YouTube is Removing Cubing Videos

Skullush

Veteran
Joined
Jun 23, 2009
Messages
677
Location
Severna Park, Maryland, USA
WCA ID
2011SAKO01
YouTube
Visit Channel
A couple of my videos, as well as many other cubing videos from various others, are being removed from YouTube on the basis of misleading information. Here's an email I got:

Hi Corey Sakowski,

One or more of your videos was removed by the YouTube team for violating our community guidelines. We removed the following videos from YouTube:

MultiBLD - 11/11, 39:54.07

Misleading descriptions, tags, titles, or thumbnails designed to increase views are not allowed. Tags should only be placed in the appropriate tag section and not in the description. It's also not okay to post large amounts of untargeted, unwanted, or repetitive content, including comments and private messages. You can watch this video to learn more about our policy and how to appeal this decision.

Please note that this removal has not resulted in a strike and once you fix the issues highlighted above you are free to reupload the video(s) listed above. Please be aware that the view count and comments from your previous upload will not carry over to the new upload.

We encourage you to review all videos in your account to make sure they are in line with our community guidelines. Additional violations could result in strikes on your account, or even lead to account termination.

- The YouTube Team

Now there wasn't really any misleading information. Our best guess is that YouTube doesn't know what scrambles are and think that it's "repetitive content," but even if that's the case, how are we going to share scrambles within the video? What about my 4BLD tutorial videos which show all the setup moves for every target? Are they grounds for removal as well?

Normally I wouldn't make a thread about this, but since this is happening to a lot of cubers and a lot of videos and it's not just an isolated incident, I wanted to bring it to the forum's attention. What's all this about?
 
Many other people have had this happen to them, with the same email from YouTube about misleading info :/ idk what's going on, I hope they don't remove my videos but this is serious
 
Has anyone tried replying to these emails or otherwise engaging with YouTube on the matter? If it's simply their misunderstanding of the kinds of videos our community is likely to produce, a heads up might help to them not delete our stuff.
 
I've also had this happen and several other people have too. ben1996123's entire channel was deleted, but he managed to get it back again. I've only had one removed so far though.
 
What kinds of videos are being deleted? While it sucks to have your videos deleted, I can understand why YouTube might remove repetitive content in the form of reviews, unboxings and home solves.
 
What kinds of videos are being deleted? While it sucks to have your videos deleted, I can understand why YouTube might remove repetitive content in the form of reviews, unboxings and home solves.

And yet "____ for 10 Hours" videos remain on youtube.

For me, it was the 11/11 and a skewb avg25 that were removed
 
Last edited:
Thanks for letting us know. I only had a few irrelevant tags on two of my videos, but I removed them. In addition, I have changed the displayed video pictures in such a way as to make the videos on my channel appear to be less repetitious.
 
Wat?! This is atrocious. Someone should alert YouTube ASAP. I've always been scared that a hacker would delete my channel or videos or something, but I never would have thought YouTube themselves would...
 
im sure that google is using somesort of software to determine whether or not a video is deserving of removal. any actual human watching an average of 12 video, even if he's not a solver, would be able to tell what's going on, and that it most obviously isnt spam content (though i cant speak for all cubers).
 
Back
Top