Verifying non-bluetooth cubes at Competition cube collection

abunickabhi

Legend
Joined
Jan 9, 2014
Messages
14,817
Location
Yo
WCA ID
2013GHOD01
YouTube
Visit Channel
https://forum.worldcubeassociation....th-cubes-at-competition-cube-collection/30220

This post is a bit ahead of current scenes in comps across the world.

The usage of Bluetooth cubes is not allowed as the cube state can be wirelessly relayed to an alias who can help the solver through signage. My estimates is that we do have one odd incident when a competitor in competition X submits a Bluetooth cube, unknowingly or even rarer intentionally.

I want to propose a guideline addition where the protocol for an organizer or a delegate to check for malpractices during cube submission including Bluetooth cubes. It is not trivial to know if a cube is Bluetooth unless we break open the puzzle.

With minimal overhead in checking procedure and cube collection time, what protocol do you guys think should be added if necessary to check for Bluetooth cubes in the present and in the future?
 
https://forum.worldcubeassociation....th-cubes-at-competition-cube-collection/30220

This post is a bit ahead of current scenes in comps across the world.

The usage of Bluetooth cubes is not allowed as the cube state can be wirelessly relayed to an alias who can help the solver through signage. My estimates is that we do have one odd incident when a competitor in competition X submits a Bluetooth cube, unknowingly or even rarer intentionally.

I want to propose a guideline addition where the protocol for an organizer or a delegate to check for malpractices during cube submission including Bluetooth cubes. It is not trivial to know if a cube is Bluetooth unless we break open the puzzle.

With minimal overhead in checking procedure and cube collection time, what protocol do you guys think should be added if necessary to check for Bluetooth cubes in the present and in the future?
i agree with this. but what would an alternate solution to this be? taking the suspicious cube apart?
 
I want to propose a guideline addition where the protocol for an organizer or a delegate to check for malpractices during cube submission including Bluetooth cubes. It is not trivial to know if a cube is Bluetooth unless we break open the puzzle.
You're really gonna put more work on the organizers and delegate? You're gonna make them go through every cube? God save worlds organizers and delegates.
 
You're really gonna put more work on the organizers and delegate? You're gonna make them go through every cube? God save worlds organizers and delegates.
1674057612116.png

God forbid the poor delegates wave a phone over some cubes and shake em a bit in the name of competitive integrity.
 
View attachment 21721
God forbid the poor delegates wave a phone over some cubes and shake em a bit in the name of competitive integrity.

I don’t know about you, but my airpods and brand iPhone (both equipped with top of the line bluetooth and both made by Apple, therefore more easily compatible) take like a minute to properly recognize eachother and pair up. Bluetooth cubes are far far worse and less compatible with phones (especially depending on the phone), so multiply that over every single cube and you’ve got an hour or two of work added to your competition time
 
I'm not saying that this couldn't happen, but is there any reason to believe that it is actively happening? I feel like it would be relatively easy to detect suspicious behavior from solvers exploiting this. If the WCA preemptively accounted for every possibile exploit, we'd probably be locked up in Faraday cages without any spectators around.
 
I'm not saying that this couldn't happen, but is there any reason to believe that it is actively happening? I feel like it would be relatively easy to detect suspicious behavior from solvers exploiting this. If the WCA preemptively accounted for every possibile exploit, we'd probably be locked up in Faraday cages without any spectators around.
Building robust Faraday cages for 30 venues a week is not cheap.

We won't get to that extreme, haha
 
Back
Top