puzzles is expensive, and judging by the voice modulation thing I'm sure he has his own reasons to not want to put himself out there too much. Tim, do you expect a 19-year-old kid to have the same amount of money and confidence as Oskar van Deventer or Tony Fisher? Can't the designs stand on their own merits, and anything else (videos, IRL pictures, etc.) be a nice extra? You act like it's your sworn duty to destroy this guy's reputation, and it makes no sense.
 
I agree.

This guy has done more for the speedcubing community than most others here. We shouldn't judge him on his age, gender, voice, money, or reputation, but for his character and his contributions to our community.

It's a lot harder than you think to design puzzles at all; never mind to the complexity this guy has. I doubt that many of you could put in as much work as he has and come out with not one, not two, but at least 10-15 designs that are all different and interesting in their own ways.

And for those who think they can; go ahead and try it. The stage is yours.
 
I agree.

This guy has done more for the speedcubing community than most others here. We shouldn't judge him on his age, gender, voice, money, or reputation, but for his character and his contributions to our community.

It's a lot harder than you think to design puzzles at all; never mind to the complexity this guy has. I doubt that many of you could put in as much work as he has and come out with not one, not two, but at least 10-15 designs that are all different and interesting in their own ways.

And for those who think they can; go ahead and try it. The stage is yours.

It's not that I'm trying to say he's bad or anything, but I do want to point out that so far he has done next to nothing for the community. He just drew up some neat designs. We still have no idea if they will work well.
 
It's not that I'm trying to say he's bad or anything, but I do want to point out that so far he has done next to nothing for the community. He just drew up some neat designs. We still have no idea if they will work well.

But could you come up with the number and complexity of designs he has; regardless of whether they work?
 
Back
Top