The limits to the demensions of cubes...

Such big cubes we be very hard to handle (either because they will be too large or because the cubies will be too small), and will take days to solve. And they don't add anything new to the puzzle, all the different type of pieces are already present on the 7^3. I don't think they will ever exist (I'm already doubtful about the 11^3...)
 
An 11^3 will no longer be a cube. Not even a pillowed one. The pillowing will be so big, that it will essentially be a sphere. I don't know what size cube will exist in N years, but I think anything over 7 or so would just take too long to solve, and it wouldn't be a new challenge either.
 
ND cubes
D=demension.
N approaches infinity.
Now there are 4-D computer cubes, there will be probably 8D "real" "cubes" in 100 years.

so that would be X^N shapes.
Where X is the # of layers (approaching infinity) and N is the dimension (also approaching infinity).
This means it is so crazy that it may take several generations of people collaborating over decades to do one solve. :)
 
Last edited:
ND cubes
D=demension.
N approaches infinity.
Now there are 4-D computer cubes, there will be probably 8D "real" "cubes" in 100 years.

so that would be X^N shapes.
Where X is the # of layers (approaching infinity) and N is the dimension (also approaching infinity).
This means it is so crazy that it may take several generations of people collaborating over decades to do one solve. :)

That's quite of a look-ahead.
 
Imagine a 99x99 cube, OK?

You want to, let's say, pick up the 99x99 cube, scramble it, and solve it.

But instead, you grab a 101x101 cube.

"They look the same!", says you.
 
An 11^3 will no longer be a cube. Not even a pillowed one. The pillowing will be so big, that it will essentially be a sphere. I don't know what size cube will exist in N years, but I think anything over 7 or so would just take too long to solve, and it wouldn't be a new challenge either.

The V-cube website shows pictures of an 11x11x11 that doesn't look like it has a much different shape from the 7x7x7. Their designs are pretty complete for the 11x11x11, so I really don't think you're right about it essentially being a sphere.

And the current big cube experts would probably be able to solve an 11x11x11 in less than 20 minutes. Michael Gottlieb has solved a computer 10x10x10 in under 14 minutes. So for some people, they wouldn't take too long to solve.

As for it not being a new challenge, I suppose you're mostly right about that. I think it would be fun from a BLD perspective, keeping track of all the different slices, though.

I can't imagine anything higher then 8^3 being fun anymore :/
Why do you think an 8x8x8 would be fun, but not a 9x9x9? What's better about an 8x8x8 than a 7x7x7 or 6x6x6? (Just wondering why you draw the line there - it seems like an arbitrary place to draw the line to me.)
 
I can't imagine anything higher then 8^3 being fun anymore :/
Why do you think an 8x8x8 would be fun, but not a 9x9x9? What's better about an 8x8x8 than a 7x7x7 or 6x6x6? (Just wondering why you draw the line there - it seems like an arbitrary place to draw the line to me.)

Because you can use it as a chess board. Imagine using magnetic stickers and pieces. You can play 6 games at the same time! And do it BLD?!?
 
I can't imagine anything higher then 8^3 being fun anymore :/
Why do you think an 8x8x8 would be fun, but not a 9x9x9? What's better about an 8x8x8 than a 7x7x7 or 6x6x6? (Just wondering why you draw the line there - it seems like an arbitrary place to draw the line to me.)

Because you can use it as a chess board. Imagine using magnetic stickers and pieces. You can play 6 games at the same time! And do it BLD?!?

Oh, I forgot about the chessboard aspect. You have a point.

But if I had a 9x9x9, I could play shogi, which is my favorite variant of chess. (Sorry to the probably many Chinese chess fans who dislike shogi, but I've played both, and I personally prefer shogi - it's just personal preference.) Chinese chess would be a little more difficult, though, even on a bigger cube, due to the difference in symmetry.
 
I can't imagine anything higher then 8^3 being fun anymore :/
Why do you think an 8x8x8 would be fun, but not a 9x9x9? What's better about an 8x8x8 than a 7x7x7 or 6x6x6? (Just wondering why you draw the line there - it seems like an arbitrary place to draw the line to me.)

Because you can use it as a chess board. Imagine using magnetic stickers and pieces. You can play 6 games at the same time! And do it BLD?!?

Oh, I forgot about the chessboard aspect. You have a point.

But if I had a 9x9x9, I could play shogi, which is my favorite variant of chess. (Sorry to the probably many Chinese chess fans who dislike shogi, but I've played both, and I personally prefer shogi - it's just personal preference.) Chinese chess would be a little more difficult, though, even on a bigger cube, due to the difference in symmetry.

What do you mean?
Chinese chess can work. It will just have to be a size or 2 bigger since you play the pieces at the intersections and have to add a river. Edit: It would be a 11x11 cube for the pieces not to fall off the edge.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xiangqi
You can see the picture here.
I guess you can use tacks as the pieces, but that might damage the cube.
 
Last edited:
I can't imagine anything higher then 8^3 being fun anymore :/
Why do you think an 8x8x8 would be fun, but not a 9x9x9? What's better about an 8x8x8 than a 7x7x7 or 6x6x6? (Just wondering why you draw the line there - it seems like an arbitrary place to draw the line to me.)

Because you can use it as a chess board. Imagine using magnetic stickers and pieces. You can play 6 games at the same time! And do it BLD?!?

And your cube has to hover in the air :P.
 
What do you mean?
Chinese chess can work. It will just have to be a size or 2 bigger since you play the pieces at the intersections and have to add a river.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xiangqi
You can see the picture here.
I guess you can use tacks as the pieces, but that might damage the cube.

I was just thinking that the board would have to be off-center (since it's 9 points wide, 10 points long). You could make it off-center, but that just doesn't seem as nice to me.
 
I think the 11x11x11 will be the biggest cube that will ever be commercially available (and I too have my doubts about it ever becoming widely available)

How much would it cost for a company to develop such a puzzle and to mass-produce it? And how many people would buy one? The answer to the last question will probably be: not enough to match the answer of question one
 
When you're doing BLD and you have to count pieces by feel to make sure you're turning the right layer, I think it's getting too big. The 7x7 is already approaching that point.
 
When you're doing BLD and you have to count pieces by feel to make sure you're turning the right layer, I think it's getting too big. The 7x7 is already approaching that point.

Actually, it's really not that bad. I was surprised when Chris mentioned that he does this so carefully. It didn't take me any time at all to get used to feeling the right places to turn the 7x7x7, and I doubt it's a problem for anyone else who has played with it for any time at all. It might get tougher going higher than 7x7x7, but 6x6x6 and 7x7x7 are almost as easy to feel your way around as 5x5x5 and 4x4x4. Have you tried it? It really is surprisingly easy.
 
Why do you think an 8x8x8 would be fun, but not a 9x9x9? What's better about an 8x8x8 than a 7x7x7 or 6x6x6? (Just wondering why you draw the line there - it seems like an arbitrary place to draw the line to me.)

The difference between 6x6x6 and 8x8x8 seems pretty major to me. Making pairs of 4 compared to 6 in the centers is more difficult, but not too the point where it would just be annoying. 9x9x9 would be the same as the 8x8x8, but without PLL parity, so it'd be easier.

Plus the 8x8x8, in my opinion, would be the most realistic to try to create in any relatively short time span.
 
Back
Top